In Re a Lehre Minor
CourtMichigan Court of Appeals
Date FiledNovember 17, 2026
Docket379451
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
If this opinion indicates that it is “FOR PUBLICATION,” it is subject to
revision until final publication in the Michigan Appeals Reports.
STATE OF MICHIGAN
COURT OF APPEALS
UNPUBLISHED
November 17, 2026
2:12 PM
In re A. LEHRE, Minor.
No. 379451
Chippewa Circuit Court
Family Division
LC No. 25-015274-NA
Before: O’BRIEN, P.J., and CAMERON and MALDONADO, JJ.
PER CURIAM.
In this child-protective proceeding subject to the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA), 25
USC 1901, et seq., and the Michigan Indian Family Preservation Act (MIFPA), MCL 712B.1 et
seq., respondent appeals as of right the trial court order terminating his parental rights to the minor
child following the child’s disclosure that respondent sexually abused her. We affirm.
I. BACKGROUND
Respondent was arrested, and this petition was filed, after the minor child and her half-
sister both disclosed to their mother (and then later to a forensic interviewer) that respondent had
sexually assaulted them on multiple occasions. The child was removed from respondent’s care and
remained in the care of her mother. Petitioner, the Department of Health and Human Services,
sought termination of respondent’s parental rights at the initial disposition. At the preliminary
hearing, it was established that respondent and the child were both members of the Sault Ste. Marie
Native American Tribe of Chippewa Indians, that petitioner consulted with the Tribe during its
investigation, and that petitioner provided the Tribe with a copy of the petition.
The case eventually proceeded to a termination trial, at which the caseworker assigned to
the child’s case testified about her attempts to provide services to respondent while he was in jail
awaiting trial. The caseworker explained that respondent refused to meet with her at her first visit,
so she provided parenting education materials for the jail to give respondent instead. The
caseworker testified that she returned to the jail the following week, and respondent agreed to meet
with her. Little was accomplished at this meeting, however. According to the caseworker,
respondent was hostile and spent most of the meeting talking about the child’s mother and “less
-1-
on the well-being and care of his child.” The caseworker offered to continue providing educational
materials to respondent, but respondent said that “he didn’t understand what the point was.” The
caseworker nevertheless provided educational materials to the jail for respondent two more times
and met with respondent one more time, but respondent said that he was not interested in further
educational materials and left. The caseworker tried to meet with respondent three more times, and
respondent refused each time. When asked if there were services available that would address the
caseworker’s concerns with respondent, the caseworker stated that she did not believe so.
Amanda Gil, an expert witness designated by the Tribe, testified that there were no further
services available to respondent that would alleviate the risk to the child under the circumstances
of the case. She further stated that she and the Tribe were satisfied that petitioner had made active
efforts as it related to respondent and the child. She described the active efforts as collaboration
with the Tribe, services for the child’s mother, counseling for the child, attempts to engage with
respondent in the jail, parenting education, parole supervision, and drug screenings for respondent.
She also clarified that there was a “comprehensive assessment of the home environment,” family
referral services were made, and the child was kept in the custody of the mother.
Following the termination trial, the trial court terminated respondent’s parental rights. In
so doing, the court adopted the following findings:
The court finds that Petitioner has shown by clear and convincing evidence
active efforts were made to provide remedial and rehabilitative programs designed
to prevent the breakup of the Indian family, and that these efforts were
unsuccessful.
The efforts provided to respondent-father included team decision making
meetings, consultation with the Sault Tribe prior to filing a petition, case planning
with the Tribe, consultation with the Tribe regarding termination of parental rights,
law enforcement investigation, contact with respondent-father to engage in
services, parenting education materials, drug testing, parole oversight, trauma
assessment for [the child] and counseling for [the child], contact with non-
respondent parent and offer of services, and a comprehensive home evaluation. The
qualified expert witness . . . testified active efforts were provided to respondent-
father, and the efforts proved unsuccessful because respondent-father continues to
pose a risk to [the child].
This appeal followed.
II. ACTIVE EFFORTS
Respondent first argues that the trial court clearly erred when it found by clear and
convincing evidence that active efforts toward reunification had been made.
A trial court’s factual findings in support of its active-efforts finding are reviewed for clear
error, while the court’s “interpretation and application of the relevant federal and state statutory
provisions is reviewed de novo.” In re Beers, 325 Mich App 653, 680; 926 NW2d 832 (2018).
-2-
There is no dispute that the child and respondent are members of the Sault Ste. Marie Tribe,
and thus active efforts towards reunification were required. ICWA states in relevant part:
Any party seeking to effect a foster care placement of, or termination of
parental rights to, an Indian child under State law shall satisfy the court that active
efforts have been made to provide remedial services and rehabilitative programs
designed to prevent the breakup of the Indian family and that these efforts have
proved unsuccessful. [25 USC 1912(d).]
And MIFPA provides in pertinent part:
(2) An Indian child may be removed from a parent or Indian custodian,
placed into a foster care placement, or, for an Indian child already taken into
protective custody, remain removed from a parent or Indian custodian pending
further proceedings, only upon clear and convincing evidence that active efforts
have been made to provide remedial services and rehabilitative programs designed
to prevent the breakup of the Indian family, that the active efforts were
unsuccessful, and that the continued custody of the Indian child by the parent or
Indian custodian is likely to result in serious emotional or physical damage to the
Indian child. The active efforts must take into account the prevailing social and
cultural conditions and way of life of the Indian child’s tribe. The evidence must
include the testimony of at least 1 qualified expert witness, who has knowledge of
the child rearing practices of the Indian child’s tribe, that the continued custody of
the Indian child by the parent or Indian custodian is likely to result in serious
emotional or physical damage to the Indian child.
(3) A party seeking a termination of parental rights to an Indian child under
state law must demonstrate to the court’s satisfaction that active efforts have been
made to provide remedial services and rehabilitative programs designed to prevent
the breakup of the Indian family and that the active efforts were unsuccessful.
[MCL 712B.15(2).]
MIFPA defines active efforts as follows:
(a) “Active efforts” means actions to provide remedial services and
rehabilitative programs designed to prevent the breakup of the Indian family and to
reunify the Indian child with the Indian family. Active efforts require more than a
referral to a service without actively engaging the Indian child and family. Active
efforts include reasonable efforts as required by title IV-E of the social security act,
42 USC 670 to 679c, and also include, but are not limited to, doing or addressing
all of the following:
(i) Engaging the Indian child, child’s parents, tribe, extended family
members, and individual Indian caregivers through the utilization of culturally
appropriate services and in collaboration with the parent or child’s Indian tribes and
Indian social services agencies.
-3-
(ii) Identifying appropriate services and helping the parents to overcome
barriers to compliance with those services.
(iii) Conducting or causing to be conducted a diligent search for extended
family members for placement.
(iv) Requesting representatives designated by the Indian child’s tribe with
substantial knowledge of the prevailing social and cultural standards and child
rearing practice within the tribal community to evaluate the circumstances of the
Indian child’s family and to assist in developing a case plan that uses the resources
of the Indian tribe and Indian community, including traditional and customary
support, actions, and services, to address those circumstances.
(v) Completing a comprehensive assessment of the situation of the Indian
child’s family, including a determination of the likelihood of protecting the Indian
child’s health, safety, and welfare effectively in the Indian child’s home.
(vi) Identifying, notifying, and inviting representatives of the Indian child’s
tribe to participate in all aspects of the Indian child custody proceeding at the
earliest possible point in the proceeding and actively soliciting the tribe’s advice
throughout the proceeding.
(vii) Notifying and consulting with extended family members of the Indian
child, including extended family members who were identified by the Indian child’s
tribe or parents, to identify and to provide family structure and support for the
Indian child, to assure cultural connections, and to serve as placement resources for
the Indian child.
(viii) Making arrangements to provide natural and family interaction in the
most natural setting that can ensure the Indian child’s safety, as appropriate to the
goals of the Indian child’s permanency plan, including, when requested by the tribe,
arrangements for transportation and other assistance to enable family members to
participate in that interaction.
(ix) Offering and employing all available family preservation strategies and
requesting the involvement of the Indian child’s tribe to identify those strategies
and to ensure that those strategies are culturally appropriate to the Indian child’s
tribe.
(x) Identifying community resources offering housing, financial, and
transportation assistance and in-home support services, in-home intensive
treatment services, community support services, and specialized services for
members of the Indian child’s family with special needs, and providing information
about those resources to the Indian child’s family, and actively assisting the Indian
child’s family or offering active assistance in accessing those resources.
(xi) Monitoring client progress and client participation in services.
-4-
(xii) Providing a consideration of alternative ways of addressing the needs
of the Indian child’s family, if services do not exist or if existing services are not
available to the family. [MCL 712B.3(a)(i) to (xii). See also 25 CFR 23.2 (defining
“active efforts” for purposes of ICWA).]
Petitioner here collaborated closely with the Tribe by reaching out to it about the petition
and inviting it to intervene in the case. As the trial court found and the evidence confirmed,
petitioner provided respondent with parenting materials in jail and monitored respondent’s
progress and participation in the services, even after respondent rebuffed petitioner’s efforts
multiple times. Petitioner also completed a comprehensive investigation of the home environment,
identified the child’s mother as an acceptable placement for the child, and provided services and
resources to the mother. Gil confirmed that these efforts were culturally appropriate under the
circumstances and opined that they satisfied the active-efforts requirement.
Respondent dismisses petitioner’s repeated attempts to meet with respondent in jail,
claiming that such actions “are not synonymous with active efforts.” That is curious because
respondent contends that, to satisfy the active-efforts requirement, petitioner should have provided
respondent with “rehabilitative programming tailored to Respondent’s incarceration,” which is
precisely what petitioner did by repeatedly trying to meet with respondent in jail. Respondent also
claims that there was “little evidence that alternative services were explored after traditional
reunification services were deemed inappropriate,” but petitioner’s repeated efforts to meet with
respondent in jail and provide him with services there were alternate services. The problem
throughout this case was that respondent resisted petitioner’s efforts and did not cooperate or
benefit from the services that petitioner provided him.
Considering the affirmative services that petitioner provided to respondent, petitioner’s
collaboration with the Tribe, and Gil’s testimony that, in her expert opinion, the services provided
amounted to active efforts to prevent the breakup of an Indian family, there is simply no basis to
conclude that the trial court clearly erred when it found by clear and convincing evidence that
petitioner had made active efforts to prevent the breakup of the family.
III. INEFFECTIVE ASSISTANCE OF COUNSEL
Respondent also argues that he was denied his constitutional right to the effective
assistance of counsel because his trial counsel never visited respondent in jail, thus depriving him
of a meaningful opportunity to participate in his defense.1
A respondent in child-protective proceedings is entitled to the effective assistance of
counsel, just as a defendant in a criminal proceeding is. See In re MJC, 349 Mich App 42, 58-59;
27 NW3d 122 (2023); In re Casto, 344 Mich App 590, 611; 2 NW3d 102 (2022). To establish that
trial counsel was ineffective, a respondent must show “that (1) counsel’s performance was
deficient, falling below an objective standard of reasonableness, and that (2) the deficient
1
No evidentiary hearing was held in this case, so our review of respondent’s ineffective-assistance
claim “is limited to mistakes apparent on the record.” In re LT, 342 Mich App 126, 133; 992 NW2d
903 (2022) (quotation marks and citation omitted).
-5-
performance prejudiced the respondent.” In re Martin, 316 Mich App 73, 85; 896 NW2d 452
(2016). The party claiming ineffective assistance has the burden of establishing the factual
predicate of their claim. People v Hoag, 460 Mich 1, 6; 594 NW2d 57 (1999).
In this case, respondent has not met that burden—nothing in the record supports
respondent’s assertion that his trial counsel did not visit him in jail. But even accepting that as true
and assuming that it constitutes deficient performance, respondent does not identify how he was
prejudiced. Respondent’s trial counsel defended respondent’s case at every relevant juncture,
effectively questioned and cross-examined witnesses, successfully moved the court to fund an
expert witness on respondent’s behalf, and moved to adjourn the case pending the result of
respondent’s criminal case. The record also shows that respondent’s trial counsel at least twice
consulted with respondent during hearings in these proceedings, and respondent never raised any
concern about his attorney’s communication until this appeal. Equally fatal to respondent’s claim,
he fails to identify any alternative trial strategy or error that his trial counsel made during the
proceeding that would have changed the outcome. Respondent contends that he cannot say “what
information, concerns, strategic decisions, or potential avenues of defense may have been
developed through meaningful consultation,” but that is what he must do to sustain his ineffective-
assistance claim. Because respondent all but admits that he cannot identify how the outcome of his
case would have been different had his trial counsel consulted with him while he was in jail, he
cannot establish his claim of ineffective assistance of counsel.
Affirmed.
/s/ Colleen A. O’Brien
/s/ Thomas C. Cameron
/s/ Allie Greenleaf Maldonado
-6-