T.A. v. New Jersey Department of Children and Families
CourtNew Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division
Date FiledNovember 16, 2026
DocketA-1921-24
StatusUnpublished
๐ฐ News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
RECORD IMPOUNDED
NOT FOR PUBLICATION WITHOUT THE
APPROVAL OF THE APPELLATE DIVISION
This opinion shall not "constitute precedent or be binding upon any court ." Although it is posted on the
internet, this opinion is binding only on the parties in the case and its use in other cases is limited. R. 1:36-3.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
APPELLATE DIVISION
DOCKET NO. A-1921-24
T.A., 1
Plaintiff-Appellant,
v.
STATE OF NEW JERSEY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILIES,
Defendant-Respondent.
__________________________
Submitted November 5, 2026 โ Decided November 16, 2026
Before Judges Mawla and Chase.
On appeal from the New Jersey Department of Children
and Families, Division of Child Protection and
Permanency, Case ID No. 17417931.
T.A., self-represented appellant.
1
We use initials pursuant to Rule 1:38-3(d)(12).
Jennifer Davenport, Attorney General, attorney for
respondent (Sookie Bae-Park, Assistant Attorney
General, of counsel; Mary L. Harpster, Deputy
Attorney General, on the brief).
PER CURIAM
Appellant T.A. challenges a July 15, 2025 final agency decision by
respondent New Jersey Department of Children and Families, finding an
allegation of neglect of her son Z.B.-T. was not established. We affirm.
The police have responded to T.A.'s home, which she shares with Z.B.-
T.'s fatherโF.B.-T.โfor prior domestic violence incidents. There have been two
prior referrals to the Division of Child Protection and Permanency (Division).
One referral involved an incident where T.A. allegedly threw objects at a wall,
damaged a door, and accused F.B.-T. of hitting Z.B.-T., which following an
investigation, also resulted in a not established finding. In the second referral,
T.A. accused her father of physical abuse. This referral was deemed unfounded.
The incident, which underlies this appeal, happened when Z.B.-T. was six
years old. F.B.-T. contacted the Division to report a domestic violence incident
between him and T.A. in Z.B.-T.'s presence. F.B.-T. alleged, during an
argument with T.A., he went back to his room to play video games, she followed
him, and threw a controller and glass items at him with Z.B.-T. in the room.
A-1921-24
2
One of the glass items shattered. The police were called but made no official
report.
Two days after the incident, a Division investigator spoke with Z.B.-T.,
who reported F.B.-T. came into the kitchen and asked him to move out of the
way and "out of nowhere" T.A. began yelling at F.B.-T. Z.B.-T. and F.B.-T.
then went into F.B.-T.'s room to play video games and T.A. kicked in the door
and threw a glass at F.B.-T. The glass did not hit anyone, and according to the
investigator, Z.B.-T. stated he did not fear his parents and interacted with them
without fear.
T.A. told the investigator she broke the bedroom door down and threw a
glass at F.B.-T. because she did not like how he told Z.B.-T. to move out of the
way. She conceded Z.B.-T. was present and saw her throw the glass. F.B.-T.
reported the same facts to the investigator. The investigator saw holes in the
wall in F.B.-T.'s bedroom.
The Division sent T.A. a letter advising its initial determination was the
alleged neglect was not established. Although there was no evidence Z.B.-T.
had been abused or neglected, there was "some credible evidence" her conduct
had harmed him or placed him at risk of harm. The letter advised T.A. she could
A-1921-24
3
supplement the record if she had other information she wanted the Division to
consider.
T.A. did not supplement the record and instead appealed from the initial
determination, claiming it did not accurately document the underlying incident.
The investigator met with T.A., who advised she did not dispute the finding, but
disagreed with the implication she made the holes in the walls. T.A. provided a
written statement with her version of the incident. For the first time, she claimed
F.B.-T. used profanity; threatened to push Z.B.-T. over, and threatened to harm
her if she objected. She admitted throwing a glass of water on the ground in the
kitchen and knocking items off F.B.-T.'s desk but denied entering his room or
putting holes in its wall. F.B.-T. gave the investigator a written statement
claiming he, not T.A., made the holes in the wall.
Although the Division revised the description of the events, accounting
for the supplemental information, it declined to change the not-established
finding. This was because the new information did not change the initial
determination the parties had a contentious relationship, which placed Z.B.-T.
at risk of harm. The Division also noted the contradictory stories T.A. and F.B.-
T. had given the first and second time they met the investigator.
I.
A-1921-24
4
T.A. argues the July 15, 2025 decision is arbitrary and capricious because
it was based on inaccurate facts and ignored the relevant evidence in the record.
She contends she provided the investigator with a "complete account" of the
underlying incident, yet the Division failed to correct its findings and instead
painted her as the aggressor, relying on facts unsupported by the record. T.A.
points to the statement F.B.-T. sent the investigator, which further confirmed
the Division's "narrative was inaccurate." She claims the Division's reference
to holes in the wall and its improper characterization of T.A. as the instigator by
claiming she "became violent," "punched and kicked the door," and "threw a
glass at a wall," along with references to "holes in the wall" contradict the record
evidence.
T.A. contends the evidence supports her version of the facts. Not only did
F.B.-T. use profanity and threaten to push Z.B.-T. out of the way, but the
evidence also shows when T.A. intervened to protect Z.B.-T., F.B.-T. threatened
her. According to T.A., these threats elicited "brief reactive conduct" from her.
T.A. also claims there was video footage of the incident, which corroborated her
account, that the Division had access to.
T.A. argues she is harmed by the Division's mistaken characterization of
her as the aggressor because it will be used against her if there are future
A-1921-24
5
referrals as well as in background checks and "collateral assessments." This
information will adversely impact her interactions with "healthcare providers,
schools, and courts," and may also "influence future risk assessments, custody
determinations, service referrals, and investigative screenings." T.A. urges us
to vacate the Division's decision and direct the Division to amend its factual
findings in the interest of justice.
II.
Our review of an administrative agency's final decision is limited.
Kadonsky v. Lee, 452 N.J. Super. 198, 201-02 (App. Div. 2017) (citing In re
Stallworth, 208 N.J. 182, 194 (2011)). "An agency's determination on the merits
'will be sustained unless there is a clear showing that it is arbitrary, capricious,
or unreasonable, or that it lacks fair support in the record.'" Saccone v. Bd. of
Trs., Police & Firemen's Ret. Sys., 219 N.J. 369, 380 (2014) (quoting Russo v.
Bd. of Trs., Police & Firemen's Ret. Sys., 206 N.J. 14, 27 (2011)). The party
challenging the administrative action bears the burden of making that showing.
Lavezzi v. State, 219 N.J. 163, 171 (2014).
A not-established finding requires some credible evidence a child was
placed at risk of harm by the acts or omissions of their parent. S.C. v. N.J. Dep't
of Child. & Families, 242 N.J. 201, 239 (2020); N.J. Dep't of Child. & Families
A-1921-24
6
v. R.R., 454 N.J. Super. 37, 47 (App. Div. 2018). A parent who is the target of
an investigation is accorded due process through: "(1) meaningful notice of the
[Division]'s planned investigatory conclusion of a 'not established' finding and
(2) affording the investigated subject an informal opportunity to be heard by the
agency before the investigatory finding is finalized." S.C., 242 N.J. at 238.
There should be a summary of the findings and the Division's reasoning, and the
parent "must be informed of [their] opportunity to rebut [the] Division's
conclusion or supplement the record." Id. at 238-39.
A not-established finding is investigatory rather than adjudicatory in
nature and involves no "determination of . . . accuracy." Id. at 232-33 (quoting
In re R.P., 333 N.J. Super. 105, 117 (App. Div. 2000)). This is because the
Division "has not adjudicated facts or reached any sort of conclusion about what
actually occurred when it applies a 'not established' finding; rather it merely
ascribes what functions as a working label to the evidence collected through
investigation." Id. at 235.
Having considered T.A.'s arguments in light of the record and the law, we
discern no evidence the Division acted in an arbitrary, capricious, or
unreasonable manner. The credible evidence in the record was collected by the
investigator who reported in detail three interviews with the family. These
A-1921-24
7
statements were not only contemporaneously reported, but also consistent with
each other.
The fact T.A. later supplemented the record with allegedly contradictory
evidence did not mandate the Division to modify its conclusion. Contrary to
T.A.'s assertions, there is no proof she showed the investigator a video of the
incident and no video evidence is in the record. The totality of the
circumstances, including T.A. and F.B.-T.'s prior history of domestic violence
and Division involvement, police involvement, and overall contentious
relationship lent more credence to the facts the Division relied upon than T.A.'s
after-the-fact supplementation. The balance of T.A.'s arguments not addressed
in this opinion lack sufficient merit to warrant discussion in a written opinion.
R. 2:11-3(e)(1)(E).
Affirmed.
A-1921-24
8