Charlotte R. Sinclair v. Brandon K. Sinclair
CourtCourt of Appeals of Washington
Date FiledNovember 19, 2026
Docket41784-1
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
FILED
NOVEMBER 19, 2026
In the Office of the Clerk of Court
WA State Court of Appeals, Division III
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON
DIVISION THREE
CHARLOTTE R. SINCLAIR, )
) No. 41784-1-III
Respondent, )
)
v. )
)
BRANDON K. SINCLAIR, ) UNPUBLISHED OPINION
)
Appellant. )
COONEY, A.C.J. — Brandon Sinclair appeals the superior court’s renewal of a
domestic violence protection order restraining him from contacting his estranged wife,
Charlotte Sinclair, and their two children. We affirm.
BACKGROUND
Charlotte and Brandon 1 were married and have two minor children together. The
parties separated, and their divorce proceeding remains pending. On December 9, 2024,
1
We refer to the parties by their first names for clarity. No disrespect is intended.
No. 41784-1-III
Sinclair v. Sinclair
the court entered a one-year domestic violence protection order against Brandon
protecting Charlotte and both children. The court later modified the order to permit
supervised visitation between Brandon and the children. Subsequent modifications
authorized the parties to communicate through OurFamilyWizard about the children and
other parenting matters, including travel and expenses. Charlotte relocated with the
children to North Carolina, and an order modifying the protection order in light of the
relocation was entered on June 30, 2025.
On November 24, Charlotte moved to renew the protection order before its
expiration on December 9. Charlotte asserted that Brandon continued to minimize the
prior domestic violence and had not accepted accountability for his conduct. She
described an incident that occurred in July 2024 during which Brandon held a gun to his
head and threw her cell phone when she tried calling for help. She also alleged that
Brandon tackled her to the ground outside their home in September 2024.
Charlotte alleged that Brandon violated the abstinence requirements of his
treatment program by purchasing cannabis in March and April 2025. She further asserted
that Brandon continued to violate the protection order and cited an arrest in November
2024 for multiple counts of residential burglary and violation of the order. Charlotte
alleged that Brandon purchased a “burner phone” and called her 11 times before the
parties’ mediation on May 29, 2025. Clerk’s Papers (CP) at 40. She stated that she
confirmed Brandon’s identity during one of the calls and that he called again on June 2,
2
No. 41784-1-III
Sinclair v. Sinclair
2025. Charlotte reported these calls to law enforcement, which resulted in two police
reports.
Charlotte also stated she overheard Brandon tell the children during a FaceTime
call that he needed to speak with her directly. She feared that direct contact would allow
Brandon to manipulate or coerce her into resuming their relationship. Charlotte stated
that she did not feel safe around Brandon and feared unwanted contact, stalking, and
physical harm.
Charlotte submitted a forensic psychological evaluation of Brandon completed by
Dr. Jameson Lontz on January 16, 2025. Dr. Lontz recommended, among other things,
that Brandon complete domestic violence programming, anger management, and
psychotherapy. Charlotte stated the evaluation echoed concerns she also had about
Brandon’s need for control and lack of accountability for domestic violence.
In response to the renewal motion, Brandon filed a declaration that asserted he
completed the psychological evaluation and complied with its recommendations. He
stated that treatment helped him recognize patterns of control he exerted in relationships
and manage emotional distress without impulsive and harmful reactions. Brandon
acknowledged that some conduct during the marriage was unacceptable and accepted
responsibility for his prior actions. After 26 sessions, discharge notes from his domestic
violence programming assessed his current risk level and risk of harm as low. The notes
further reported no identified risk factors and “meaningful progress in emotional
3
No. 41784-1-III
Sinclair v. Sinclair
regulation, accountability, and risk reduction.” CP at 160. Brandon also submitted a
letter from his therapeutic provider that stated the provider observed no indication that
Brandon posed a danger to himself or others.
Brandon denied that he sought to resume a relationship with Charlotte and stated
that he wanted contact only for co-parenting purposes. He also stated that no criminal
charges had been filed in connection with the alleged violations of the protection order in
May 2025. Brandon further requested that the court exclude the children from the
renewed protection order if it granted Charlotte’s motion.
In reply, Charlotte stated that Brandon did not respond to her OurFamilyWizard
message regarding one child’s alleged pattern of dishonesty. She claimed that the
children returned from time alone with Brandon confused and disrespectful. Charlotte
reported that the children said Brandon called her a liar, accused her of stealing money,
and stated that he wanted to kill himself. She also reported that Brandon told the children
that Charlotte could not remarry. Charlotte enrolled the children in therapy due to these
alleged “inappropriate interaction[s].” CP at 72.
The court held a renewal hearing on December 11, 2025, and recognized Brandon
bore the burden of proving a substantial change in circumstances. The court stated that it
had reviewed the parties’ submissions and the 2024 record. The court renewed the
protection order through December 11, 2026, and concluded the governing statute
constrained its discretion.
4
No. 41784-1-III
Sinclair v. Sinclair
When Brandon’s counsel sought clarification regarding the court’s determination
that Brandon had not shown a substantial change in circumstances, the court directed
counsel to RCW 7.105.405(6)(e), (f), and (g). The court recognized that the statute
prohibited it from denying renewal based on Charlotte’s ability to seek relief in another
proceeding, the passage of time since the conduct giving rise to the original order, or the
parties now living in two different states. When pressed by counsel about the court’s
authority to renew the order, the court responded that it relied on RCW 7.105.405(5), (6),
and (7).
Brandon timely appeals.
ANALYSIS
We review a trial court’s order renewing a domestic violence protection order for
abuse of discretion. In re Dom. Viol. Prot. Ord. of Hudon, 35 Wn. App. 2d 653, 656, 577
P.3d 944 (2025). There is an abuse of discretion where the court’s decision is based on
untenable grounds or untenable reasons. Rodriguez v. Zavala, 188 Wn.2d 586, 598, 398
P.3d 1071 (2017). “A decision is based ‘on untenable grounds’ or made ‘for untenable
reasons’ if it rests on facts unsupported in the record or was reached by applying the
wrong legal standard.” State v. Rohrich, 149 Wn.2d 647, 654, 71 P.3d 638 (2003)
(quoting State v. Rundquist, 79 Wn. App. 786, 793, 905 P.2d 922 (1995)). Issues
involving statutory interpretation are reviewed de novo to give effect to the legislative
5
No. 41784-1-III
Sinclair v. Sinclair
intent. Rodriguez, 188 Wn.2d at 591. “Plain language that is not ambiguous does not
require construction.” Id.
We review the trial court’s factual findings for substantial evidence. In re
Marriage of Rockwell, 141 Wn. App. 235, 242, 170 P.3d 572 (2007). Substantial
evidence exists to support a finding of fact if the record contains sufficient evidence to
persuade a fair-minded, rational person of the truth of the determination. Bering v.
SHARE, 106 Wn.2d 212, 220, 721 P.2d 918 (1986). We do not reweigh evidence or
determine credibility. Id. We defer to the trial court’s decisions on the weight of the
evidence, credibility of the witnesses, and conflicting evidence. Snyder v. Haynes, 152
Wn. App. 774, 779, 217 P.3d 787 (2009). A finding may still be supported by substantial
evidence even where the evidence is conflicting. Merriman v. Cokeley, 168 Wn.2d 627,
631, 230 P.3d 162 (2010). Unchallenged findings of fact are verities on appeal. In re
Marriage of Rounds, 4 Wn. App. 2d 801, 804, 423 P.3d 895 (2018).
Under RCW 7.105.405(4)(a), the court must grant a motion to renew a
protection order unless the respondent proves, by a preponderance of the evidence, both
that (1) there has been a substantial change in circumstances, and (2) the respondent will
not resume acts of domestic violence when the order expires. In assessing whether a
substantial change in circumstances has occurred, the trial court may—but is not required
to—consider the nonexclusive, unweighted factors listed in RCW 7.105.405(5). In
6
No. 41784-1-III
Sinclair v. Sinclair
addition, RCW 7.105.405(6) provides that the court may not deny a motion to renew a
protection order on the ground that:
(e) The relief sought by the petitioner may be available in a different
action or proceeding;
(f) The passage of time since the last incident of conduct giving rise
to the issuance of the protection order; or
(g) The respondent no longer lives near the petitioner.
Brandon argues the trial court abused its discretion by (1) misapplying RCW
7.105.405(4)(a) and failing to analyze both prongs of the statute before concluding he did
not carry his burden to show a substantial change in circumstances, and (2) misapplying
RCW 7.105.405(6)(e), (f), and (g). 2 Charlotte responds that the trial court acted within
its discretion because Brandon failed to prove both a substantial change in circumstances
and that he would not resume acts of domestic violence when the order expired.
Charlotte further argues that RCW 7.105.405(6) is not sundered from the rest of the
statute and merely identifies grounds that, standing alone, cannot support denial of
renewal.
The trial court did not abuse its discretion. The record shows the court correctly
applied RCW 7.105.405(4) and its failure to make findings under RCW 7.105.405(4)(a)
2
Brandon also contends the trial court improperly conflated RCW 7.105.100(a)
with the renewal statute, RCW 7.105.405. We disagree. Although the parties and the
court discussed the standards applicable to an initial order, the court expressly cited
RCW 7.105.405 as the authority for renewing the protection order.
7
No. 41784-1-III
Sinclair v. Sinclair
is inconsequential. RCW 7.105.405(4)(a) mandates renewal unless the respondent proves
both a substantial change in circumstances and that they will not resume acts of domestic
violence. RCW 7.105.405(5) provides, in relevant part:
In determining whether there has been a substantial change in
circumstances, the court may consider the following unweighted factors,
and no inference is to be drawn from the order in which the factors are
listed:
....
(b) Whether the respondent has violated the terms of the protection
order and the time that has passed since the entry of the order;
(c) Whether the respondent has exhibited suicidal ideation or
attempts since the protection order was entered;
....
(f) Whether the respondent has a continuing involvement with drug
or alcohol abuse, if such abuse was a factor in the protection order;
and
Here, the court cited RCW 7.105.405(5) as the primary basis for concluding
Brandon failed to show a substantial change in circumstances. Substantial evidence
supports that determination, including evidence that Brandon violated the protection
order by repeatedly calling Charlotte from a “burner phone,” made statements of suicidal
ideation to the children, and continued using cannabis in violation of his domestic
violence treatment requirements. CP at 40. On appeal, this court does not reweigh the
evidence, assess witness credibility, or resolve conflicting evidence. Snyder, 152 Wn.
App. at 779.
8
No. 41784-1-III
Sinclair v. Sinclair
Brandon bore the burden to prove both elements under RCW 7.105.405(4)(a).
Because he failed to carry his burden on the first element—substantial change in
circumstances—the trial court did not err by declining to make findings on the second
element.
The record also shows that the court correctly applied RCW 7.105.405(6). In
granting renewal, the court observed that RCW 7.105.405(6) provides the court “shall not
deny a motion to renew a protection order for any of the following reasons.” CP at 106.
The court specifically noted which subsections it was considering in granting renewal:
subsection (e) (that the relief sought may be available in a different proceeding),
subsection (f) (the passage of time since the last incident of conduct giving rise to the
issuance of the protection order), and subsection (g) (that the parties no longer live near
one another).
The record shows the court considered RCW 7.105.405(6), but it did not treat
those provisions as dispositive or as requiring automatic renewal, contrary to Brandon’s
claims. Rather, the court expressly stated it was relying on RCW 7.105.405(5), (6), and
(7) in granting the motion. In other words, the court did not blanketly conclude that the
availability of relief in dissolution proceedings, the passage of time, or Charlotte’s move
to North Carolina compelled renewal. The court considered those facts within the
statutory framework and applied the statute as written. Because the court’s ruling rests
9
No. 41784-1-III
Sinclair v. Sinclair
on tenable grounds and reflects a proper application of RCW 7.105.405, it did not abuse
its discretion.
Affirmed.
A majority of the panel has determined this opinion will not be printed in
the Washington Appellate Reports, but it will be filed for public record pursuant to
RCW 2.06.040.
Cooney, A.C.J.
WE CONCUR:
Lawrence-Berrey, J.
Murphy, J.
10