Full Opinion

Case: 26-1549 Document: 35 Page: 1 Filed: 11/20/2026 NOTE: This disposition is nonprecedential. United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit ______________________ MOHAMMAD KHAGHANI, Petitioner v. DEPARTMENT OF THE NAVY, Respondent ______________________ 2026-1549 ______________________ Petition for review of the Merit Systems Protection Board in No. AT-1221-23-0644-W-1. ______________________ Decided: November 20, 2026 ______________________ MOHAMMAD KHAGHANI, Mandeville, LA, pro se. AN HOANG, Commercial Litigation Branch, Civil Divi- sion, United States Department of Justice, Washington, DC, for respondent. Also represented by ELIZABETH MARIE HOSFORD, PATRICIA M. MCCARTHY, BRETT SHUMATE. ______________________ Before DYK, CHEN, and CUNNINGHAM, Circuit Judges. PER CURIAM. Case: 26-1549 Document: 35 Page: 2 Filed: 11/20/2026 2 KHAGHANI v. NAVY Mohammad Khaghani petitions for review of a final or- der of the Merit Systems Protection Board (Board) denying his request for corrective action relating to alleged retalia- tion for protected activity by his employer, the Department of the Navy (Department). Khaghani v. Dep’t of the Navy, No. AT-1221-23-0644-W-1, 2024 WL 4581031 (M.S.P.B. Oct. 15, 2024) (Decision). 1 For the reasons discussed below, we affirm. BACKGROUND Mr. Khaghani is an electronics engineer employed by the Department at the Naval Oceanographic Office located at the Stennis Space Center, Bay St. Louis, Mississippi. During his employment, Mr. Khaghani made eight commu- nications that he later alleged were protected disclosures. The alleged disclosures are as follows: 1) Mr. Khaghani alleged that in August 2019, he dis- closed an operational security (OPSEC) violation by Rebecca Martinolich, who was acting as a Senior Naval Oceanographic Office Representative (SNR). Mr. Kha- ghani stated that Ms. Martinolich allowed foreign na- tionals, who did not have clearance, access to a Navy ship’s computer systems and networks and to secure spaces on the ship. 2) Mr. Khaghani alleged that in 2019, he disclosed a violation of law and gross waste of funds when he be- lieved there were financial irregularities with respect to a vendor contract. He alleged that it was “strange” that the same item was purchased for different amounts across different years. Id. at 9. 1 Because the online version of the Initial Decision lacks pagination, we use the pagination employed in the Board’s original document. For example, “Decision, 2024 WL 4581031, at 1” corresponds to the first page of the de- cision, located at Appendix page 8. Case: 26-1549 Document: 35 Page: 3 Filed: 11/20/2026 KHAGHANI v. NAVY 3 3) Mr. Khaghani alleged that in 2019 and 2020, he dis- closed violations of law, gross mismanagement, and abuse of authority after he felt retaliated against for having made protected disclosures. 4) Mr. Khaghani alleged that in the summer of 2021, he disclosed violations of laws and rules, gross waste of funds, and abuse of authority when he reported that Naser El Abed, who was acting as SNR on a field as- signment, was committing time and attendance (T&A) fraud and OPSEC violations. Regarding the alleged OPSEC violation, Mr. Khaghani testified that he saw classified items left in an unsecured box. 5) Mr. Khaghani alleged that in August 2021, he dis- closed a violation of law, gross mismanagement, and abuse of authority when he reported that he attended a meeting where he was subjected to abusive, berating, and degrading treatment in retaliation for previously disclosing others’ wrongdoings. 6) Mr. Khaghani alleged that in January 2022, he again disclosed that Mr. El Abed committed T&A fraud and OPSEC violations related to the events in Disclo- sure 4. He also alleged that he reported one of his su- pervisors for retaliating against him for previously making protected disclosures. 7) Mr. Khaghani alleged that in April 2022, he dis- closed that his supervisors were retaliating against him for his prior protected disclosures by denying him permission to proceed with SNR training. 8) Mr. Khaghani alleged that in 2022, he disclosed that the same foreign nationals in Disclosure 1 were again allowed unauthorized access to the shipboard computer systems and networks. In August 2022, Mr. Khaghani filed a complaint with the Office of Special Counsel (OSC) alleging that the De- partment retaliated against him for making protected dis- closures when it did not select him for two positions, denied Case: 26-1549 Document: 35 Page: 4 Filed: 11/20/2026 4 KHAGHANI v. NAVY him permission to continue SNR training, and subjected him to a significant change in duties, responsibilities, or working conditions. Decision, 2024 WL 4581031, at 2. In June 2023, OSC informed Mr. Khaghani that it had termi- nated its inquiry into his allegations. Id. In August 2023, Mr. Khaghani filed an individual right of action (IRA) appeal with the Board repeating his allega- tions of retaliation for protected whistleblower disclosures and/or activity. The administrative judge (AJ) determined that Mr. Khaghani made non-frivolous allegations that he made protected disclosures. Id. at 3. In March 2024, the AJ conducted the hearing requested by Mr. Khaghani. Id. The AJ issued an initial decision denying Mr. Kha- ghani’s request for corrective action. The AJ found that Mr. Khaghani failed to make a prima facie case of whistle- blower retaliation for the majority of his claims, as he failed to establish that he had made protected disclosures. See id. at 8, 13–14, 18, 25, 31. But the AJ found that Mr. Kha- ghani established that he made two protected disclosures: (1) the OPSEC violation from classified items left outside secure containers (Disclosure 4) 2; and (2) foreign nationals having access to shipboard computer systems and net- works (Disclosure 8). See id. at 21, 27, 33. The AJ also found that Mr. Khaghani’s two protected disclosures qual- ified as contributing factors in the alleged personnel ac- tions under the “knowledge-timing test.” 3 2 The AJ also found that to the extent that Mr. Kha- ghani’s Disclosure 6 alleged the OPSEC violation described in Disclosure 4, the disclosure was protected. However, the AJ found that the remainder of his disclosures in this in- stance were not protected. Decision, 2024 WL 4581031, at 27. 3 The AJ notes, “The knowledge-timing test allows an appellant to demonstrate that the disclosure was a con- Case: 26-1549 Document: 35 Page: 5 Filed: 11/20/2026 KHAGHANI v. NAVY 5 However, the AJ found that the Department presented clear and convincing evidence that it would have taken the same personnel actions in the absence of protected activity. The AJ found that the Department “put forth strong evi- dence” in support of Mr. Khaghani’s non-selection for two vacancy announcements, id. at 37, and that the Depart- ment showed that it would not have selected Mr. Khaghani for either position in the absence his protected disclosures, id. at 36–37, 40. The AJ also determined that the Depart- ment would have removed Mr. Khaghani from the SNR training program in the absence of his protected disclo- sures, as there were legitimate reasons for his removal. The AJ found that Mr. Khaghani’s other alleged purported agency actions did not constitute a “significant change in duties, responsibilities, or working conditions.” Id. at 57. The Initial Decision became final on February 10, 2026, due to lack of quorum for Board review pursuant to 5 C.F.R. § 1200.3(b). Mr. Khaghani timely appealed. We have jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1295(a)(9). DISCUSSION We set aside a decision of the Board only if it is “(1) ar- bitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law; (2) obtained without procedures re- quired by law, rule, or regulation having been followed; or (3) unsupported by substantial evidence.” Rickel v. Dep’t of the Navy, 31 F.4th 1358, 1363–64 (Fed. Cir. 2022) (quoting 5 U.S.C. § 7703(c)). On appeal, the petitioner bears the tributing factor in a personnel action through circumstan- tial evidence, such as evidence that the official taking the personnel action knew of the disclosure and that the per- sonnel action occurred within a period of time such that a reasonable person could conclude that the disclosure was a contributing factor in the personnel action.” Decision, 2024 WL 4581031, at 33–34. Case: 26-1549 Document: 35 Page: 6 Filed: 11/20/2026 6 KHAGHANI v. NAVY burden of establishing error in the Board’s decisions. Jones v. Merit Sys. Prot. Bd., 98 F.4th 1376, 1380 (Fed. Cir. 2024). Aggrieved federal employees may seek corrective ac- tion from the Board resulting from a “prohibited personnel practice described in section 2302(b)(8) or sec- tion 2302(b)(9)(A)(i), (B), (C), or (D)” of the Whistleblower Protection Act (WPA). 5 U.S.C. § 1221(a). Sec- tion 2302(b)(8) of the WPA protects an employee against retaliation for “any disclosure of information” that the em- ployee “reasonably believes evidences” either a “violation of law, rule, or regulation,” or “gross mismanagement, a gross waste of funds, an abuse of authority, or a substantial and specific danger to public health or safety.” 5 U.S.C. § 2302(b)(8)(A). On appeal, Mr. Khaghani challenges the Board’s appli- cation of legal standards and the sufficiency of its reason- ing. Appellant Br. 16–18. We find Mr. Khaghani’s arguments unpersuasive. First, Mr. Khaghani contends that the Board failed to apply the correct legal standard regarding his procurement disclosure (Disclosure 2). Appellant Br. 19–22. Specifi- cally, he states “[t]he procurement disclosure was evalu- ated using later-developed explanations rather than contemporaneous information.” Id. at 20. We see no such error in the AJ’s decision. The WPA requires a reasonable belief of a “violation of any law, rule, or regulation” or “gross mismanagement, a gross waste of funds, an abuse of authority, or a substantial and specific danger to public health or safety.” 5 U.S.C. § 2302(b)(8)(A). The AJ con- cluded that Mr. Khaghani did not have a reasonable belief of wrongdoing with respect to the procurement disclosure because “he offered no evidence showing the two items pur- chased . . . were the same.” Decision, 2024 WL 4581031, at 13. This did not “transform[] reasonable belief into proof.” Appellant Br. 20–21. Case: 26-1549 Document: 35 Page: 7 Filed: 11/20/2026 KHAGHANI v. NAVY 7 Further, Mr. Khaghani claims that the Board failed to sufficiently address contrary evidence and explain its cred- ibility determinations. Appellant Br. 26–28. However, Mr. Khaghani fails to explain how the Board deviated from the correct legal standard or misapplied it. Mr. Khaghani’s arguments amount to mere disagreement with the Board’s weighing of the record evidence. Mr. Khaghani’s initial brief does not challenge any particular credibility determi- nation at issue and makes only a generalized assertion of error. In any event, credibility determinations are “virtu- ally unreviewable.” Holmes v. United States Postal Serv., 987 F.3d 1042, 1047 (Fed. Cir. 2021). We do not disturb those findings unless they are “inherently improbable, dis- credited by undisputed evidence, or contrary to physical facts.” Id. Mr. Khaghani fails to meet this burden. Next, Mr. Khaghani argues that the Board failed to sufficiently explain how the Department proved by clear and convincing evidence that it would have taken the same personnel action absent protected activity. Appellant Br. 22–23. We find no error. The Board reasonably found that the Department would have taken the same personnel actions in the ab- sence of Mr. Khaghani’s protected disclosures. Regarding the first position that Mr. Khaghani was not selected for, the Board found that it was due to Mr. Khaghani’s failure to submit a complete application. The Board credited tes- timony that Mr. Khaghani was not selected for the second job position because he was less qualified than the other candidates. Further, the Board reasonably found that Mr. Khaghani would have been removed from the SNR training regardless of his protected disclosures, as he had only reached 50% completion of the program in four years, failed to timely report a witnessed OPSEC violation, and refused to board a ship in defiance of an order. Moreover, the AJ’s analysis of all three personnel actions involved a correct application of the Carr factors. See Carr v. Soc. Sec. Admin., 185 F.3d 1318, 1323 (Fed. Cir. 1999). Mr. Kha- Case: 26-1549 Document: 35 Page: 8 Filed: 11/20/2026 8 KHAGHANI v. NAVY ghani’s other alleged purported agency actions did not con- stitute a “significant change in duties, responsibilities, or working conditions” because Mr. Khaghani provided “little, if any, evidence supporting hostile behavior by the [Depart- ment].” Decision, 2024 WL 4581031, at 57. And “[e]ven accepting the appellant’s claims individually or collectively as true,” the AJ found they “do not demonstrate a pattern of harassment.” Id. Finally, Mr. Khaghani asserts that the Board erred by failing to consider the cumulative effect of the alleged ad- verse personnel actions. Appellant Br. 29. We are not per- suaded. To the extent Mr. Khaghani’s argument refers to the purported actions allegedly constituting “significant change in duties, responsibilities, or working conditions” under 5 U.S.C. § 2302(a)(2)(A)(xii) (enumerated as ele- ments “a” through “k” in the AJ’s decision, see Decision, 2024 WL 4581031, at 42–43), the AJ did consider the cu- mulative effect, as discussed above. To the extent Mr. Kha- ghani’s argument refers to all alleged personnel actions (i.e., non-selection, training removal, and other significant changes in duties, responsibilities, or working conditions), we see no error in the AJ’s approach. CONCLUSION We have considered Mr. Khaghani’s remaining argu- ments and find them unpersuasive. For the foregoing rea- sons, we affirm. AFFIRMED COSTS No costs.