In re E.A. CA4/1
CourtCalifornia Court of Appeal
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
DocketD087871
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Filed 11/18/26 In re E.A. CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
In re E.A., a Person Coming Under the
Juvenile Court Law.
D087871
SAN DIEGO COUNTY HEALTH AND
HUMAN SERVICES AGENCY,
(Super. Ct. No. J521645)
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
L.A. et al.,
Defendants and Appellants.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Daniela Reali-Ferrari, Judge. Affirmed.
Jack A. Love, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant
and Appellant L.A.
Clare M. Lemon, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant A.A.
Damon M. Brown, County Counsel, Lisa M. Maldonado, Chief Deputy
County Counsel, and Eliza Molk, Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
Mother L.A. and Father A.A. (the Parents) appeal from the juvenile
court’s March 3, 2026 order under Welfare and Institutions Code
section 300(a). The court found true the allegation in the petition brought on
behalf of Minor E.A. (born January 2025) by the San Diego County Health
and Human Services Agency that his torn labial frenulum—the fibrous tissue
that connects the upper lip to the gum—resulted from nonaccidental injury
caused by the Parents.
On appeal, the Parents contend no substantial evidence supports the
court’s finding that Minor has suffered, or there is a substantial risk he will
suffer, serious physical harm inflicted nonaccidentally. We disagree and
therefore affirm.
I.
A.
During Minor’s medical appointment in early February 2025, his family
doctor observed he had bleeding gums and bruises on his back and stomach.
The Parents denied seeing or causing the bruising. The doctor suspected
“‘non-accidental trauma’” and notified the Agency.
An ambulance transported Minor to Rady Children’s Hospital for
evaluation. A Rady’s emergency room doctor observed three linear petechial
bruises on the right side of Minor’s back and one linear petechial bruise on
the left side. No other injuries were observed, including to Minor’s mouth.
Father disclosed that a few days earlier, he saw a drop of blood on the tip of
Minor’s baby bottle. The child protection team at Rady’s concluded the
bruising was possibly the result of nonaccidental trauma.
2
Dr. Nicole Ayson, a Rady’s child abuse pediatrician, recommended
Minor undergo a nonaccidental trauma (NAT) workup. Minor’s tests came
back unremarkable. But due to the Parents’ lack of a plausible explanation
for the bruises, Dr. Ayson concluded they likely resulted from inflicted injury.
The Agency closed its investigation, finding the allegation of physical
abuse “inconclusive.”
B.
On June 20, 2025, the Agency received another referral for Minor, the
day after Mother informed his family doctor of Minor’s torn labial frenulum.
The doctor advised the Parents to take Minor to Rady’s for evaluation.
At Rady’s, Mother denied “shov[ing] anything” into Minor’s mouth and
suggested the injury may have resulted from Minor’s fingers or a toy. She
disclosed she was Minor’s “sole provider” when Father was at work; Minor
did not have a babysitter or attend day care; she suffered from “‘bouts of
postpartum [depression]’”; and she was removed from her parents’ care and
placed in foster care five years prior at age 15.
Shalon Nienow, M.D., the medical director of the Chadwick Center at
Rady’s and the division chief of child abuse pediatrics for the University of
California, San Diego, recommended Minor undergo a full NAT workup.
Against medical advice, the Parents refused and left Rady’s, after being
advised this protocol was a standard of care process. A few days later, the
Parents agreed to additional testing by Rady’s, and the results once again
“returned unremarkable/clear.”
C.
The Agency’s petition consisted of one count under section 300(a),
alleging Minor “has suffered, or there is substantial risk that [Minor] will
3
suffer[,] serious physical harm inflicted non-accidently,” evidenced by his torn
frenulum.
At the detention hearing, the court made a prima facie finding on the
petition; detained Minor with the Parents, on the condition that at least one
paternal grandparent reside with the family; ordered the Agency to provide
the Parents with referrals for services; and denied the Agency’s protective
custody warrant.
In July 2025, the Agency submitted referrals for a child abuse group
and parenting classes for the Parents. Dr. Nienow examined Minor and
reported his frenulum had healed and his repeat skeletal survey showed no
evidence of fractures. Dr. Nienow reaffirmed that the bruising on Minor’s
back and the tear to his frenulum were “more likely than not the result of
physical abuse.” (Bolding omitted.)
D.
The Agency’s July 2025 jurisdiction/disposition report recommended a
true finding on the petition; that Minor remain in the home with the Parents,
on the condition that at least one of the paternal grandparents continue to
reside with the family; and the Agency provide the Parents with family
maintenance services.
Included in the Agency’s July report was a consult by Kelly Motadel,
M.D., the chief pediatric officer at San Diego County Medical Care Services.
After reviewing Minor’s medical records and the Agency’s detention report,
Dr. Motadel opined Minor’s torn frenulum “appeared to be inflicted.”
E.
The Agency prepared multiple addenda for the contested
jurisdiction/disposition hearing. Attached to the October 16 addendum were
4
two reports prepared by medical experts retained by the Parents. Both
experts testified at the hearing, as did Dr. Nienow.
In his August 4, 2025 report, pediatric neurologist Perry Lubens, M.D.,
opined Minor potentially had a “congenital defect” to his labial frenulum and
the tear was likely related to the prior injury when Minor was three weeks
old. The “repeated tears” were thus “not a result of child abuse.”
Otolaryngologist Nadim Bikhazi, M.D., opined in his September 2, 2025
report that Minor had suffered a torn frenulum when he was first seen at
Rady’s and photographs from Minor’s second visit showed “an open wound”
from an “old injury with a healing ridge” possibly resulting from pressured
“bottle feeding” or a “fingernail.” Because no other injuries were observed,
such as a swollen lip or other facial trauma, Minor’s torn frenulum was not
indicative of abuse.
Dr. Nienow disagreed with the Parents’ experts’ reports, opining a
frenulum tear could not result from a congenital defect, normal bottle
feeding, or a fingernail; Minor’s June tear was not a “re-injury” because it
was not present in February; and, in any event, frenula injuries “heal very
rapidly and completely.” Dr. Nienow concluded a “reasonable trauma
history” could explain Minor’s injury, but a lack of such history was
“significant” in making her diagnostic findings.
Dr. Motadel, the Agency’s expert, also reviewed the Parents’ expert’s
reports and disagreed that a newborn or five-month-old child could tear their
frenula on their own or that such an injury could occur from routine bottle
feeding or pacifier use. In her 20 years of practice, she saw “very few” such
injuries, and, because injuries to the “mucosa heal[] quickly,” she doubted
Minor had suffered a prior, not properly healed labial frenulum tear.
5
The Agency reported in its November 12 addendum that Mother had
yet to start therapy or a child abuse group. Mother reported she had
completed intake for her child abuse group in November and as of mid-
December had attended two and missed three group sessions, while Father
had attended 10 sessions and missed one due to work.
In November, after the Parents received a notice of violation from their
military housing authority, the court lifted the condition that paternal
grandparents reside with the Parents, instead requiring them to check on
Minor a “few hours” every day.
F.
At the contested hearing, the court admitted the Agency’s reports into
evidence and designated Dr. Nienow as a pediatric child abuse expert. The
testimony of the three expert witnesses was generally consistent with their
opinions in their respective reports.
According to Dr. Nienow, in nonambulatory children, a frenulum tear is
“rare” and thus a “high-risk prognostic indicator . . . strongly associated with
inflicted injury.” Scientific studies confirm “intraoral injuries as a whole are
strongly associated with inflicted trauma,” with one study focusing on frenula
tears.
Dr. Nienow noted two other Rady’s doctors saw Minor in February,
including a child abuse fellow, and concluded the marks on his back were
bruises and not skin “blotching.” Dr. Nienow found the bruising
“extraordinarily worrisome.” Because there was no trauma history to explain
it, it was indicative of “inflicted injury that is also concerning for future, more
severe injury.” Minor’s records also showed his frenula was “completely
intact and normal at that time,” with “no signs of oral trauma.” Dr. Nienow’s
6
July 8, 2025 examination of Minor showed his labial frenulum had “healed
completely” and he had normal intraoral anatomy.
In forming his opinions in this case, Dr. Lubens reviewed two studies
relied on by Dr. Nienow and Minor’s medical records. He opined Minor
should have been evaluated by a pediatric otolaryngologist (i.e., ENT) to
determine whether he had a “congenital problem” with his labial frenulum.
Were Minor his patient, Dr. Lubens would have done so because he was not
an “expert in labial frenula.”
As an ENT, Dr. Bikhazi estimated he had seen over 25,000 patients for
“a variety of intraoral pathology” and “trauma.” The court designated
Dr. Bikhazi as an expert in otolaryngology. “Many” of the pediatric patients
Dr. Bikhazi saw suffered from accidental trauma, and only a “few” had
injuries caused nonaccidentally. He estimated children under the age of six
months made up about two percent of his patients, with most seen for
recurring ear infections. Dr. Bikhazi ordinarily was not consulted for frenula
tears, which were typically handled by emergency room physicians, unless
more severe injuries were also involved.
Regarding Minor, Dr. Bikhazi questioned the accuracy of Dr. Nienow’s
report and the Rady’s physicians’ notes from Minor’s February consult,
believing the photographs instead showed “petechial blemishes” on Minor’s
back from noninflicted trauma. As to the tear, Dr. Bikhazi opined Minor had
suffered two injuries to his labial frenulum. While Dr. Bikhazi recognized
the Rady’s records from February described Minor’s frenula as “intact,” he
considered the emergency room doctor’s notes to be “vague” regarding the
examination of Minor’s mouth. Dr. Bikhazi could not determine from the
photographs whether Minor had an abnormal labial frenulum and
acknowledged a frenulum tear in a nonmobile child was “rare.” He opined
7
that, if a “significant” amount of pressure was applied, a pacifier, a toy, or a
fingernail could injure the frenula. Because there were no “associated
injuries,” Dr. Bikhazi questioned Dr. Nienow’s diagnosis of inflicted injury.
G.
Counsel for the Agency and Minor asked the court to make a true
finding on the petition, while counsel for Mother and Father requested its
dismissal. The court took the matter under submission.
At the continued hearing, the court found Minor’s section 300(a)
petition true. Of the three experts, the court found Dr. Nienow was the only
doctor specifically trained as a child abuse pediatrician. It credited her
testimony that frenula injuries were “quite rare” and “strongly associated
with inflicted trauma” because nonmobile infants could not “generate enough
force to cause injury in general.” In taking jurisdiction, the court also noted
the Parents had just begun their child abuse groups and other services.
II.
The Parents contend no substantial evidence supports the court’s
finding that Minor has suffered, or there is a substantial risk he will suffer,
serious physical harm inflicted nonaccidentally. We disagree.
A.
We review for substantial evidence the court’s jurisdictional findings.
(In re Sheila B. (1993) 19 Cal.App.4th 187, 199–200.) A finding that a minor
is a person described in section 300 must be made “by a preponderance of
[the] evidence.” (§ 355(a).)
On substantial evidence review, we do not reweigh the evidence or
consider matters of credibility. (Sheila B., 19 Cal.App.4th at p. 199.) “[W]e
must uphold the court’s findings unless, after reviewing the entire record and
resolving all conflicts in favor of the respondent and drawing all reasonable
8
inferences in support of the judgment [or order], we determine there is no
substantial evidence to support the findings.” (In re Veronica G. (2007)
157 Cal.App.4th 179, 185.)
Section 300(a) provides in part that a child is within the jurisdiction of
the court if “[t]he child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the
child will suffer, serious physical harm inflicted nonaccidentally upon the
child by the child’s parent or guardian.” “[A] court may find there is a
substantial risk of serious future injury based on the manner in which a less
serious injury was inflicted, a history of repeated inflictions of injuries on the
child or the child’s siblings, or a combination of these and other actions by the
parent or guardian that indicate the child is at risk of serious physical harm.”
(Ibid.)
“The court need not wait until a child is seriously abused or injured to
assume jurisdiction.” (In re R.V. (2012) 208 Cal.App.4th 837, 843.) “[A]n
allegation that a child has suffered serious physical harm inflicted
nonaccidentally by a parent . . . is sufficient to establish jurisdiction.” (In re
David H. (2008) 165 Cal.App.4th 1626, 1644.) “Once the child is found to be
endangered in the manner described by one of the subdivisions of
section 300[, f]or jurisdictional purposes[,] it is irrelevant which parent
created those circumstances.” (In re I.A. (2011) 201 Cal.App.4th 1484, 1491–
1492.)
B.
We conclude substantial evidence supports the court’s finding that
Minor “has suffered, or there is substantial risk” he will suffer, serious
physical harm inflicted nonaccidentally by the Parents. As the trier of fact,
the court weighed the credibility of the three medical experts and found
9
Dr. Nienow to be the most persuasive, as she was the only pediatric child
abuse specialist and the only one who examined Minor.
At three weeks old, Minor’s family doctor, a Rady’s emergency room
physician, and Drs. Ayson and Nienow all agreed Minor had unexplained
bruising on his back. Drs. Ayson and Nienow opined such injuries were
“extremely rare” because nonmobile children cannot generate enough force to
injure themselves. About four months later, Minor suffered another
unexplained injury, this time to his labial frenulum. Both Drs. Nienow and
Motadel opined Minor could not have caused this injury on his own, as
children his age are unable to generate sufficient force to do so, nor could the
injury have resulted from regular bottle feeding or pacifier use. They further
opined frenula injuries heal quickly, so the tear was unrelated to Minor’s oral
bleeding when he was three weeks old. Dr. Nienow thus opined Minor’s
frenulum tear was more likely than not caused by nonaccidental injury.
The foregoing evidence amply supports the court’s true finding on the
section 300(a) petition. (See Veronica G., 157 Cal.App.4th at p. 185.) The
evidence also supports the court’s finding that Parents were Minor’s sole
caregivers when both unexplained injuries—bruising and the frenulum
tear—occurred and that they had no plausible explanation for them.
We recognize there is evidence supporting a contrary finding.
Nonetheless, because substantial evidence supports the court’s findings that
(1) Minor suffered serious physical harm inflicted nonaccidently while in the
exclusive care of the Parents (see § 300(a)) and (2) the Parents were just
beginning services, as a reviewing court we cannot make new findings,
including that Minor’s injuries resulted from accidental trauma. (See
Sheila B., 19 Cal.App.4th at p. 199 [“‘Issues of fact and credibility are
questions for the trial court.’”].)
10
Finally, we disagree with the Parents that the court’s jurisdictional
findings cannot stand because there allegedly was no evidence that Minor
was at risk for future physical harm.
First, jurisdiction is proper even without such a finding, as
section 300(a) provides that a child is within the jurisdiction of the court if
“[t]he child has suffered . . . serious physical harm inflicted nonaccidentally.”
(Italics added; see David H., 165 Cal.App.4th at p. 1644.)
Second, because there was no trauma history to explain Minor’s
injuries, which occurred when he was nonmobile, the court was “grave[ly]
concern[ed]” for Minor’s future wellbeing. In so finding, the court credited
the medical research relied on by Dr. Nienow and her testimony that Minor’s
injuries were a “harbinger” “for future, more severe injury.” We conclude this
finding is supported by evidence that is reasonable, credible, and of solid
value and further supports the court’s decision to take jurisdiction of Minor
under section 300(a). (See Veronica G., 157 Cal.App.4th at p. 185.)
11
III.
We affirm the juvenile court’s March 3, 2026 order.
CASTILLO, J.
WE CONCUR:
BUCHANAN, Acting P. J.
RUBIN, J.
12