Amazing Valley Health Services, Inc. and Daniel Torres v. Janie Vargas
CourtTexas Court of Appeals, 13th District
Date FiledNovember 19, 2026
Docket13-24-00396-CV
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
NUMBER 13-24-00396-CV
COURT OF APPEALS
THIRTEENTH DISTRICT OF TEXAS
CORPUS CHRISTI – EDINBURG
AMAZING VALLEY HEALTH
SERVICES, INC. AND
DANIEL TORRES, Appellants,
v.
JANIE VARGAS, Appellee.
ON APPEAL FROM THE COUNTY COURT AT LAW NO. 10
OF HIDALGO COUNTY, TEXAS
MEMORANDUM OPINION
Before Chief Justice Tijerina and Justices West and Cron
Memorandum Opinion by Chief Justice Tijerina
By two issues, which we have renumbered, appellants Amazing Valley Health
Services, Inc. (Amazing) and Daniel Torres first contend that the summary judgment
granted in favor of appellee Janie Vargas is not final and that summary judgment was
improper because they raised issues of material fact. We affirm.
I. FINAL JUDGMENT
By their first issue, appellants contend that the trial court’s summary judgment is
not final because it did not specifically dispose of appellee’s counterclaim.
“[W]hen there has not been a conventional trial on the merits, an order or judgment
is not final for purposes of appeal ‘unless it actually disposes of every pending claim and
party or unless it clearly and unequivocally states that it finally disposes of all claims and
all parties.’” Rehab 2112, L.L.C. v. Audio Images Intern., Inc., 168 S.W.3d 308, 311 (Tex.
App.—Dallas 2005, no pet.) (quoting Lehmann v. Har–Con Corp., 39 S.W.3d 191, 205
(Tex. 2001)). “[A] judgment that purports to be final, even if erroneously so, is final for
purposes of appeal, and we have jurisdiction to review the issues presented on appeal.”
Cespedes v. Am. Express-CA, No. 13-05-385-CV, 2007 WL 1365441, at *2 (Tex. App.—
Corpus Christi–Edinburg May 10, 2007, no pet.) (mem. op.) (citing Ritzell v. Espeche, 87
S.W.3d 536, 538 (Tex. 2002) (per curiam)).
Here, the judgment states, “This is a final and appealable judgment, resolving all
controversies herein. All other and further relief, not expressly granted, is hereby
DENIED.” We conclude that the judgment clearly and unequivocally states that it denies
all relief requested and has finally disposed of all claims and parties; therefore, even if the
judgment is erroneous as appellants complain, it is final. See id. (explaining that the trial
court’s judgment was final and appealable because it “clearly and unequivocally state[d]
the following: ‘This judgment disposes of all parties and claims and is final and
appealable’”); see also Ritzell, 87 S.W.3d at 537 (concluding that similar language
rendered the judgment final). We overrule appellants’ first issue.
2
II. SUMMARY JUDGMENT
By their second issue, appellants contend that the trial court improperly granted
appellee’s motion for no evidence summary judgment on all their causes of action.
A. Standard of Review and Applicable Law
A party may file a motion for no evidence summary judgment if “‘there is no
evidence of one or more essential elements of a claim . . . which an adverse party would
have the burden of proof at trial.’” State v. Three Thousand, Seven Hundred Seventy-
Four Dollars & Twenty-Eight Cents U.S. Currency, 713 S.W.3d 381, 386 (Tex. 2025)
(quoting TEX. R. CIV. P. 166a(i)). Once the movant files a motion for no evidence summary
judgment, “the burden shifts to the nonmoving party to present evidence raising an issue
of material fact as to the elements specified in the motion.” Mack Trucks, Inc. v. Tamez,
206 S.W.3d 572, 582 (Tex. 2006). The non-movant’s burden is met if he produces “more
than a mere scintilla of evidence in support of each challenged element.” Battista v. City
of Alpine, 345 S.W.3d 769, 774 (Tex. App.—El Paso 2011, no pet.). The non-movant may
do so by either attaching evidence to its response or by discussing and calling “the court’s
attention to evidence already in the court’s record.” Three Thousand, Seven Hundred
Seventy-Four Dollars & Twenty-Eight Cents U.S. Currency, 713 S.W.3d at 389.
The court must grant the motion if the non-movant fails to produce summary
judgment evidence raising a genuine issue of material fact. TEX. R. CIV. P. 166a(i). “We
review the evidence presented by the motion and response in the light most favorable to
the party against whom the summary judgment was rendered, crediting evidence
favorable to that party if reasonable jurors could, and disregarding contrary evidence
unless reasonable jurors could not.” Mack Trucks, Inc., 206 S.W.3d at 582 (first citing City
3
of Keller v. Wilson, 168 S.W.3d 802, 827 (Tex. 2005); and then citing Johnson v. Brewer
& Pritchard, P.C., 73 S.W.3d 193, 208 (Tex. 2002)).
B. Discussion
Appellants filed suit against appellee for breach of contract, fraudulent inducement,
fraud, negligent misrepresentation, money had and received, theft of property, and
conversion claiming that appellee had improperly failed to pay $40,000 to appellants.
Appellee filed a motion for no evidence summary judgment challenging each element of
each of appellants’ claims. Appellants filed a response stating only the following:
This action by [Appellants] is simply a lawful attempt to recover the balance
of money paid to [Appellee] for an apparent successful home health agency
which in—fact had failed to continue under Texas and Federal law, and
unknown to [Appellants] had closed down in Violation of its operations. The
sale was rescinded by agreement of the Parties for a total refund, but only
a portion of the monies paid were returned. The balance of $40,000 was
promised by [Appellee] as seller and is now attempting to convert the stated
amount for no lawful reason.
....
[Appellants], as buyers, began in good faith began all operations, but
were legally blocked by the foregoing obstacle. All prayers and proceedings
are presented by [Appellants’] the pleadings and facts already presented,
and make a case for [Appellants] (See Discovery).
Wherefore, [Appellants] request that this Court deny any motion for
judgment, and set the case for trial as early as practically possible.
On May 11, 2024, appellants filed an offer of proof of action for breach of contract
and conversion and attached a copy of a check from appellee to Amazing. Appellants
stated that the copy of the check “was given to [appellants] by [appellee] for partial refund
of the consideration given for the sale of what had been represented as lawful and, on-
going business, CON FED health services.” They claimed that “the sale was quickly
rescinded and [appellee] was returning the full consideration to . . . [appellants].”
4
Appellants did not address any of the challenged elements of their causes of action. They
claimed, without citation to any evidence, that “a balance of $40,000 was to be paid
subsequently” and that the “amount ha[d] not been repaid, and the business operation
was never turned over to [appellants] as an on-going business.” The trial court granted
appellee’s motion for no evidence summary judgment on May 14, 2024. On May 24, 2024,
appellants filed a motion for new trial arguing that they provided sufficient evidence of
their claims and attached exhibits to their motion.
Appellants did not attach evidence to their response or substantively discuss or
call attention to evidence already in the trial court’s record that raised a question of fact
on each element of each of the challenged causes of action. See Three Thousand, Seven
Hundred Seventy-Four Dollars & Twenty-Eight Cents U.S. Currency, 713 S.W.3d at 389.
Instead, they generally claimed in their response that appellee failed to return money to
them. Appellants did not mention any of the challenged causes of action, their elements,
or state what evidence raised questions of fact on those elements. See id. However, “the
nonmovant must, at the very minimum, provide some form of discussion that raises issues
of material fact on the challenged elements.” Holloway v. Tex. Elec. Util. Const., Ltd., 282
S.W.3d 207, 212 (Tex. App.—Tyler 2009, no pet.). Appellants, nonetheless, argue that
they raised issues of material fact in their offer of proof of action for breach of contract
and conversion. However, although appellants attached purported evidence to their offer
of proof, they did not mention any elements relating to the challenged causes of action,
did not substantively discuss or call attention to evidence already in the trial court’s record
that raised a question of fact on each element of each of the challenged causes of action,
or state what evidence raised questions of fact. See Three Thousand, Seven Hundred
5
Seventy-Four Dollars & Twenty-Eight Cents U.S. Currency, 713 S.W.3d at 389.
Therefore, we conclude that appellants failed to produce summary judgment evidence
raising issues of material fact on each element of the challenged causes of action. See
Battista, 345 S.W.3d at 775 (explaining that although the non-movants “included evidence
addressing the first two [challenged] elements,” they “omitted evidence” of one of the
challenged elements and summary judgment was proper because the non-movant failed
“to meet their responsive burden of proof”). Accordingly, the trial court was required to
grant appellee’s motion for no evidence summary judgment on all claims. See TEX. R.
CIV. P. 166a(i); Three Thousand, Seven Hundred Seventy-Four Dollars & Twenty-Eight
Cents U.S. Currency, 713 S.W.3d at 389. We overrule appellants’ second issue.
III. CONCLUSION
We affirm the trial court’s judgment.
JAIME TIJERINA
Chief Justice
Delivered and filed on the
19th day of November, 2026.
6