Intermountain Electronics, Inc.
CourtUnited States Tax Court
Date FiledNovember 17, 2026
Docket11019-19
JudgeBuch
StatusUnpublished
š° News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
United States Tax Court
T.C. Memo. 2026-118
INTERMOUNTAIN ELECTRONICS, INC.,
Petitioner
v.
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE,
Respondent
__________
Docket No. 11019-19. Filed November 17, 2026.
__________
Matthew S. Reddington, Robert G. Wonish II, Coby R. Leslie, John H.
Dies, Jr., Janine M. Campanaro, and Jefferson H. Read, for petitioner.
Christopher J. Richmond, Jonathan D. Walker, Bryant W. Smith, Daniel
J. Kleid, and Inga C. Plucinski-Holbrook, for respondent.
MEMORANDUM FINDINGS OF FACT AND OPINION
BUCH, Judge: This case involves section 41 1 research credits
claimed by Intermountain Electronics, Inc. (Intermountain), a
corporation principally engaged in the business of manufacturing
custom mining equipment. The Commissioner disallowed research
credits claimed for 2012 through 2015 (years in issue).
The disallowed credits relate to thousands of projects; however,
we instructed the parties to present evidence with respect to a
representative sample of those projects. The issue for decision is
1 Unless otherwise indicated, statutory references are to the Internal Revenue
Code, Title 26 U.S.C. (I.R.C.), in effect at all relevant times, regulation references are
to the Code of Federal Regulations, Title 26 (Treas. Reg.), in effect at all relevant times,
and Rule references are to the Tax Court Rules of Practice and Procedure. All monetary
amounts are shown in U.S. dollars and rounded to the nearest dollar.
Served 11/17/26
2
[*2] whether these projects (and by extrapolation, the thousands of
projects) qualify for section 41 credits.
The parties put on evidence with respect to twelve of those
projects. Most of those projects related to products designed and
manufactured for delivery to Intermountainās customers. As to those
projects, the attempt to allocate costs between routine manufacturing
and research was conducted retrospectively, and the attempted
allocation proved unreliable. Two projects, however, were designs of new
products, and the parties agree that they constitute qualified research.
Thus, of the twelve projects presented at trial, petitioner met its burden
to establish that two of its projects qualified for the research credit.
Regarding those two projects, petitioner provided credible
substantiation of the amount to be taken into account to calculate the
credit.
FINDINGS OF FACT
I. Background
Intermountain is a corporation with its principal place of business
in Price, Utah. Intermountain is principally a manufacturer of custom
electrical distribution and control equipment for underground and
surface mining, among other applications.
Intermountainās story begins with a tragedy. John Houston
received a degree in electrical automation technology in the early 1970s.
He put his degree to use working as an electrician on both surface and
underground mining equipment. A decade into his career, he found
himself working for Emery Mining Co. Shortly before Christmas in
1984, 27 people died as a result of a mine fire at the mine where Mr.
Houston worked. The following month, Mr. Houston founded
Intermountain in Price, Utah, which initially focused on repairing and
modifying electrical components used in the mining industry.
Intermountain started out repairing electrical equipment for
mining operations. Tom Akers joined the company in the late nineties
as a partial owner, leading Intermountain to focus on developing the
business. Because of its growth in the mining industry, Intermountain
established new facilities in Ohio and Illinois, near the Ohio Valley and
the Illinois River Basin coal regions.
Over time, Intermountain began performing more complex
services and designing custom products to meet the demands of the
3
[*3] mining industry. However, because of the cyclical nature of the coal
mining industry, Intermountain needed to diversify. Intermountain
opened its Denver, Colorado location to expand into the oil and gas
industry.
By the early 2000s, Intermountain expanded into design and
manufacturing control systems and mine-related power distribution
equipment. Intermountain created custom electrical equipment,
including control buildings, switchgears, transformers, variable
frequency drive packages or controller packages, and skids. A
transformer, also called a power center or load center, transforms
voltage and provides circuits to operate individual pieces of
underground equipment. A variable frequency drive (VFD) changes the
frequency of the power signal of an AC motor to change the speed at
which it operates. A skid is the structure at the bottom of a product on
which an enclosure, outdoor equipment, or pumps rest. Intermountain
also performed design and manufacturing work for electrical systems.
To this day, Intermountain focuses on creating equipment that
distributes power.
II. Intermountainās Project Design Process for Custom Electrical
Equipment and Custom Transformers
A. Phase 1 ā Initial Design
For custom electrical equipment and transformers,
Intermountainās work begins with a customer need or request.
Intermountainās business comes from its existing customer base, word
of mouth referrals, and competitive bidding. Customers choose
Intermountain for its technical expertise and ability to craft custom
solutions for customer problems. For Intermountainās custom electrical
equipment manufacturing, the customer typically comes to
Intermountain with a problem, and Intermountain develops a product
to solve it.
Intermountainās customers make requests of varying levels of
complexity. Some customers provide drawings to Intermountain with
the expectation that it would build their designs. Other customers
provide a list of needs or specifications from which Intermountain can
design and build a product. Intermountain declines projects when it is
not confident that it can design and build a product that meets the
customerās needs.
4
[*4] Intermountain works with its customers to create a list of
specifications. To develop project specifications, Intermountain must
consider many technical and environmental complications. Electrical
installations in an underground mine present vastly different
environmental challenges when compared to more typical above-ground
electrical installations. Intermountain distinguishes itself from its
competition by placing engineering staff, as opposed to salespeople, as
the first point of contact for its customers. The engineering staff have
the necessary expertise to identify the customerās concerns and technical
requirements and to propose a design to address those concerns and
requirements.
Scheduling considerations are at the forefront during the initial
design stage. If Intermountain cannot meet a customerās deadline, they
let the customer know ahead of time. Intermountain has an incentive to
schedule things accurately because missing a deadline can cause
residual delays for other projects.
Intermountain enters into fixed-fee contracts with its customers.
Intermountain provides a preliminary design as part of its quote to a
customer for a contract. This preliminary design shows the customer the
major components of the product and explains their functions.
Intermountain discusses the design with its customer to ensure the
project meets the customerās needs and specifications. On the basis of
this design, Intermountain provides a quote to the customer. After
receiving the quote, a customer may issue a purchase order.
Intermountain then typically issues a sales order acknowledgment,
which includes an estimated date of completion for the product in that
document.
Of course, Intermountain prices projects so as to profit from them.
Intermountain seeks to accurately price projects to ensure the costs of
labor and materials do not exceed the quoted price. To do this,
Intermountain relies on specialized staff members who understand the
engineering involved. If a design must change after the initial quote, the
party that precipitated the change bears the cost.
B. Phases 2 and 3: Mechanical and Electrical Design and
Layout
From the original designs, Intermountain creates the mechanical
and electrical designs. These designs serve as instructions for the
5
[*5] production team. The processes for designing the mechanical and
electrical layouts occur simultaneously.
After receiving the order, the assigned electrical engineer begins
identifying the relevant parts to create the design. The electrical
engineer prepares a series of electrical drawings and a list of necessary
components. The electrical engineer determines whether certain
products would function as intended and, if not, finds a suitable
alternative. After the design is complete and a bill of materials is
created, the project proceeds to a mechanical engineer under the
direction of the project manager.
Mechanical engineering consists of drawing the product in 3āD
and ensuring it complies with various requirements such as the relevant
codes. Intermountain will often include in its designs equipment that it
obtains from third parties. Intermountain relies on drawings from
manufacturers or vendors to determine necessary information for the
equipment. This information includes the equipmentās weight,
dimensions, how certain parts are mounted, its center of gravity, and
how power goes either into or out of the equipment. The mechanical
engineer uses this information along with the information from the
electrical engineer. The mechanical engineer runs calculations on
components such as the structural members of the project base frame to
determine dead loads, live loads, and cable tray loads. 2 Creating the 3āD
drawing involves sizing the structural members and locating and
placing those members based on where the loads exist within the
structure. When creating the drawing, the mechanical engineers also
factor in information collected from weather and seismic data. This
information assists Intermountain in calculating the appropriate
building supportive structures.
Intermountain faces unique challenges in creating the electrical
designs for applications in mines. Electricity travelling through mines
may be subject to voltage drops. Intermountain also needs to consider
how power loads affect the system.
Intermountain also encounters challenges in creating the
mechanical design and layout. Intermountain needs to create products
2 Dead loads are the weight of the permanent elements of a building or
structure. Live loads are the weight of intermittent variables occurring on the building
or structure, including personnel walking across the floor or seasonal snow landing on
top of a structure. And cable tray loads are the weight of the cable tray which is used
to hold electrical cables inside equipment.
6
[*6] that withstand a variety of environmental factors, both above and
below ground. Products situated above ground need to withstand
weather conditions common to surface mines such as dusty river basins
and deserts. Below ground, the products are placed in direct proximity
with caustic materials such as soda ash, potash, and salts.
Intermountain creates products that account for a variety of
factors. One of those factors is the size constraints of an underground
mine, which affect the entire product, including ventilation, cooling, and
airflow. To address these constraints, Intermountain conducts
computational fluid dynamics to ensure proper ventilation and
circulation.
Intermountain also needs to create equipment that can enter
different kinds of mines through either tunnels or shafts. Occasionally,
the equipment a customer requires has dimensions that, when the
equipment is upright, exceed the length or width of the tunnel or shaft.
Thus, installing the equipment requires that it be tilted in such a way
that it will pass through the tunnel or shaft before reaching its ultimate
installation destination. This requires special engineering to allow
equipment that is intended to be installed upright to be tilted and
rotated during the installation process. Intermountain also needs to
ensure that equipment can withstand delivery across dirt roads and into
mines. This requires mechanical specifications that can withstand a
high degree of abuse. Finally, Intermountain needs to build equipment
that can operate safely around hazardous or explosive gases. The
equipment must be designed and built to contain any sparks within the
equipment so as to avoid possible explosions. For example, equipment
for use in the extraction of oil and gas contains systems to monitor levels
of methane, propane, and other potentially dangerous gases.
Despite these challenges, Intermountain is well equipped to face
them. Intermountain maintains a standard parts library to use in
designing its projects. Intermountain ensures that its projects are
designed and built by experts who understand the products and
applications. Intermountain assigns projects according to each project
managerās particular expertise.
Intermountain uses specialized software to design its projects to
meet the structural stresses to which they will be exposed. An engineer
enters project information into the application, which calculates the
amounts of bending stress, deflection, and shear stress a part will
encounter. This permits engineers to determine whether a selected part
7
[*7] can withstand the anticipated stress. Engineers also need to
calculate the centers of gravity of projects to determine pick points and
determine the load and stress.
To calculate heat loss, Intermountainās engineers take
information provided by vendors of various components and input them
into a program to calculate heat loss. To ensure compliance with various
code requirements, an Intermountain engineer inputs information into
a computer program that will confirm whether a proposed design is in
compliance.
If possible, Intermountain relies on past designs to form the basis
for new ones. Intermountainās staff discusses all revisions to designs.
Sometimes revisions are necessary because a vendor makes a change to
a part used in a project. Some of Intermountainās customers require
Intermountain to seek its approval before revising a drawing, while
others do not.
Intermountain models its projects using 3āD drawing software.
The software enables the engineers to rotate the model and review it
from different angles and elevations. Intermountainās engineers use the
software to visualize the assembly of parts to see whether parts overlap
or collide, to line up parts, and to check clearances. The software
calculates an objectās center of gravity and accounts for the weight of the
components.
C. Phase 4: Pre-Production Review
Before fabrication, every project undergoes an electrical review
and a mechanical review. The electrical pre-production review consists
of confirming the appropriateness of building materials and the
electrical components. The mechanical pre-production review
sometimes requires reworking a design. The manufacturing team works
with the mechanical design team to identify any barriers to
manufacturing the final product. At times, reworking a design takes
anywhere from one day to two months, and Intermountain may have to
rework significant portions of a design. Once the internal reviews and
the reviews by the client are complete, Intermountain prepares
construction drawings.
D. Phase 5: Laser Cutting and Bending
Intermountain works with heavy 10-gauge steel to create custom
parts for its projects. It laser cuts steel to meet precise specifications.
8
[*8] Intermountain cannot buy precut steel that meets its needs and
tolerances.
E. Phase 6: Fabrication and Final Assembly
The fabrication process includes construction, painting, piping,
and skid construction. Individuals involved in the manufacturing
process sometimes encounter issues and provide feedback or ideas on
how to resolve an uncertainty in the project design. āPaintingā is more
than mere painting; the paint department ensures that the products
have the necessary protective coatings to meet project requirements of
the environment where the product will be installed. The piping
department is responsible for custom welding.
F. Phase 7: Testing and Quality Control
Testing and quality control are separate departments. The
testing department conducts functional testing to check for engineering
or design flaws and to ensure the product functions as designed. Quality
control evaluates the product to ensure that the already-functioning
product meets Intermountainās quality standards.
Intermountain measures the functionality of the product using its
Transformer Test Report. The results of the testing undertaken for
custom transformers are published in the report. These tests check the
resistance, termination, and density of transformer coils, the core steel,
the system voltage, the functionality of the design, and Occupational
Safety and Health Administration sound requirements. Although
necessary and helpful, the testing does not allow Intermountain to
simulate the environmental conditions at the ultimate installation site.
A transformer consists of four components that are designed and
fabricated in parallel: the insulation system, the coil winding, the core
steel, and the clamping system. Most of the testing is done before the
entire product is dipped in resin and baked. After the resin is applied,
alterations to the transformer are impossible without breaking the steel
and coils. Intermountain submerges coils in resin and puts them under
pressure for several hours and bakes them before testing them again.
After testing, the entire assembly is dipped in resin. A failed
transformer can overheat, which can lead to catastrophic fires, injuries,
and even death.
9
[*9] III. Intermountainās Project Process for Proprietary Product
Development
In addition to building custom electrical equipment,
Intermountain also develops specialized proprietary products.
A. Phase 1: Product Development/Product Architecture
The first phase of Intermountainās proprietary product
development is the development phase or project architecture phase. In
the development phase Intermountain conceptualizes the product it
intends to design and fabricate.
At the outset of the project, Intermountain evaluates one or more
alternatives regarding the appropriate design and architecture of the
product. Intermountain undertakes a design process that involves
forming hypotheses, testing them, and adjusting them as necessary.
Intermountain also creates simulations to evaluate the feasibility of a
conceptual design.
After the completion of the initial concept design, the project
manager sends a product specification sheet to Intermountainās
stakeholders. The sheet contains more detail regarding the proposed
design and initial diagramming.
B. Phase 2: First-Level Prototype Design
The second phase of Intermountainās product development
process is to create a first-level prototype. To be able to review and test
a first-level prototype, Intermountain uses software that tests all the
inputs and outputs in the electronics and makes sure that all the
electronics function properly.
Once Intermountain has an initial design, it creates a schematic
design for its first-level prototype. The 3āD modeling is completed by a
mechanical engineer or draftsman with computer-aided design and
drafting (CADD) software. Once completed, the drawing goes to an
Intermountain employee, Dale Curtis, who oversees Intermountainās
internal research and development department. He works on all of
Intermountainās proprietary products. The design is then input into a
circuit board design program to graphically design the circuit board.
The 3āD modeling software resolves some but not all
uncertainties surrounding product feasibility. The software does not tell
10
[*10] the designer whether the electrical componentry is going to
interact appropriately or whether its initial electrical design is
functional. Although Intermountain creates 3āD models for all the
important components in a product, other elements of the product (such
as wiring) are often excluded from the model.
Mechanical design has a direct effect on the electrical design of a
product. If spaces are too narrow, electrical components can create an
electric arc. The Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) of the
U.S. Department of Labor has strict safety standards regarding the level
at which electric currents may leak into one another, to avoid the
creation of hazardous conditions.
Once the 3āD model is approved, Intermountain converts that
model from a 3āD perspective to a 2āD drawing. The 2āD drawings are
then prepared for approval and phase two prototype fabrication.
C. Phase 3: Second-Level Prototype Fabrication
The next phase is what Intermountain refers to as the āP2
Development Phase.ā In the development of the second-level prototype,
Intermountain evaluates all the data that it gathered from the design
and review of the first-level prototype to make all the necessary design
modifications. Before Intermountain begins fabrication of the second-
level prototype, they run calculations and use computer simulations on
the circuits to test the engineering.
Intermountain tests the second-level prototype using an āalpha
release code,ā which is testing software with all relevant functions and
features built into it. Throughout this phase, Intermountain thoroughly
evaluates and tests the second-level prototype while also making
improvements. Intermountain then fabricates the second-level
prototypes, assembles them, tests them, and finds any mistakes in its
design. The team sometimes repeats the process until the second-level
prototype passes its final functional review and the team is ready to
obtain approvals.
D. Phase 4: Pre-Production Review
The fourth phase of Intermountainās product development design
process is the Pre-Production and Approvals phase. This phase involves
preparing the product for release. A product can take years to go from
phase 1 to the pre-production phase. It is not uncommon for
Intermountain to discover additional material failures in the product at
11
[*11] this phase, which would then require returning to the proverbial
drawing board to improve the design.
E. Final MSHA Approval Requirements
Before Intermountain can introduce a newly designed product
into the stream of commerce, MSHA must approve it. To meet MSHA
requirements, Intermountain relies on simulations and its familiarity
with MSHA requirements.
IV. Financial Data Tracking
During the years in issue, Intermountain used Enterprise
Resource Planning (ERP) to track financial data by using a single
system to account for every project, order, quote, and invoice that was
generated. ERP maintained both contractor costs and supply
expenditures. The system allowed Intermountain to track costs from
when a product, component, or material was either purchased, received,
or added to a job. Intermountain used an ERP system called Epicor to
track and generate every project, order, quote, and invoice. Hourly
employees did not enter time into Epicor before a project was released
to the production floor. Engineers typically did not log their time in
Epicor. Salaried employees did not have any time tracking
requirements.
V. alliantgroup Study
For the years in issue, Intermountain hired alliantgroup, LP
(alliantgroup), a tax consulting firm, to conduct a section 41 research
credit study. Intermountain provided financial records and
documentation to alliantgroup to substantiate and quantify the
amounts of qualified research expenditures incurred for 2010 through
2015, inclusive. These financial records included the gross salaries of its
employees. Intermountain provided alliantgroup with explanations for
multiple projects.
After reviewing the provided records, alliantgroup used a
statistical sampling method to determine the amounts of
Intermountainās activities that might count as qualified research during
the years in issue. Once the sample was drawn, alliantgroup conducted
interviews with representatives of Intermountain. The people who were
interviewed had experience overseeing a particular project or historical
knowledge of a project. After estimating the amount of qualified
research, alliantgroup quantified its findings in a calculation summary.
12
[*12] This summary included a chart summarizing the gross salaries of
Intermountainās employees and the qualifying research expenditures.
The record does not contain a study for 2015; however, the
corporate representative for alliantgroup testified that alliantgroup
performed a study for that year.
VI. Amended Returns and Audit
Relying on the alliantgroup reports, Intermountain amended its
2012 through 2015 tax returns to claim research credits. Intermountain
claimed the following credits or carryforwards for each year:
Tax Year Research Credit Claimed
2012 $1,458,436
2013 1,526,866
2014 1,559,625
2015 1,118,811
The Commissioner selected Intermountainās tax returns for 2012
through 2015 for examination. On April 19, 2019, the Commissioner
issued a notice of deficiency to Intermountain, disallowing research
credits and credit carryforwards, and determined the following
deficiencies:
Tax Year Deficiency
2012 $880,433
2013 1,051,499
2014 498,847
2015 873,332
Intermountain timely filed a Petition with this Court for
redetermination of the deficiencies.
13
[*13] VII. Trial Projects
During the years in issue, Intermountain generated expenses for
thousands of projects for which they claimed research credits. Given the
number of projects for which petitioner claimed research credits, the
parties agreed to present at trial a sample of twelve research projects
(trial projects). Our conclusions with respect to these trial projects are
not binding as to the remaining research projects. Rather, it is the
Courtās expectation that this Opinion will enable the parties to mutually
resolve the credits for the remaining projects. See Phx. Design Grp., Inc.
v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2024-113, at *10ā11.
The parties each selected six projects for a total of twelve projects.
These projects are individually labeled by Intermountainās internal
reference numbers: 20047X, 205662, 209564-1-1, 209873-1-1, 210464-1-
1, 210554-1-1, 208277-2-1, 024649-1-1, 206901-1-1, 69545, RD-0000,
and RD-0009. In a stipulation of settled issues, the Commissioner noted
that he does not stipulate the extrapolation of the results of the trial
projects to all of petitionerās projects during the years in issue.
A. Project 20047X: Hillsboro Longwall Project
1. Longwall Mining
In general, there are two kinds of underground mining:
continuous and longwall mining. Continuous mining systems mine coal
or other minerals by drilling straight into the rock with small machines.
Conversely, longwall mining systems mine seams of coal or other
minerals with a machine that passes in front of the coal and shaves it
away layer by layer. The seam of coal a longwall system mines is called
a longwall face. Longwall faces are generally the length of a city block
and can range from 1,000 feet to a mile wide.
A longwall mining system is highly mechanized. At the cutting
edge is a āshearer,ā which can include either one or two cutting heads
studded with pegs, spikes, or blades, referred to as ābits.ā Beneath the
entire path of the shearer is a āface conveyor,ā a conveyor belt that
catches the coal that is sheared off the wall. The face conveyor
transports the mined materials to a āhead gateā where it falls onto a
āstage loader.ā A stage loader is another conveyor that is at 90 degrees
to the face conveyor. A crushing device on the stage loader pulverizes
the coal before it continues to the main line conveyor up to the surface.
14
[*14] Above the track of the shearer and conveyor belt are ceiling
shields controlled by hydraulic power. The shields are numerous and set
side by side along the coal block. The shields use large hydraulic rams
to support the roof and prevent the roof from collapsing into the mining
area. As the shearer passes the shield, it creates a void of unsupported
ceiling. The shields must then reposition themselves to the newly
exposed coal face.
2. Intermountainās Experience with Longwall Mining
Project 20047X, the Hillsboro Longwall project, was the first
longwall mining system Intermountain produced. It was completed in
2012. The Hillsboro Longwall project included various subprojects.
Although this was the first longwall mining system produced by
Intermountain, it had experience working on longwall mining
equipment before undertaking the Hillsboro Longwall Project. Between
2009 and 2012, Intermountain was exposed to longwall mining projects
through repair and rebuilding projects for a variety of clients. Since as
early as 1985, Intermountain has maintained electrical components for
longwall systems. Additionally, it had been rebuilding components for
longwalls since at least 1997. Intermountainās prior custom electrical
equipment works for longwall systems included bringing longwall
machinery into its facilities to overhaul, update, or redesign its electrical
systems. Intermountain also had experience rebuilding power centers,
working on master controllers, and fixing or rebuilding several parts for
longwall systems.
3. Hillsboro Longwall Mining Project
Hillsboro Energy (Hillsboro) hired Intermountain to design and
build a complete underground longwall system. Hillsboro wanted
Intermountain to build an electrical system that powered the face
conveyor, the stage loader, the crusher, and all the safety systems within
those electrical systems. During the bidding process, Hillsboro Energy
provided Intermountain with information about necessary features of
the final product. Hillsboro and Intermountain worked together to
develop ideas for new functions and features that could be used to create
an improved longwall system. The design of the final product was not
clear to Intermountain at the outset of the project.
After the initial meetings, Intermountain presented a
preliminary design to Hillsboro. Hillsboro provided Intermountain with
basic product constraints but did not specify the design of the final
15
[*15] product. After Hillsboro transmitted these constraints,
Intermountain began designing the final product.
4. Project Design
Intermountainās design needed to resolve a variety of problems
Hillsboro was facing with its longwall mining operation. Solutions to one
problem would sometimes yield new obstacles, which would require a
design process to resolve. We will address each of the problems and its
corresponding solution.
a. CAT Tracks and Monorail System
A longwall mining system requires equipment to deliver
electricity to the system. This equipment is typically located at the mine
headgate and includes several separate housing units for transformers
and other electrical devices. As the shearer progresses, it travels further
from the otherwise stationary electrifying equipment. Periodically, the
electrifying equipment must move closer to the shearer.
Before enlisting Intermountain, Hillsboroās process to move this
electrifying equipment was labor intensive. Hillsboro attached steel
beams to the bottom of the housing units, and laborers would haul the
units in what amounted to a āgame of leapfrog.ā Additionally, Hillsboroās
system attached cables or hydraulic lines to a monorail on the ceiling,
which operated as a festoon system. Moving the cables and hydraulic
equipment was a labor-intensive operation that required workers to pull
down cables weighing twenty-five pounds per foot and rehang them.
To solve this issue, Intermountain proposed self-propelling
electrical housing units. The design would add continuous tracks of
interconnected metal plates that wrap around wheels, referred to as
CAT tracks, to the bottom of the housing units of the longwall train. The
tracks would propel the equipment alongside the shearing mechanism
without the need for additional intervention.
The train would have five cars: a 3-megavolt power center, a 9-
megavolt power center, a starter car, a variable frequency drive car, and
a production car. Intermountain affixed CAT tracks to only some cars,
while the others just had wheels. After calculating the weight of the
train, Intermountain determined the longwall train would also need
another engine. The train moved at 4 to 5 miles per hour and could be
steered via remote control. Intermountain designed the CAT tracks and
wheels to function even given the unlevel nature of a mine floor and the
16
[*16] presence of debris. The design included heavy duty connecting
devices to attach each of the cars to one another.
Intermountain first planned the electrical details, such as the
number of cars needed in the train and what equipment could be fit into
each car. After the initial electrical layout began, Intermountain
involved the mechanical engineering design team to incorporate
automation into the design.
The monorail system was designed to be mounted to the ceiling,
from which equipment would hang from rollers overhead. The system
was made of a six-inch steel I-beam that runs for miles down the
entryway of the longwall system to the mouth of the mining section. The
stage loader, the transformer, and variable frequency drive sections
were hooked to the monorail system by cables and moved with the
monorail system. The whole train of cars moved in unison with the
monorail. This alleviated the need for workers to physically move the
festooned cables, because the cables are attached to the longwall train.
This project represented Intermountainās first design integrating
CAT tracks into a longwall system. Pat Lemmon, Intermountainās
project manager for this project, had experience with CAT tracks in
other contexts.
b. Hydraulic Pressure
Hillsboroās prior system did not deliver constant pressure to its
shields when moving. To solve this problem, Hillsboro and
Intermountain discussed the possibility of adding a variable frequency
drive to control the longwall pump. Integrating a variable frequency
drive into the pump system was a challenge for Intermountain. A
variable frequency drive takes input voltage, converts it, and puts out a
variable voltage and frequency to control a motor at a desired speed.
This process generates a significant amount of heat.
The variable frequency drive systems Intermountain used in the
Hillsboro project were relatively large at six feet tall. The mining
conditions placed sizing constraints on the design, which required
Intermountain to design the variable frequency drive to be horizontal,
creating additional heat. Intermountainās design had to account for that
additional heat.
17
[*17] c. Coal Spillover
Another problem was that the main line conveyors would often
become overloaded with mining materials. Overloaded conveyor systems
lead to spillage, which creates excess waste, inefficiency, and MSHA
violations. Coal was overflowing because Hillsboro could not control the
rate at which the conveyor system transported the coal coming off the
rock face.
To solve the spillover issue, Intermountain introduced a variable
frequency drive into the system. By delivering power to the stage loader
at any desired frequency, Hillsboro could control the rate of the stage
loader and, thus, control the flow of coal to the mainline conveyor.
d. Custom Transformers and Safety
Intermountain custom designed a 9,000 kilovolt transformer,
which was integrated into the 9 megavolt power center. Because of size
constraints, Intermountain designed the 9,000 kilovolt transformer to
be split across three parts, each containing 3,000 kilovolt transformers.
The core assemblies were then interconnected to act as one 9 megavolt
transformer.
The electrical design of the 9 megavolt power center went through
a minimum of 10 revisions. The mechanical design of the 9 megavolt
power center went through twice as many design drawing revisions
because the mechanical design changes when the electrical design
changes. The design of the 9 megavolt power center also depended on
the design of the starter car.
Intermountain also designed the controller, the ābrains of the
system.ā The controller is located at the head gate and acts as an
interface between the operators and the equipment. The controller
provides vital readings on pump pressure, which equipment was on or
off, and the current on the tail drive. Most of the safety components are
in the controller. If there were any changes to the mechanical or
electrical design of other longwall components, it would affect the design
of the controller.
Intermountain included an additional custom feature in the
variable frequency drive power cars and the starter car to permit
maintenance without interrupting mining. Intermountain developed an
innovative design for what it called ādraw-out drawers.ā Draw-out
drawers included controls on a panel that would swing out and allow
18
[*18] access to the back of the cabinet. Intermountain built spare
circuits so that workers could access the drawers without interrupting
the longwall operation.
As the electrical design was developed, Intermountain had
several requirements to monitor. It had to ensure compliance with
MSHA standards, make preliminary calculations, and determine how
the components would work together electrically and mechanically.
Intermountain would enlist an employee who was unfamiliar with the
electrical design to conduct an independent review comparing the
original bill of materials to the electrical schematics to determine
discrepancies.
5. Project Testing
Intermountain ran a series of simulations to check for failures in
the system. In