Cuevas Machine v. Calgon Carbon
CourtCourt of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
Date FiledNovember 19, 2026
Docket25-60198
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Case: 25-60198 Document: 81-1 Page: 1 Date Filed: 11/19/2026
United States Court of Appeals
for the Fifth Circuit United States Court of Appeals
____________ Fifth Circuit
FILED
No. 25-60198 November 19, 2026
____________
Thomas B. Plunkett, III
Clerk
Cuevas Machine Company, Incorporated,
Plaintiff—Appellant,
versus
Calgon Carbon Corporation,
Defendant—Appellee.
______________________________
Appeal from the United States District Court
for the Southern District of Mississippi
USDC No. 1:24-CV-114
______________________________
Before Elrod, Chief Judge, and Smith and Wilson, Circuit Judges.
Cory T. Wilson, Circuit Judge:
This case concerns the requirements for the creation of a valid
construction lien under Mississippi law. Cuevas Machine Company sued
Calgon Carbon Corporation seeking to foreclose on two construction liens
totaling $1.23 million. The liens themselves did not provide the “date the
claim was due” (i.e., the “last date [that] labor, services or materials were
supplied to the premises”), as required by Mississippi law. Cuevas attached
a series of dated invoices to the liens, but it is unclear what the dates signified.
Case: 25-60198 Document: 81-1 Page: 2 Date Filed: 11/19/2026
No. 25-60198
Unsure how Mississippi’s lien law would apply in this context, we
sought guidance from the Mississippi Supreme Court as to whether Cuevas’s
liens were enforceable in light of the dated invoices. The Mississippi
Supreme Court has now answered that question in the negative.
Accordingly, we affirm the district court’s ruling, which likewise held that
the liens were not enforceable. 1
In March 2025, the district court dismissed Cuevas’s complaint with
prejudice because its construction liens did not comply with Miss. Code
Ann. § 85-7-405(1)(b). Making an Erie 2 guess, the district court held that
(1) Cuevas’s lien documents did not specify the “last date [that] labor,
services or materials were supplied to the premises,” and (2) the attached
invoices 3 did not specify the relevant dates clearly enough to render the liens
substantially compliant with the statute. Cuevas appealed.
Considering the issue, we expressed uncertainty about “whether a
lienor may establish the ‘last date’ on which labor, services, or materials were
provided—as required to create a valid construction lien—by attaching
invoices that do not clearly identify such a ‘last date.’” Cuevas Mach. Co.,
173 F.4th at 224. To resolve any doubt about the correct application of
Mississippi’s construction lien statute, we certified the following question to
the Mississippi Supreme Court:
_____________________
1
Both this panel’s April 15, 2026 opinion and the Mississippi Supreme Court’s
opinion contain a full recitation of the facts. See Cuevas Mach. Co. v. Calgon Carbon Corp.,
173 F.4th 222, 224 (5th Cir. 2026); Cuevas Mach. Co., Inc. v. Calgon Carbon Corp., No.
2026-FC-00451-SCT, --- So. 3d ----, 2026 WL 3081641, *1–2 (Miss. Oct. 15, 2026).
2
See Erie R.R. Co. v. Tompkins, 304 U.S. 64, 78 (1938).
3
Cuevas recorded one lien against Calgon for $763,245, and another for $471,661.
See Cuevas Mach. Co., 173 F.4th at 224.
2
Case: 25-60198 Document: 81-1 Page: 3 Date Filed: 11/19/2026
No. 25-60198
If a lienor attaches[4] dated invoices to a construction lien, but
these invoices do not plainly indicate the “the last date the
labor, services or materials were supplied to the premises,” do
the attachments nonetheless satisfy the requirement that an
enforceable lien “specify the date the claim was due” under
Miss. Code Ann. § 85-7-405(1)(b)?
Id. at 228. On October 15, 2026, the Mississippi Supreme Court answered
the certified question in the negative:
If . . . these invoices do not plainly indicate “the last date the
labor, services or materials were supplied to the premises,” the
attachments do not nonetheless satisfy the requirement that an
enforceable lien “specify the date the claim was due” under
Section 85-7-405(1)(b).
Cuevas Mach. Co., 2026 WL 3081641, at *8 (emphasis added). The
Mississippi Supreme Court’s thorough analysis of this issue “control[s] [the
outcome of] this case[.]” See Cuevas Mach. Co., 173 F.4th at 228.
Cuevas seeks to enforce two construction liens for fabrication and
machining services it provided at Calgon’s filtration plant. Neither of those
liens specifies “the last date the labor, services or materials were supplied to
the premises.” Miss. Code Ann. § 85-7-405(1)(b). And the invoices
attached to the liens, though carrying various dates, cannot bring the liens
into compliance because the dates are fatally ambiguous—it is unclear
_____________________
4
We considered “whether the information required to be included in a valid lien
may be supplied by reference to incorporated attachments as opposed to being set forth in the
body of the lien itself.” Cuevas Mach. Co., 173 F.4th at 226 (emphasis added). Although
the Mississippi Supreme Court had not answered this question, we concluded that the
statute’s text and relevant case law suggested that there was no “four corners”
requirement (i.e., attached materials were relevant to statutory compliance). See id. We
did not certify this issue to the Mississippi Supreme Court. See id. at 228; see also Cuevas
Mach. Co., 2026 WL 3081641, *4 (acknowledging that the court did not include this issue
in the question certified).
3
Case: 25-60198 Document: 81-1 Page: 4 Date Filed: 11/19/2026
No. 25-60198
whether the dates reflect when the invoiced services were provided, when
Cuevas generated the invoices themselves, or some other occurrence.
The invoices attached to the liens mention eight different dates but no
explicit explanation of what these dates signify. See Cuevas Mach. Co., 2026
WL 3081641, *6. This is undisputed. Id. at *4. Thus, applying the
Mississippi Supreme Court’s definitive reading of § 85-7-405(1)(b), the
invoices do not specify “the last date the labor, services or materials were
supplied to the premises.” See Wilson v. State, 194 So. 3d 855, 868 (Miss.
2016) (“The Court has no business amending or disregarding statutes.”); see
also Zepeda v. Fed. Home Loan Mortg. Corp., 967 F.3d 456, 458 (5th Cir. 2020)
(the Supreme Court of Texas’s “definitive and authoritative answer” to the
certified question was “binding”).
In light of the decision by the Mississippi Supreme Court, we
AFFIRM the district court’s judgment dismissing Cuevas’s complaint with
prejudice.
4