PPG Industries, Inc. v. Westlake Corporation
CourtCourt of Chancery of Delaware
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
DocketC.A. No. 2024-0648-NAC
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
PPG INDUSTRIES, INC.,
Plaintiff,
v. C.A. No. 2024-0648-NAC
WESTLAKE CORPORATION, AXIALL
CORPORATION, WESTLAKE US 2
LLC (f/k/a EAGLE US 2 LLC), and
EAGLE SPINCO INC.,
Defendants.
POST-TRIAL MEMORANDUM OPINION
Date Submitted: August 4, 2026
Date Decided: November 18, 2026
David A. Dorey, Gregory P. Ranzini, BLANK ROME LLP, Wilmington, Delaware;
Andrew Fletcher, Jason Snyderman, John A. Gibbons, BLANK ROME LLP,
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; Counsel for Plaintiff and Counterclaim Defendant PPG
Industries, Inc.
Jennifer C. Wasson, Tyler E. Cragg, POTTER ANDERSON & CORROON LLP,
Wilmington, Delaware; William R. H. Merrill, Ryan V. Caughey, Ace M. Factor,
Alexxa Leon, SUSMAN GODFREY LLP, Houston, Texas; David B. Goodwin,
Christine S. Haskett, COVINGTON & BURLING LLP, San Francisco, California;
Counsel for Defendants and Counterclaim Plaintiffs Westlake Corporation, Axiall
Corporation, Westlake US 2 LLC (f/k/a Eagle US 2 LLC), and Eagle Spinco Inc.
COOK, V.C.
In 1998, cargo ship DG Harmony caught fire off the coast of Brazil. After
attempting to fight the flames, the crew abandoned ship, and the fire destroyed the
vessel and most of its cargo. A flurry of lawsuits followed. In a consolidated action,
the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York found that
calcium hypochlorite manufactured by PPG Industries, Inc. caused the fire. PPG
settled the claims for $81.5 million, with insurance contributing $56.5 million after
PPG satisfied a $25 million self-insured retention amount.
In 2006, Di Gregório Navegação Ltda. (“Di Gregorio”)—a Brazilian cargo
transportation company that sub-chartered the DG Harmony—filed a lawsuit against
PPG in Brazil. Despite being named in the consolidated New York action, Di Gregorio
never appeared. In 2009, the New York court entered an order of default judgment
against Di Gregorio, specifically enjoining the Brazil lawsuit. Notwithstanding the
New York court’s order, the Di Gregorio litigation in Brazil continued, and, in 2010,
the Brazil court found PPG liable against Di Gregorio.
In 2013, PPG spun off its commodity chemicals business through a transaction
involving Georgia Gulf Corporation, later renamed Axiall Corporation. The
transaction was governed by a series of agreements, including a Separation
Agreement and a Contribution Agreement. Those agreements addressed the transfer
of assets and assumption of liabilities, the parties’ indemnification rights and
obligations, and their rights and responsibilities concerning insurance. As relevant
here, the Separation Agreement allocated responsibility for the Di Gregorio litigation
to entities in the spun-off business. And PPG retained the insurance policies
potentially covering the Di Gregorio litigation.
For years after the transaction, the spun-off entities defended the Di Gregorio
litigation and communicated with PPG’s insurers, including submitting invoices for
defense costs. In 2023 and 2024, the Di Gregorio litigation was coming to a head. A
decision on damages was imminent, and everyone started taking positions. Despite
years of communication—including about strategy and settlement—the insurers
refused to engage with the spun-off entities without an assignment from PPG, and
they denied coverage for the Di Gregorio litigation. PPG refused to assign any rights
to the insurance until any judgment in the Di Gregorio litigation was satisfied. The
spun-off entities demanded an assignment before they would pay anything in the Di
Gregorio litigation.
In May 2024, the Brazil court entered a substantial damages award against
PPG. The next month, PPG filed this action asking the Court to order the spun-off
entities and their subsequent acquirer (collectively, Defendants here) to substitute
PPG out of the Di Gregorio litigation and post a bond or satisfy the judgment.
Defendants countered, asking the Court to order PPG to assign insurance rights to
them.
This decision denies PPG’s requests for specific performance and grants
Defendants’ in part. Even assuming PPG has proven a breach of contract, it has not
shown, by clear and convincing evidence, that specific performance is appropriate.
PPG waited to request substitution for 11 years after the spinoff, and it would violate
2
principles of comity for this Court to order Defendants to take any action in the Di
Gregorio litigation when that litigation was specifically enjoined by the New York
court’s 2009 order. Defendants are entitled to an assignment of insurance proceeds,
but, under the Separation Agreement’s terms, only for the costs of defending PPG in
the Di Gregorio litigation that they have already incurred and paid.
The parties agree that the spun-off entities are ultimately responsible for any
enforceable judgment and related losses. And Defendants continue to defend the Di
Gregorio litigation and have committed to hold PPG harmless against any attempts
to enforce the Di Gregorio judgment. The parties also agree that the spun-off entities
are entitled to an assignment of insurance proceeds at some point. Boiled down, the
parties tussle over the logistics of their contractual obligations, with the crux of the
dispute concerning sequencing and timing. Like colleagues arriving at the entrance
to the office, PPG and Defendants are dancing over who goes first and who will hold
the door. In the end, they’ll both make it inside.
I. FACTUAL BACKGROUND
The following facts were stipulated to by the parties or proven by a
preponderance of the evidence at trial. 1
1 See Dkt. 147, Pre-Trial Stipulation and Order (”PTO”). The trial record includes live
testimony from two fact witnesses and four experts, 234 joint exhibits, and three deposition
transcripts. Trial testimony is cited as “TT [Page]:[Lines] (Name).” See Dkts. 179–80.
Exhibits are cited by the numbers provided on the parties’ joint exhibit list as “JX ,” unless
otherwise defined. See Dkt. 170. Pincites refer to pagination stamped with the parties’ joint
exhibit numbers. Deposition transcripts are cited as “[Name] Dep. [Page]:[Lines].”
3
A. The Parties
Plaintiff PPG Industries, Inc. is an industrial conglomerate based in
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Through a Separation Agreement dated July 18, 2012, 2
PPG agreed to spin off its commodity chemicals business in a transaction (the
“Spinoff”) with Georgia Gulf Corporation, which was subsequently renamed Axiall
Corporation.
Defendant Eagle Spinco Inc. was PPG’s counterparty to the Separation
Agreement and is a wholly owned subsidiary of Axiall. 3
Defendant Eagle US 2 LLC (now Westlake US 2 LLC) is a subsidiary of Eagle
Spinco. 4 Eagle US 2 was a party to the Contribution Agreement dated January 22,
2013, with PPG as its counterparty. 5 The purpose of the Contribution Agreement
was “solely to effect the transfer of” assets and liabilities contemplated by the
Separation Agreement. 6
Defendant Axiall Corporation is Eagle Spinco’s parent company. Axiall
acquired Eagle Spinco in 2013. This decision refers to Axiall, Eagle US 2, and Eagle
Spinco as the “Spinco Group.”
2 JX 23.
3 PTO ¶ 2.
4 Id. ¶ 3.
5 JX 41.
6 Id. § 1.2.
4
Defendant Westlake Corporation is Axiall’s, Eagle Spinco’s, and Eagle US 2’s
ultimate parent company. 7 Westlake acquired Axiall in 2016. 8 Westlake is not a
party to the Separation or Contribution Agreements. This decision refers to Westlake
and the Spinco Group as “Defendants.” 9
B. The DG Harmony Fire and Ensuing Litigation
In November 1998, an explosion occurred aboard the container ship DG
Harmony off the coast of Brazil. 10 The explosion caused a total loss of the ship and
its cargo. Among DG Harmony’s cargo was PPG-manufactured calcium
hypochlorite. 11 Following the DG Harmony fire, numerous parties sued PPG,
alleging that its calcium hypochlorite caused the explosion and subsequent fire. The
claims were consolidated in the United States District Court for the Southern District
of New York. In 2009, the court entered a judgment, finding PPG liable for the
7 PTO ¶ 5.
8 JX 92; JX 98.
9 As explained below, however, the Court concludes that Westlake is not a proper
defendant in this action.
10 PTO ¶ 15.
11 Id. ¶ 16.
5
explosion and the resulting fire. 12 PPG eventually settled the lawsuits for
approximately $81.5 million. 13
C. The Di Gregorio Litigation
On January 11, 2006, Di Gregório Navegação Ltda (“Di Gregorio”)—a Brazilian
cargo transportation company that sub-chartered the DG Harmony—filed a lawsuit
against PPG in the 13th Civil and Work Accident Court of the District of Manaus,
State of Amazonas, Brazil (the “Di Gregorio Litigation”). 14 PPG hired the Brazilian
law firm Mattos Filho, Veiga Filho, Marrey Jr. e Quiroga Advogados (“Mattos Filho”)
as defense counsel in the Di Gregorio Litigation. 15
Di Gregorio was a named party in the consolidated New York litigation but did
not appear. 16 In June 2006, PPG filed a lawsuit against Di Gregorio in the Southern
District of New York, seeking to enjoin the Di Gregorio Litigation. 17 On October 28,
2009, the New York court entered a default judgment in PPG’s favor, declaring that
PPG was not liable to Di Gregorio and enjoining Di Gregorio from pursuing any
12 PTO ¶¶ 17–18. For a comprehensive recitation of these facts, see In re M/V DG
Harmony, 394 F. Supp. 2d 649 (S.D.N.Y. 2005), opinion clarified, 2007 WL 895251 (S.D.N.Y.
Mar. 16, 2007), and aff’d in part, vacated in part, rev’d in part, 533 F.3d 83 (2d Cir. 2008).
13 TT 162:2–10 (Bloch).
14 PTO ¶¶ 19, 21.
15 Id. ¶ 22; JX 10.
16 PTO ¶ 20.
17 JX 11.
6
claims against PPG for losses arising from the DG Harmony fire (the “SDNY
Order”). 18 The SDNY Order expressly enjoined the Di Gregorio Litigation. 19
Notwithstanding the SDNY Order, the Brazil court allowed the Di Gregorio
Litigation to proceed and, in January 2010, entered judgment against PPG in the
liability phase of the litigation. 20 PPG appealed the liability finding but was
unsuccessful. 21
At the time of the DG Harmony fire, PPG maintained an insurance tower
worth $350 million, subject to a $25 million self-insured retention. 22 PPG notified its
insurers about the DG Harmony fire and submitted insurance claims for liabilities
arising from it, including the Di Gregorio Litigation. 23 Before the Separation
Agreement was executed in 2012, PPG had received about $56.5 million in
reimbursement from its insurance for DG Harmony-related losses. 24 Just under $300
18 JX 12.
19 Id.
20 PTO ¶ 24.
21 Id. ¶¶ 25–28.
22 JX 1–9; JX 147; TT 135:12-18, 161:6-22 (Bloch).
23 TT 131:1–10 (Bloch).
24 Id. 162:2–10 (Bloch); see also JX 13; JX 14; JX 73.
7
million of insurance remains available under PPG’s applicable insurance policy. And
the Di Gregorio Litigation is the only remaining open claim under that policy. 25
D. The Spinoff
In 2012, while the Di Gregorio Litigation was proceeding, PPG agreed to spin
off and sell its chlor-alkali, derivatives, and other commodity chemicals business to
Georgia Gulf (now Axiall) through a series of agreements, including, as relevant here,
the Separation Agreement and the Contribution Agreement.
Through the Separation Agreement, PPG agreed to transfer certain assets to
Eagle Spinco, and Eagle Spinco agreed to assume certain liabilities, with the
remaining assets and liabilities to be retained by PPG. 26 The Contribution
Agreement effectuated the transfer of the assets and liabilities to Eagle US 2 (an
Eagle Spinco subsidiary) in accordance with the terms of the Separation
Agreement. 27
Among the liabilities Eagle US 2 assumed under the Separation Agreement
was the Di Gregorio Litigation (the “Di Gregorio Liability”). 28 According to the
25 TT162:17–24 (Bloch); id. 383:4–7 (Posner); id. 539:3–15 (Baker); McClain Dep.
162:17–165:9.
26 See JX 23 at 6.
27 JX 41 § 1.2.
28 See JX 23 §§ 2.5(a)(i), (ix), (xi).
The Di Gregorio Litigation is also included in the
list of transferred “Spinco Assets.” JX 23 § 2.4(a)(xiii) (“all rights to causes of Action, lawsuits,
judgments, claims and demands that are, in each case, related primarily to the Eagle
Business, including those listed or described on Schedule 2.4(a)(xiii)[.]”); JX 24.12 (listing the
Di Gregorio Litigation in the schedule of open matters); see also Dkt. 184, Defendants Post-
Trial Opening Brief (“Defs. PTOB”) at 56 (“Defendants have admitted, during discovery and
8
insurance experts who testified at trial, the industry norm is that the rights to
insurance policies follow the liabilities they cover. 29 The Separation Agreement
departed from this norm. Instead of following the Di Gregorio Liability, the insurance
policy covering the Di Gregorio Liability remained with PPG as an excluded asset
under the Separation Agreement. 30
Although PPG retained its rights to insurance policies, the parties negotiated
a carve-out that imposed on PPG the obligation to pursue coverage under relevant
policies using commercially reasonable efforts. 31 The parties also separately
addressed the interplay between indemnification and insurance, providing that the
potential availability of insurance not permit delay of indemnification. 32 Further to
this concept, the parties agreed that an indemnifying party would be entitled to an
assignment of PPG’s claim for insurance proceeds upon payment of indemnification
and expressed an overarching intent that no provision of the Separation Agreement
result in a “windfall” for insurers or relieve insurers of the obligation to provide
coverage. 33
then at trial, that Eagle US 2 assumed the Di Gregorio liability, subject to the terms and
conditions of the Separation Agreement.”).
29 TT 378:12–19, 379:12–17 (Posner); id. 563:10–17 (Baker).
30 JX 23 § 2.4(b)(iv).
31 Id. § 6.11(a); accord id. § 5.4(b).
32 Id. § 5.4(b).
33 Id.
9
On December 14, 2012, in anticipation of the Spinoff, PPG’s in-house counsel
informed PPG’s insurers that the Di Gregorio Litigation “will become the
responsibility of [Eagle Spinco]” and explained that PPG “envision[s] that the carriers
will continue to reimburse or pay directly defense and indemnity costs in the open
matters.” 34 The Spinoff closed on January 28, 2013. 35 Diana Reed—the in-house
attorney who had been overseeing the Di Gregorio Litigation at PPG—moved to
Axiall and continued to manage the defense of the Di Gregorio Litigation. 36 PPG did
not ask Axiall to substitute itself or one of its subsidiaries as the named defendant in
the Di Gregorio Litigation.
In August 2016, Westlake acquired Axiall and its subsidiaries through a
reverse triangular merger. 37 Reed moved to Westlake and continued managing the
defense of the Di Gregorio Litigation. 38 Mattos Filho continued to represent PPG in
Brazil at Westlake’s direction. 39 PPG still did not request substitution of Westlake
or one of its subsidiaries as the named defendant in the Di Gregorio Litigation.
34 JX 37.
35 PTO ¶ 6.
36 TT 242:22–243:16; 248:4–21 (Kroger).
37 PTO ¶ 13; JX 92; JX 97.
38 TT 242:22–243:16; 248:4–21 (Kroger).
39 Id. 316:13–16 (Kroger).
10
E. Westlake and Mattos Filho Discuss Potential Substitution of PPG as
the Defendant in the Di Gregorio Litigation
On April 20, 2021, Mattos Filho emailed Richard Kroger, assistant general
counsel at Westlake, seeking clarification about “the nature of the succession, from
PPG, to Axiall and [then] to Westlake.” 40 “More specifically,” Mattos Filho asked
“whether it is correct that the proceedings should continue to be conducted in the
name of PPG?” 41 The answer to this question was “of particular relevance [to Mattos
Filho] in the event that an award of damages is made in favor of Di Gregorio, as PPG
would be the company obliged to satisfy that award[.]” 42 Mattos Filho also noted that
“any assets [PPG] has in Brazil” could be at risk and flagged that “PPG has a
Brazilian subsidiary, PPG Industrial do Brasil Ltda.” 43
The next day, Eva Gregory of Westlake responded to Mattos Filho, explaining
the 2013 Spinoff and Westlake’s acquisition of Axiall in 2016. Gregory confirmed that
“liability for the claims asserted against PPG [in the Di Gregorio Litigation] rests
with Axiall/Westlake.” 44 While leaving the ultimate decision on substitution to
Kroger, Gregory stated that “[w]e [Westlake] still have active lawsuits in the name
40 JX 124.
41 Id. (emphasis removed).
42 Id.
As explained below, the level of risk to PPG’s Brazilian subsidiary is speculative
43 Id.
and was not established by the evidence and testimony presented at trial.
44 Id.
11
of PPG[,] and we are keeping them in the name of PPG until they are resolved.” 45
Kroger followed up:
Eva is correct in her explanation. I think the lawsuit should continue
in PPG’s name. Even though Westlake is the ultimate successor in
interest to the liability, it seems to me that PPG is still the correct entity
to be party to the proceeding. They were the responsible party then, and
this suit (along with many others we have) are continuing in their name,
even though Westlake is overseeing the action and is responsible for
resolving at the end of the day. 46
Mattos Filho responded: “[i]n light of these [explanations], we agree that the
proceedings should continue in the name of PPG (and, indeed, that will save
unnecessary disruption in the proceedings).” 47 Neither Westlake nor Mattos Filho
consulted PPG about potential substitution.
F. The Insurers Refuse to Consider Westlake’s Submissions Absent an
Assignment
From its acquisition of Axiall in 2016, Westlake regularly communicated with
PPG’s insurers about the Di Gregorio Litigation. 48 Kroger testified that the insurers
were “heavily involved” in the Di Gregorio Litigation, including strategy discussions
and settlement negotiations. 49 And Westlake had been sending the insurers invoices
45 Id.
46 Id.
47 Id.
48 TT 244:1–23, 246:5–23 (Kroger).
49 Id. 244: 1–23 (Kroger); JX 70; JX 99–102; JX 109; JX 110.
12
for defense costs in the Di Gregorio Litigation. 50 At the time of trial in this action,
Defendants had incurred over $2 million in attorneys’ fees in the Di Gregorio
Litigation following the Spinoff. 51
On January 12, 2023, the insurers sent Westlake a letter, asserting they would
not consider Westlake’s submissions of invoices in part because PPG—not Westlake—
was the named insured under the policy. 52 The insurers indicated that “if Westlake
shall present an assignment of PPG’s rights to the recovery of damages under the
policy to Insurers for their consent, . . . Insurers would duly consider the request and
would not unreasonably withhold consent.” 53
Westlake forwarded the insurers’ letter to PPG and asked “whether PPG would
be agreeable to assigning its pertinent policy rights to Westlake, so that Westlake
could pursue its claims related to the Di Gregorio matter directly with the
insurers[.]” 54 In response, PPG stated that “no insurance rights [] transferred to
Spinco” under the Separation Agreement. 55 PPG indicated its willingness “to assign
50 TT 246:24–247:13 (Kroger); JX 104–106; JX 113; JX 118; JX 121; JX 126; JX 132.
51 TT 251:17–252:4 (Kroger).
52 JX 130. The insurers also took the position that there was no payment obligation
under the policy until a settlement or final judgment was paid. Both the insurance experts
who testified at trial disagreed with this position and opined that defense costs are typically
reimbursed as they are incurred. TT 383:8–384:3 (Posner); id. 539:8–11 (Baker).
53 JX 130.
54 JX 133.
55 JX 135.
13
narrowly tailored rights under the triggered policy” on the condition that “Westlake
agree[] to reimburse PPG its proportionate share of the” $25 million self-insured
retention it had previously paid in connection with the other DG Harmony-related
claims by paying PPG 30 percent of any insurance proceeds recovered by Westlake. 56
On December 8, 2023, Kroger emailed Evan Bloch, PPG’s assistant general
counsel, asking for “a few minutes” to discuss “new developments with respect to our
1998 ship fire, Harmony, and the Di Gregorio lawsuit in Brazil.” 57 Kroger explained
that “[t]hings have not gotten better on that front[,] and the insurance issues are
more critical than ever given recent developments.” 58 Kroger and Bloch had a call
the following Monday, December 11. And on December 13, Bloch emailed Kroger
regarding “the various outstanding matters between our companies, including the Di
Gregorio/Harmony matter.” 59 Bloch indicated that “PPG [was] willing to include
Westlake’s request for an assignment of insurance rights as part of a comprehensive
settlement dialogue to resolve all outstanding issues between our companies.” 60
Bloch proposed a two-step process, including discussion about “a proposed
56 JX 145. The parties dispute whether these discussions can be relied on as evidence
of liability. The Court is not relying on this correspondence and only includes it here to give
context to the parties’ insurance dispute.
57 JX 137.
58 Id.
59 JX 139.
60 Id.
14
assignment of insurance rights specific to the Di Gregorio/Harmony claim that would
be acceptable/consented to by the insurers.” 61
Discussions between the two companies were apparently unsuccessful. On
January 22, 2024, Westlake’s outside counsel sent a letter to PPG, claiming that PPG
was in breach of the Separation Agreement and demanding that PPG “seek as much
coverage as possible in connection with the Di Gregorio litigation and any judgment
that may be entered or assign its rights to proceeds from the 1998-1999 policy year
to Westlake.” 62 The letter explained that the Brazil court “could issue a final
judgment” on damages of up to $2.6 billion “against PPG,” that “PPG will have to post
a bond” if a stay is not granted, that “Westlake is not a party to the litigation,” and
that “[i]t is in our mutual interest to pursue the maximum insurance coverage
available.” 63 In an email the next day, Bloch told Kroger “[t]his letter was not well
received at PPG” and asserted that “PPG has fully complied with its obligations under
the Separation Agreement[.]” 64
On January 31, 2024, Westlake sent another letter to PPG, “request[ing] that
PPG work with Eagle Spinco to pursue insurance coverage for the Di Gregorio
61 Id.
62 JX 145.
63 Id.
64 JX 146.
15
matter.” 65 Westlake asked PPG to “assign to Eagle Spinco (in a manner that is
satisfactory to the insurers) all rights to make claims for and to receive insurance
proceeds in connection with the Di Gregorio matter.” 66 “Alternatively,” Westlake
asked PPG to “confirm that PPG will pursue insurance coverage for any adverse
judgment and for the cost of an appeal bond, if necessary[.]” 67
G. PPG Demands Substitution in the Di Gregorio Litigation
On March 12, 2024, PPG sent a notice to Westlake, demanding that “Westlake
take immediate steps to substitute itself for PPG” in the Di Gregorio Litigation. 68
Westlake “disagree[d] with PPG’s substitution request, largely because substitution
is infeasible and impractical at this juncture.” 69 Westlake said it was “not refusing
to ‘endeavor to substitute’ in for PPG,” but would only do so if PPG would “cooperat[e]
with Westlake in pursuing claims against the insurers and assign[] PPG’s policy
rights to Westlake[.]” 70
65 JX 149.
66 Id.
67 Id.
68 JX 152.
69 JX 153.
70 Id.
16
H. The Brazil Court Issues Its Damages Decision in the Di Gregorio
Litigation
The first phase of the Di Gregorio Litigation—referred to as the “liability
phase”—ended with the June 15, 2019, final and non-appealable certification holding
PPG liable. 71 The Di Gregorio Litigation then entered the second—or “liquidation”—
phase in 2020, to determine the amount of damages. 72 Both parties, along with court-
appointed experts, submitted accounting reports to the Brazil court, and final
argument on damages was held in January 2024. 73
On May 21, 2024, the Brazil court issued its damages decision, concluding that
Di Gregorio was entitled to damages of $90,423,764, plus an additional $93,283,196
in monetary corrections and interest. 74 The Brazil court also ordered PPG to pay Di
Gregorio’s legal fees of 20 percent of the damages and a 1 percent procedural fine.
Both PPG and Di Gregorio filed subsequent appeals. 75
The day after the Brazil court issued its damages decision, Mattos Filho told
Westlake’s attorneys at Susman Godfrey LLP that “the amount of the award is
surprising to say the least.” 76 Mattos Filho also explained that “the time period for
71 TT 400:13 – 401:2 (Carmona); id. 479:1–12 (Sica).
72 PTO ¶ 24; TT 401:3–9 (Carmona); id. 479:17–480:12 (Sica).
73 PTO ¶¶ 29–35.
74 Id. ¶ 36.
75 Id. ¶¶ 38–43.
76 JX 162.
17
making payment has not yet begun to run[,] and there are a number of different
options available to PPG at this stage in terms of next steps, which we are also
considering.” 77
The following week, Westlake emailed PPG about the damages decision,
providing its estimated total damages amount of $703.85 million. 78 Westlake
explained it “believe[d] the decision to be flawed” and laid out next steps, including
“preparing an appeal” and requesting “a suspension of the effect of the Decision (i.e.,
so that no order can be made against PPG to effect payment of the award) until there
has been a final and binding decision.” 79
Before payment of the judgment is required, the Brazil court’s accounting clerk
must calculate interest and monetary corrections to the damages award. 80 Following
this process—including any challenges to the calculations—the Brazil court will issue
an order to pay at Di Gregorio’s request. 81 Once an order to pay issues, the judgment
must be paid within 15 days. Otherwise, the Brazil court will tack on a penalty
amount of 10 percent of the judgment plus additional legal fees of 10 percent. 82 At
trial, PPG’s Brazilian law expert, Professor Carmona, testified that this process
77 Id.
78 JX 163.
79 Id.
80 PTO ¶ 44.
81 Id. ¶¶ 45–47.
82 Id. ¶ 11.
18
should take “a matter of days,” that he was unsure why it had not happened yet, and
that the delay is “unusual.” 83
Professor Carmona also testified that neither posting a bond nor depositing the
full judgment amount into the Brazilian court registry would stay enforcement under
Brazil’s procedural rules. 84 But for Di Gregorio to enforce an order to pay against
PPG’s Brazilian subsidiary would require a request to pierce PPG’s corporate veil.
Such a request would stay enforcement proceedings in Brazil and proceed as a
separate action, subject to all available challenges and appeals. 85
I. This Litigation
On June 18, 2024, PPG filed this action against Defendants. 86 Two days later,
PPG filed a Motion for Temporary Restraining Order (the “TRO”), asking the Court
to (1) require Defendants to substitute into the Di Gregorio Litigation and remove
PPG entirely; (2) failing substitution, enter an order preventing Westlake from
abandoning defense in the Di Gregorio Litigation; and (3) compel Westlake to “post
any bond, amount in escrow, and/or Court fees necessary to secure the $706+ million
award.” 87
83 TT 406:1–16, 408:13–18 (Carmona). As of the date of this decision, no order to pay
has issued in the Di Gregorio Litigation.
84 Id. 455:9–15; 461:5–8 (Carmona).
85 Id. 469:5–16, 495:14–496:12 (Sica).
86 Dkt. 1.
87 Dkt. 9.
19
Following a telephonic hearing, the Court denied PPG’s request for a TRO and
ordered the parties to file a stipulation agreeing that Defendants would continue to
defend and pay all necessary defense fees in the Di Gregorio Litigation, and provide
notice to PPG’s counsel of any material developments. 88
The Court held a two-day trial on May 6 and 7, 2025, and heard post-trial
argument on July 25, 2025. On December 18, 2025, the Court held a telephonic status
conference and requested supplemental briefing. 89 Following the parties’ submission
of supplemental briefs, the Court heard argument on August 4, 2026, and took the
matter under advisement. 90
II. LEGAL ANALYSIS
Both sides seek declaratory judgments and specific performance based on
provisions of the Separation Agreement. The parties’ requests for relief thus present
questions of contract interpretation.
“Under Delaware law, the role of a court when interpreting a contract is ‘to
effectuate the parties’ intent.’” 91 In doing so, the Court “must give effect to all terms
of the instrument, must read the instrument as a whole, and, if possible, reconcile all
88 See Dkt. 29.
89 Dkts. 200, 201.
90 Dkts. 212, 214.
91 Meteora Cap. P’rs, LP v. Roadzen Inc., 2026 WL 2530118, at *20 (Del. Ch. Aug. 27,
2026) (quoting Lorillard Tobacco Co. v. Am. Legacy Found., 903 A.2d 728, 739 (Del. 2006)).
20
the provisions of the instrument.” 92 “Unless there is ambiguity, Delaware courts
interpret contract terms according to their plain, ordinary meaning.” 93 “Contract
language is not ambiguous merely because the parties dispute what it means.” 94 “To
be ambiguous, a disputed contract term must be fairly or reasonably susceptible to
more than one meaning.” “Delaware courts will not destroy or twist language under
the guise of construing it.” 95 “If a writing is plain and clear on its face, i.e., its
language conveys an unmistakable meaning, the writing itself is the sole source for
gaining an understanding of intent.” 96
A. PPG’s Requests for Declaratory Judgment
“Parties to a contract may seek a declaratory judgment to determine ‘any
question of construction or validity’ and may seek a declaration of ‘rights, status or
other legal relations thereunder.’” 97 “Declaratory relief is in the discretion of the
Court and not available as a matter of right.” 98 “The court may not exercise that
92 Lorillard, 903 A.2d at 739.
93 Alta Berkeley VI C.V. v. Omneon, Inc., 41 A.3d 381, 385 (Del. 2012) (citations
omitted).
94 Id.
95 Id.
96 Rhone-Poulenc Basic Chem. Co. v. Am. Motorists Ins. Co., 616 A.2d 1192, 1195 (Del.
1992).
97 Those Certain Underwriters at Lloyd’s London v. Nat’l Installment Ins. Servs., Inc.,
2007 WL 4554453, at *6 (Del. Ch. Dec. 21, 2007) (quoting 10 Del. C. § 6502).
98 Id. (citing 10 Del. C. § 6506).
21
discretion, however, unless the action presents an ‘actual controversy.’” 99 The party
seeking a declaratory judgment bears the burden of proof. 100
PPG seeks declaratory judgment as to three issues.
First, PPG seeks a declaration that Eagle US 2 assumed the Di Gregorio
Liability. 101 Defendants do not dispute this. 102 Accordingly, there does not appear to
be a justiciable controversy as to this issue warranting a declaratory judgment. 103
99 XL Specialty Ins. Co. v. WMI Liquidating Tr., 93 A.3d 1208, 1216 (Del. 2014).
100 State Farm Mut. Automobile Ins. Co. v. Spine Care Del., LLC, 238 A.3d 850, 860
n.55 (Del. 2020) (“We observe that there is some debate on the burden of proof in declaratory
judgment actions. . . . The Rhone-Poulenc court concluded that, ‘[t]he better view is that a
plaintiff in a declaratory judgment action should always have the burden going forward.’ . . .
We agree that this is the better view.”); see also San Antonio Fire & Police Pension Fund v.
Amylin Pharm., Inc., 983 A.2d 304, 316 n.38 (Del. Ch. 2009) (“Because Amylin seeks a
declaratory judgment as to its right to approve, it bears the burden of proof here.”), aff’d 981
A.2d 1173 (Del. 2009); Hexion Specialty Chemicals, Inc. v. Huntsman Corp., 965 A.2d 715,
739 (Del. Ch. 2008) (“[I]n determining the allocation of the burden of proof in suits for
declaratory judgment, ‘the better view is that a plaintiff in a declaratory judgment action
should always have the burden of going forward.’”) (quoting Lloyd’s London, 2007 WL
4554453, at *6).
101 Dkt. 183, PPG’s Post-Trial Opening Brief (“Pl. PTOB”) at 57.
102 Dkt. 188, Defendants’ Post-Trial Answering Brief (“Defs. PTAB”) at 31 (“The first
declaration that PPG seeks—that Eagle US 2 ‘assumed liability for the Di Gregorio action,’
PPG Br. 57—is undisputed.”).
103 The Court is relying on Defendants’ representation in concluding there is no
justiciable controversy. Defendants are thus judicially estopped from taking a contrary
position in the future. See Hermelin v. K-V Pharm. Co., 2011 WL 6225377, at *1 (Del. Ch.
Dec. 13, 2011) (finding request for declaratory judgment moot based on representations that
defendant had paid indemnification and would not seek to claw back the amounts paid, and
concluding that “[h]aving waived its right to contest indemnification . . . , and having
specifically waived the right to claw back amounts paid, the Defendant and its assigns are
barred from further actions inconsistent with such waiver. Moreover, I have relied
specifically on the Defendant’s waivers in reaching my decision here, and thus the Defendant
and its assigns are judicially estopped from litigating the issue in this or any court in a
manner inconsistent with its representations here”).
22
Second, PPG seeks a declaration that Eagle US 2 is responsible for all
liabilities and defense costs associated with the Di Gregorio Litigation. 104 This also
appears to be undisputed. Indeed, Defendants seek their own declaration that they
“must indemnify and hold PPG harmless, which will protect PPG in the event of a Di
Gregorio-related Loss[.]” 105 To the extent this request for declaratory judgment
includes PPG’s request for damages in the amount of its attorneys’ fees incurred in
this action and the Di Gregorio Litigation, that is addressed separately below.
Finally, PPG seeks a declaration that “in the event Eagle US 2 cannot satisfy
any provision of the [Di Gregorio] judgment, for whatever reason, the provisions of
the judgment shall apply equally to Westlake, Axiall, and [Eagle] Spinco.” 106 This is
addressed in the section below regarding Defendants’ competing request for a
declaration that “Westlake is not a proper defendant in this action.” 107
B. PPG’s Requests for Specific Performance
PPG seeks an award of specific performance ordering Defendants to:
• “take all necessary steps to substitute Westlake into the Di Gregorio
action, remove PPG as the nominal defendant or obligor, and instruct
the Mattos Filho law firm to terminate or withdraw its Power of
Attorney with PPG; or, if the Court in the Di Gregorio Action does not
permit substitution, Westlake must join in the Di Gregorio Action as an
additional defendant;”
104 Pl. PTOB at 57.
105 Defs. PTOB at 2.
106 Pl. PTOB at 57.
107 Defs. PTOB at 2.
23
• “defend the Di Gregorio Action without interruption (including but not
limited to, posting any bond and court costs required to preserve all
rights of appeal and prevent any efforts to enforce the judgment against
PPG’s or its affiliates’ interests); and”
• “[t]ake all steps necessary to protect PPG and its affiliates from any
enforcement action or other harm arising out of the Di Gregorio Action,
including, if necessary, satisfying the judgment issued in the Di
Gregorio Action.” 108
There appears to be no dispute that Defendants have been defending the Di
Gregorio Litigation. And Defendants have repeatedly committed—under oath at trial
and in documents filed with the Court—to continue defending the Di Gregorio
Litigation, including defending PPG against any attempts at enforcing any order to
pay. 109 Defendants have likewise conceded that, having assumed the Di Gregorio
Liability, Eagle US 2 will ultimately be the party responsible for any final, non-
appealable judgment in the Di Gregorio Litigation and any losses that arise from any
such judgment. 110 The Court expressly relies on these representations in concluding
there is no live controversy on these issues. Defendants are thus judicially estopped
from taking a contrary position later. 111
108 Pl. PTOB at 57–58.
109 TT240:19–242:3, 327:22–328:8, 345:22–346:1 (Kroger); Defs. Supp. Br. at 5–6
(“Westlake has confirmed—in briefing, to the Court, and in sworn testimony—that it will
hold PPG harmless, consistent with Article V.”) (collecting citations).
110 See, e.g., Defs. PTAB at 6 (“Defendants have consistently acknowledged their
obligations.”) (collecting citations); id. at 7 (“PPG was protected because, as Kroger explained,
Defendants held ultimate responsibility.”).
111 See Motors Liquidation Co. DIP Lenders Tr. v. Allstate Ins. Co., 191 A.3d 1109 (Del.
2018) (TABLE) (affirming trial court’s application of judicial estoppel to bar arguments
contrary to representations made in prior litigation).
24
Thus, PPG’s live requests for specific performance boil down to (1) an order
requiring substitution or addition in the Di Gregorio Litigation and (2) an order
requiring Defendants to post a bond or to satisfy any judgment that issues in that
action before the conclusion of all appeals and without regard to th