Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S'holder Representative Servs., LLC
CourtCourt of Chancery of Delaware
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
DocketC.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
COURT OF CHANCERY
OF THE
STATE OF DELAWARE
PAUL A. FIORAVANTI, JR. LEONARD L. WILLIAMS JUSTICE CENTER
VICE CHANCELLOR 500 N. KING STREET, SUITE 11400
WILMINGTON, DELAWARE 19801-3734
November 18, 2026
Joseph C. Schoell, Esquire David E. Ross, Esquire
Oderah C. Nwaeze, Esquire Ross Aronstam & Moritz LLP
Renée M. Dudek, Esquire Hercules Building
Faegre Drinker Biddle & Reath LLP 1313 North Market Street, Suite 1001
222 Delaware Avenue, Suite 1410 Wilmington, Delaware 19801
Wilmington, Delaware 19801
RE: Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
Dear Counsel:
This letter decision resolves the parties’ dispute concerning the form of final
order implementing the court’s post-trial memorandum opinion.1 The dispute
concerns the interaction between the Memorandum Opinion and the court’s June 21,
2023, order awarding SRS prejudgment interest. For the reasons explained below,
the court denies Golden Rule’s proposed order and grants SRS’s proposed partial
final judgment pursuant to Court of Chancery Rule 54(b).
1
This order adopts the defined terms used in the memorandum opinion Golden Rule
Financial Corp. v. Shareholder Representative Services LLC, 2026 WL 1182159 (Del. Ch.
Apr. 30, 2026), Dkt. 176 (the “Mem. Op.”). Unless otherwise indicated, citations to the
parties’ briefs are to supplemental briefs on the proposed implementing orders (Dkts. 184,
186–187).
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 2 of 28
I. BACKGROUND
A. The Merger Agreement
Golden Rule acquired USHEALTH in 2019. The terms of the transaction are
documented in a June 2, 2019, Merger Agreement. 2 The Merger Agreement
required Golden Rule, at Closing, to deposit: (1) the cash needed to pay the Initial
Merger Consideration, less the Escrow Deposit and the Representative Fund, with
the designated paying agent,3 and (2) the $75 million Escrow Deposit with the
designated escrow agent in accordance with the terms of the Escrow Agreement.4
Within 90 days after Closing, Golden Rule was required to deliver to SRS a
Final Adjustment Statement setting forth the Final Adjustment Amount. 5 SRS then
had 45 days to review Golden Rule’s calculation and, if it disagreed, to deliver a
Dispute Notice identifying the disputed items. 6 If the parties could not resolve the
2
See JX 161 (“Merger Agreement”) § 1.1 “Final Adjustment Amount”; Mem. Op. at *9
n.81.
3
Merger Agreement § 3.2(a). The Merger Agreement defined “Escrow Deposit” as “an
amount equal to $75,000,000” and “Representative Fund” as “a portion of the Initial
Merger Consideration equal to $1,000,000 . . . deposited in an account designated by the
Stockholder Representative.” See id. §§ 1.1, 10.10(d).
4
Merger Agreement § 3.3(a); see id. Ex. D (hereinafter the “Escrow Agreement”).
5
Merger Agreement § 3.4(b).
6
Id. § 3.4(b)(i)‒(ii).
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 3 of 28
disputed items, either side could submit them to KPMG LLP, acting as an expert, to
decide the issues in dispute.7
Section 3.4(a) prescribed the payment obligation upon the “final
determination” of the Final Adjustment Amount. If the Final Adjustment Amount
exceeded the Adjusted Initial Amount, Golden Rule had to pay the excess to the
paying agent for further distribution to the former USHEALTH securityholders
within five business days.8 If the Final Adjustment Amount was lower than the
Adjusted Initial Amount, Golden Rule and SRS had to instruct the escrow agent to
pay the difference to Golden Rule from the Escrow Funds.9
Section 9.2(a) of the Merger Agreement requires the former USHEALTH
securityholders to indemnify Golden Rule and related indemnitees for Losses
attributable to, resulting from, or arising out of specified breaches of representations,
warranties, and covenants. Under Section 9.3(b), subject to specified exceptions,
the former USHEALTH securityholders’ aggregate liability for those Losses could
not exceed the Escrow Funds then remaining in the Escrow Account. Under Section
7
See id. § 3.4(b)(iv).
8
Id. § 3.4(a).
9
Id.; see Escrow Agreement § 1.1 (“The initial escrow deposit will be an amount of cash
equal to $75,000,000 (such amount, together with interest, dividends, gains and other
income earned with respect thereto, the ‘Escrow Funds’).”).
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 4 of 28
9.3(c), subject to specified exceptions, the Escrow Funds were the sole source of
recovery and exclusive remedy for those claims.
B. The Prior Action
In the Prior Action, Golden Rule sought declaratory and injunctive relief to
prevent SRS from asking KPMG to determine the Final Adjustment Amount using
an application of ASC 606 different from the one used in the Company’s pre-closing
financial statements. 10 Golden Rule argued that the court, rather than KPMG, should
decide the contract-construction issue regarding the application of ASC 606.
The court dismissed the Prior Action, concluding that, “[u]nder the language
of the [Merger] Agreement, consistency with past practices cannot justify a
concededly incorrect application of ASC 606.” 11 The Delaware Supreme Court
affirmed that decision. 12
10
See Dkt. 1, Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC, C.A. No.
2020-0378-PAF (May 18, 2020) ¶¶ 81‒106; id. ¶ 105 (“The Court should declare that,
under the doctrine of quasi-estoppel, the Seller may not ask KPMG to award any Final
Adjustment Amount that relies on an application of ASC 606 that is different from or
inconsistent with the application of ASC 606 that the Company relied on and disclosed to
Golden Rule before closing, and enjoin the Seller from making such a request.”).
11
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC, 2021 WL 305741, at *12
(Del. Ch. Jan. 29, 2021), aff’d, 267 A.3d 382 (Del. 2021) (TABLE).
12
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC, 267 A.3d 382 (Del. 2021)
(TABLE).
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 5 of 28
C. This Action and the Summary Judgment Order
Golden Rule then commenced this action in 2022, asserting claims for
indemnification and damages based on alleged breaches of the Merger Agreement.13
SRS asserted counterclaims.14 The first counterclaim (“Counterclaim I”) alleged
that Golden Rule breached the Merger Agreement by refusing to pay the Final
Adjustment Amount when it was due. 15 SRS sought payment of the $40,164,358.82
Final Adjustment Amount, plus pre- and post-judgment interest and attorneys’
fees.16
SRS moved for partial summary judgment on Counterclaim I. SRS sought
payment of the Final Adjustment Amount, prejudgment interest, reasonable
attorneys’ fees and expenses, and entry of partial final judgment under Court of
Chancery Rule 54(b). SRS argued that, under Section 3.4(a) of the Merger
Agreement, Golden Rule was required to pay the Final Adjustment Amount within
13
Dkt. 1.
14
Dkt. 5.
15
Dkt. 5 Counterclaims ¶¶ 84‒85 (quoting Merger Agreement § 3.4(a)); see also Dkt. 51
(“Summary Judgment Arg.”) at 4:13‒15 (Def.’s Counsel: “Today’s motion is on Golden
Rule’s failure to pay the purchase price adjustment when it was due under the contract.”).
16
Dkt. 5 Counterclaims ¶ 86.
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 6 of 28
five business days of its final determination and that Golden Rule’s indemnification
claims did not excuse or delay that payment obligation.17
In opposing the motion, Golden Rule did not contest SRS’s right to
prejudgment interest, but it disputed when prejudgment interest began to accrue.18
Golden Rule also opposed entry of a partial final order under Court of Chancery
Rule 54(b), arguing that its indemnification claims remained pending and that there
was a reasonable possibility of overlapping fee, interest, and offset issues. 19
Before argument on the motion, Golden Rule paid the Final Adjustment
Amount of $40,164,358.82, thereby mooting SRS’s request for an order compelling
payment of the principal amount. 20 In an oral ruling granting partial summary
judgment (the “Summary Judgment Ruling”) to Defendant, the court determined that
SRS was entitled to prejudgment interest beginning on May 18, 2020, the date that
17
Dkt. 18 (“Def.’s Summary Judgment Opening Br.”) 19; Dkt. 24 (“Def.’s Summary
Judgment Reply Br.”) 4–6.
18
Dkt. 21 (“Pl.’s Summary Judgment Answering Br.”) 12‒13.
19
Id. at 21–23.
20
Mem. Op. at *14; see also Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs.
LLC, C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF (Del. Ch. May 22, 2023) (TRANSCRIPT) (“Summary
Judgment Ruling”) at 13:6–15.
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 7 of 28
Golden Rule filed the Prior Action.21 The court’s implementing order (the
“Summary Judgment Order”) awarded SRS prejudgment interest “from May 18,
2020 through June 16, 2023 in the amount of $7,219,340,” with interest continuing
“to accrue on $7,219,340 from June 16, 2023 at the legal rate, compounded quarterly
with a fluctuating interest rate until the date of payment by Golden Rule of the
outstanding interest owed to SRS.”22
The court denied SRS’s request for entry of a partial final order under Rule
54(b).23 Thus, the Summary Judgment Order remained interlocutory and subject to
revision before entry of final judgment. See C. v. C., 320 A.2d 717, 720 (Del. 1974)
(“An interlocutory judgment is one made in the progress of a case, and which is only
intermediate and does not finally determine or complete the suit.”); see also Frank
G.W. v. Carol M.W., 457 A.2d 715, 719 (Del. 1983) (“Until the rendition of the final
judgment, the interlocutory judgment remains within the control of the court.”)
(citation modified).
21
Summary Judgment Ruling at 19:5‒13; see also id. at 24:7‒14 (“[P]rejudgment interest
accrued from the date that payment was due, which was the date that Golden Rule filed its
original action in this Court on May 18, 2020, bypassing the independent accountant
process and opting for a judicial determination on the purely legal issue of whether ASC
606 dictated payment of a Final Adjustment Amount in the way that Golden Rule saw it or
how SRS saw it.”).
22
Dkt. 73 (“Summary Judgment Order”) ¶ 2(a)(1).
23
Summary Judgment Ruling at 29:13‒19; see Summary Judgment Order ¶ 3(c).
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 8 of 28
D. The Memorandum Opinion
The action proceeded to trial on Golden Rule’s affirmative claims. 24 Count I
asserted breach of the representations and warranties in Section 4.5 of the Merger
Agreement. Count II asserted breach of covenants and obligations under
Sections 3.1 and 3.5 of the Merger Agreement. Plaintiff sought specific
performance requiring indemnification or, in the alternative, damages.25
In a post-trial Memorandum Opinion, the court determined that “USHEALTH
breached its financial statement representation in Section 4.5(a) and its obligations
under Section 3.1(a), and SRS is liable for those breaches under the Merger
Agreement’s indemnification provisions.” 26 Golden Rule established an
“indemnifiable Loss in the amount of $38.3 million, plus prejudgment interest at the
legal rate from the date it paid the additional consideration attributable to the Final
Adjustment Amount through the date of judgment, compounded quarterly.” 27
24
See Dkts. 143, 145‒147.
25
Mem. Op. at *14.
26
Id. at *28.
27
Id.
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 9 of 28
E. The Competing Proposed Orders
The parties submitted competing forms of order to implement the
Memorandum Opinion.28 The parties agree that: (i) Golden Rule is entitled to
$38,342,458, plus prejudgment interest from January 25, 2023 through the date of
judgment, (ii) partial Rule 54(b) certification is appropriate, and (iii) the court should
reserve jurisdiction to resolve attorneys’ fees and costs issues.
The parties’ disagree over the treatment of prejudgment interest that was
awarded to SRS in the Summary Judgment Order. Golden Rule proposes to limit
SRS’s recovery to prejudgment interest on the approximately $1.8 million portion
of the Final Adjustment Amount that Golden Rule does not attribute to
USHEALTH’s breaches.29 Golden Rule calculates the amount as $327,477 and,
with additional interest, $434,693. Golden Rule’s proposed order would apply that
amount only as an offset against Golden Rule’s prejudgment interest award and
provide that the Summary Judgment Order is “satisfied and of no further effect.”30
28
Dkts. 181 (“Def.’s Proposed Implementing Order”), 182 (“Pl.’s Proposed Implementing
Order”).
29
See Pl.’s Proposed Implementing Order ¶ 3.
30
Id.
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 10 of 28
SRS proposes judgment for Golden Rule in the amount awarded by the
Memorandum Opinion—$38,342,458 in damages, plus $14,614,103 in prejudgment
interest, for a total judgment amount of $52,956,561. Unlike Golden Rule’s
proposed order, SRS’s proposed order would not disturb the prejudgment interest
awarded to SRS in the Summary Judgment Order. 31
II. ANALYSIS
A. Entry of a Partial Final Judgment Is Warranted.
“A final judgment is generally defined as one that determines the merits of the
controversy or defines the rights of the parties and leaves nothing for future
determination or consideration.” Tyson Foods, Inc. v. Aetos Corp., 809 A.2d 575,
579 (Del. 2002). “Under the ‘merger rule,’ prior interlocutory orders merge with the
final judgment in a case, and the interlocutory orders (to the extent that they affect
the final judgment) may be reviewed on appeal from the final order.” DeMatteis v.
RiseDelaware Inc., 315 A.3d 499, 510 n.72 (Del. 2024) (quoting Camesi v. Univ. of
Pittsburgh Med. Ctr., 729 F.3d 239, 244–45 (3d Cir. 2013)); see also Tyson, 809
A.2d at 580 (“[O]nce interlocutory rulings achieve finality at the trial level, through
31
Def.’s Proposed Implementing Order ¶¶ 3‒4.
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 11 of 28
incorporation in the final judgment of the trial court, review of those subsidiary
rulings must be achieved through a timely appeal of that final order.”).
The Delaware Supreme Court “has consistently held . . . that a judgment on
the merits is not final until an outstanding application for an award of attorney’s fees
has been decided.” Emerald P’rs v. Berlin, 811 A.2d 788, 790–91 (Del. 2001). “A
trial court therefore cannot defer ruling on an application for expenses until after the
merits appeal is completed, unless the trial court first certifies its merits ruling as
interlocutory or as a partial final judgment pursuant to Court of Chancery
Rule 54(b).” Marilyn Abrams Living Tr. v. Pope Invs. LLC, 188 A.3d 829, 835 (Del.
Ch. 2018).
The competing forms of order contemplate entry of partial final judgment
under Rule 54(b), leaving the attorneys’ fees and costs for later determination. “[A]n
attorneys’ fees petition does not foreclose this court from granting [a] Rule 54(b)
[m]otion.” Totta v. CCSB Fin. Corp., 2022 WL 4087800, at *2 (Del. Ch. Sep. 7,
2022); see also Campbell v. Caravel Acad., Inc., 1989 WL 25804, at *1 (Del. Ch.
Mar. 16, 1989) (“Costs and attorney fees are best addressed after the appellate
process is completed.”). There is no just reason to delay entry of judgment on the
resolved merits issues. Therefore, entry of a partial final judgment is appropriate at
this stage.
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 12 of 28
B. The Law of the Case Doctrine Governs Golden Rule’s Request to
Revise the Summary Judgment Order.
The parties agree that partial final judgment should be entered, but they
disagree about the treatment of the Summary Judgment Order. Golden Rule’s
proposed order would reduce the prejudgment interest awarded to SRS in the
Summary Judgment Order, declaring it “satisfied and of no further effect.” 32 In other
words, entry of Golden Rule’s proposed order revises the Summary Judgment Order.
Under Court of Chancery Rule 54(b), “any order . . . that adjudicates fewer
than all the claims or the rights and liabilities . . . may be revised at any time before
the entry of a judgment adjudicating all the claims and all the parties’ rights and
liabilities.” Ct. Ch. R. 54(b). The court’s exercise of that authority is guided by law
of the case principles. See Tornetta v. Musk, 326 A.3d 1203, 1223 (Del. Ch. 2024)
(“Rule 54(b) does not, on its face, ‘identify a standard for determining when it would
be warranted to revise an earlier interlocutory order’ under the second sentence, but
the ‘law-of-the-case doctrine fills the gap.’” (quoting Perry v. Neupert, 2019 WL
719000, at *28 n.221 (Del. Ch. Feb. 15, 2019))), rev’d on other grounds sub nom.
In re Tesla, Inc. Deriv. Litig., 351 A.3d 1005 (Del. 2025).
32
Pl.’s Proposed Implementing Order ¶ 3.
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 13 of 28
“The ‘law of the case’ doctrine requires that issues already decided by the
same court should be adopted without relitigation, and once a matter has been
addressed in a procedurally appropriate way by a court, it is generally held to be the
law of that case and will not be disturbed by that court unless compelling reason to
do so appears.” Taylor v. Jones, 2006 WL 1510437, at *5 (Del. Ch. May 25, 2006)
(citation modified); see also State v. Wright, 131 A.3d 310, 321 (Del. 2016) (“The
law of the case doctrine is a self-imposed restriction that prohibits courts from
revisiting issues previously decided, with the intent to promote ‘efficiency, finality,
stability and respect for the judicial system.’” (quoting Cede & Co. v. Technicolor,
Inc., 884 A.2d 26, 39 (Del. 2005))). The law of the case doctrine “is not inflexible
in that, unlike res judicata, it is not an absolute bar to reconsideration of a prior
decision that is clearly wrong, produces an injustice or should be revisited because
of changed circumstances.” Gannett Co., Inc. v. Kanaga, 750 A.2d 1174, 1181 (Del.
2000).
C. The Memorandum Opinion Does Not Justify Revising the
Summary Judgment Order.
Golden Rule’s principal argument rests on the Memorandum Opinion’s
finding that SRS must indemnify Golden Rule for $38.3 million in Losses under
Article IX due to USHEALTH’s breach of its representations and warranties.
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 14 of 28
Golden Rule contends that SRS should not be entitled to prejudgment interest on an
amount SRS obtained through USHEALTH’s breaches for which SRS is liable.33
But that argument conflates Golden Rule’s obligation to pay the Final Adjustment
Amount under Section 3.4(a) with its indemnification right under Article IX.
The Summary Judgment Order addressed Golden Rule’s obligation to pay the
Final Adjustment Amount after its final determination under Section 3.4(a) of the
Merger Agreement. Although Golden Rule’s January 25, 2023, payment mooted
SRS’s request for the principal amount, the court held that “the litigation over
ASC 606 and Golden Rule’s persistent refusal to pay the base amount until [January
25, 2023,] . . . resulted in Golden Rule having use of SRS’s funds for nearly three
years from the commencement of the [P]rior [Action] and nearly three and a half
years since the [C]losing . . . .” 34 At that stage, the parties agreed that SRS was
entitled to prejudgment interest as a matter of right, and the only dispute concerned
when interest began to accrue. The court determined that the accrual starting date
was May 18, 2020, i.e., the date on which Golden Rule filed the Prior Action.
The Memorandum Opinion resolved Golden Rule’s indemnification claims
under Article IX. After trial, the court held that USHEALTH breached
33
Pl.’s Opening Br. 1‒2, 10‒13, 15.
34
See Summary Judgment Ruling at 20:10‒17.
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 15 of 28
Sections 3.1(a) and 4.5(a), that Golden Rule had established an indemnifiable Loss
of $38.3 million, and that SRS was liable for that Loss, plus prejudgment interest
from January 25, 2023—the date of Golden Rule’s payment of the Final Adjustment
Amount—through judgment.
The two rulings addressed different contractual rights. The Summary
Judgment Order addressed SRS’s right to receive payment of the Final Adjustment
Amount under Section 3.4(a) and Golden Rule’s delay in satisfying that obligation.
The Memorandum Opinion addressed Golden Rule’s right to indemnification under
Article IX.
Golden Rule suggests that the court’s decision not to certify the Summary
Judgment Order as a partial final judgment reflects the court’s predisposition to
revise its decision at a later stage. 35 While the court noted that other claims and
counterclaims remained pending and that fee-shifting issues could benefit from a
more developed record,36 it did not reserve SRS’s entitlement to prejudgment
35
Pl.’s Opening Br. 13.
36
Summary Judgment Ruling at 27:10‒18 (“There are several other claims remaining in
this case on both sides that may, upon final resolution, implicate whether fee shifting is
available under the indemnity provisions of Section 9.2(a) and 9.2(b). In my view, issues
concerning the scope of Section 9.2, including issues pertaining to the application for fees
on the present motion, can benefit from a better development of the factual record to clarify
the law and its application.”).
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 16 of 28
interest for later redetermination. The court denied Rule 54(b) certification because
SRS had not shown the infrequent and harsh case warranting immediate partial final
judgment. Nothing in the Summary Judgment Ruling suggested that the
prejudgment interest award was dependent on Golden Rule’s later success on its
indemnification claims.
Therefore, Golden Rule has failed to show any compelling reason to revise
the Summary Judgment Order in light of the determinations made in the
Memorandum Opinion.
1. The res judicata ruling is not implicated.
SRS argues that Golden Rule’s request to revise the Summary Judgment
Order cannot be reconciled with the Memorandum Opinion’s res judicata ruling.37
That argument lacks merit. SRS contended that the indemnification claim was
barred by res judicata because Golden Rule had not asserted it in the Prior Action.
The Memorandum Opinion rejected that theory because Golden Rule’s
37
SRS argues that Golden Rule’s position vis-à-vis the post-trial implementing order
requesting unwinding of the prejudgment interest award in the Summary Judgment Order
“runs head-on into the Court’s res judicata ruling, in which the Court accepted—at Golden
Rule’s urging—that this action is wholly distinct from the first one.” Def.’s Answering Br.
2; see also id. at 9 (“Golden Rule resists this straightforward application of Delaware law
by arguing that SRS’s later liability for indemnification in this action extinguishes its
award of prejudgment interest on the Final Adjustment Amount from the first action. . . .
But that novel position has no binding legal basis and cannot be reconciled with this Court’s
res judicata ruling.”).
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 17 of 28
indemnification claim was not ripe at the time of the Prior Action, which resolved
whether the Final Adjustment Statement had to reflect the correct application of ASC
606 under GAAP or consistently with historical practice. The Memorandum
Opinion further observed that, had Golden Rule prevailed in the Prior Action, it
would not have incurred a Loss giving rise to an indemnification claim. Thus, the
scope of the Prior Action was limited to addressing the dispute arising from the
calculation of the Final Adjustment Amount.
The Memorandum Opinion held that the doctrine of res judicata did not bar
the present action, which concerns whether Golden Rule had incurred a Loss
indemnifiable under Article IX. The Summary Judgment Ruling addressed
Counterclaim I and awarded SRS prejudgment interest on Golden Rule’s obligation
to pay the Final Adjustment Amount under Section 3.4(a) of the Merger Agreement,
beginning from May 18, 2020. As the court observed, that was the date Golden Rule
filed the Prior Action, and thereby “eschewed the independent accountant process
and acknowledged that it owed a base Final Adjustment Amount of
$40,164,3[58].82 if SRS’s position on the application of ASC 606 were correct.” 38
38
Summary Judgment Ruling at 19:5‒13; see also id. at 24:7‒14 (“[P]rejudgment interest
accrued from the date that payment was due, which was the date that Golden Rule filed its
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 18 of 28
The distinction between the different actions and rulings is therefore
straightforward. The Prior Action concerned the dispute about the calculation of the
Final Adjustment Amount. The Summary Judgment Order and the Summary
Judgment Ruling address SRS’s prejudgment interest request on Golden Rule’s
delayed payment of the Final Adjustment Amount under Section 3.4(a) of the
Merger Agreement asserted in Counterclaim I. The Memorandum Opinion
addressed Golden Rule’s indemnification right under Article IX. Therefore, the res
judicata ruling is not implicated here because it was not the Prior Action that entitled
SRS to prejudgment interest. It was Golden Rule’s delay in paying the Final
Adjustment Amount when it was due under the Merger Agreement, which was
asserted in Counterclaim I.
D. The Interest Awarded to SRS Was Not Awarded as an Additional
Indemnifiable Loss.
Golden Rule advances another argument in support of its proposed
implementing order, relying on the Merger Agreement’s definition of “Losses.” The
Merger Agreement defines “Losses” as
original action in this Court on May 18, 2020, bypassing the independent accountant
process and opting for a judicial determination on the purely legal issue of whether
ASC 606 dictated payment of a Final Adjustment Amount in the way that Golden Rule
saw it or how SRS saw it.”).
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 19 of 28
any and all costs, losses, damages, Liabilities, charges, interest,
judgments, sanctions, fines, penalties and settlements, in each case
whether or not arising out of any demands or Actions brought by third
parties, and reasonable fees and expenses (including reasonable legal,
accounting and investigation fees and expenses) in connection with any
of the foregoing or similar damages incurred, sustained or suffered by
them . . . attributable to, resulting from or arising out of . . . any breach
of, or inaccuracy in, any of the representations or warranties of the
Company contained in Article IV . . . [or] the breach of any
covenant . . . contained in [the Merger] Agreement.39
Golden Rule argues that if it must pay interest to SRS on the portion of the Final
Adjustment Amount attributable to USHEALTH’s breaches, then that interest
necessarily arises out of those breaches and is indemnifiable. 40 Golden Rule further
contends that, if it had paid the prejudgment interest awarded to SRS in the Summary
Judgment Order when entered, it would now be entitled to recover that amount from
the Escrow Funds. According to Golden Rule, requiring payment now would create
an unnecessary “daisy-chain.”41
Golden Rule relies on Arwood v. AW Site Services, LLC, where this court
granted plaintiff’s motion for reargument following a post-trial judgment for the
defendant. 2022 WL 973441, at *3 (Del. Ch. Mar. 31, 2022). In granting
39
Merger Agreement § 9.2(a)(i)‒(ii).
40
Pl.’s Opening Br. 12‒13; Pl.’s Reply Br. 4‒5.
41
Pl.’s Opening Br. 18.
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 20 of 28
reargument, this court held that prejudgment interest and costs awarded in the post-
trial ruling fell within the parties’ contractual definition of “Losses” and therefore
could not be awarded above the contractual cap of recoverable losses that had
already been exhausted by the defendant’s proven damages. Id. at *2–3. Golden
Rule is correct that the contractual definition at issue in Arwood bears similarities to
the definition of “Losses” in the Merger Agreement. Yet, in Arwood, the court
addressed whether the same party that had recovered capped damages could also
recover prejudgment interest and costs above the cap.
Arwood did not involve a separate, previously adjudicated interest award in
favor of the opposing party as here, nor did it hold that an indemnification judgment
retroactively extinguishes interest awarded for a distinct payment delay. Most
important, the Memorandum Opinion did not hold that SRS’s prejudgment interest
award was an indemnifiable “Loss” under Article IX. That is because SRS’s
prejudgment interest awarded in the Summary Judgment Order originated from
Golden Rule’s delay in paying the Final Adjustment Amount when it was due under
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 21 of 28
Section 3.4(a) of the Merger Agreement, not from USHEALTH’s breach of
Sections 3.1(a) or 4.5(a). 42
The Memorandum Opinion further identified the interest component of
Golden Rule’s indemnifiable Loss by awarding prejudgment interest from
January 25, 2023, the date Golden Rule paid the additional consideration attributable
to the Final Adjustment Amount. Had Golden Rule paid the Final Adjustment
Amount earlier, Golden Rule’s prejudgment interest on its indemnifiable Loss would
have begun to accrue sooner. Golden Rule’s proposed order would shift to SRS the
interest consequences of Golden Rule’s payment delay.
E. The Summary Judgment Ruling Awarded SRS Prejudgment
Interest.
Golden Rule also argues that the Summary Judgment Order should not be
treated as a prejudgment interest award because SRS’s principal counterclaim was
mooted when Golden Rule paid the Final Adjustment Amount before argument.
Rather, Golden Rule contends that the award should be understood as damages for
delay in payment. 43 Golden Rule contends “[t]hat also explains [the] [c]ourt’s order
42
See Summary Judgment Ruling at 24:4‒8 (because “Golden Rule was obligated to make
the payment, could make the payment, and did not do so until shortly before the argument
on this motion . . . prejudgment interest [had] accrued from the date the payment was
due”).
43
Pl.’s Opening Br. 14.
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 22 of 28
of interest on top of the prejudgment-interest award; it considered the first level of
prejudgment interest as the principal damages and ordered as-of-right prejudgment
interest on that award.” 44
Golden Rule’s argument is unpersuasive. The Summary Judgment Ruling
determined that SRS was entitled to prejudgment interest as a matter of right, that
Golden Rule did not dispute that entitlement, and that the only question was when
prejudgment interest began to run. “Prejudgment interest serves two purposes: first,
it compensates the [prevailing party] for the loss of the use of [its] money; and,
second, it forces the [non-prevailing party] to relinquish any benefit that it has
received by retaining the [prevailing party’s] money in the interim.” Brandywine
Smyrna, Inc. v. Millennium Builders, LLC, 34 A.3d 482, 486 (Del. 2011); see also
id. (“[P]rejudgment interest in Delaware cases is awarded as a matter of right[;] the
general rule is that ‘interest accumulates from the date payment was due the plaintiff,
because full compensation requires an allowance for the detention of the
compensation awarded and interest is used as a basis for measuring that allowance.’”
(quoting Moskowitz v. Mayor & Council of Wilm., 391 A.2d 209, 210 (Del. 1978))).
44
Id. at 15.
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 23 of 28
Consistent with these principles, the Summary Judgment Order awarded SRS
prejudgment interest on the delayed payment of the Final Adjustment Amount and
provided that interest would continue to accrue on the unpaid prejudgment interest
amount until payment.
F. Offset of the Prejudgment Interest Is Not Warranted.
In addition to arguing that SRS should not be entitled to prejudgment interest
on $38.3 million, Golden Rule seeks to offset any prejudgment interest awarded to
SRS. Golden Rule concedes that SRS is entitled to prejudgment interest, but only
on a portion of the Final Adjustment Amount amounting to approximately $1.8
million. 45 It contends that the court should apply that interest as an offset against
Golden Rule’s award. Golden Rule calculates prejudgment interest on that amount
as $327,477, with additional interest bringing the total to $434,693. Golden Rule
further contends that, if the court were to award interest on the $38.3 million, “the
equities doubly demand an offset as to that interest.”46
“‘Set-off’ is a legal or equitable remedy that may occur when two entities that
owe money to each other apply their mutual debts against each other.” 80 C.J.S.
Set-off and Counterclaim § 5 (2026). Golden Rule invokes equitable offset here. As
45
Pl.’s Opening Br. 2, 10‒11.
46
Id. at 18; see also Pl.’s Reply Br. 10.
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 24 of 28
the Delaware Supreme Court has observed, “a set-off should be allowed only when,
in view of all the circumstances, equity and good conscience require it to be made,
substantial justice will be promoted thereby, and the rights and interests of third
persons will not be infringed.” Pettinaro Constr. Co., Inc. v. Lindh, 428 A.2d 1161,
1164 (Del. 1981) (citation modified). “Generally, a setoff procedure simply
eliminates a superfluous exchange of money between the parties.” 80 C.J.S. Set-off
and Counterclaim § 5 (2026).
Golden Rule relies on Reddy v. PrimeCare International, Inc., where an
officer and director sought advancement from a corporation for litigation expenses,
but the officer had assumed the primary obligation under a merger agreement to
indemnify the corporation and its parent for the same litigation expenses. 2000 WL
1654834, at *2 (Del. Ch. Oct. 20, 2000). The court reasoned that if the corporation
owed advancement, the officer had an identical obligation to reimburse the
corporation. Id. at *4. Offset was appropriate because the obligations were identical
and circular. See id.
Golden Rule’s reliance on Reddy is misplaced. SRS’s interest award
compensates SRS for Golden Rule’s payment delay in satisfying the Final
Adjustment Amount under Section 3.4(a). Golden Rule’s judgment reflects SRS’s
liability under Article IX for USHEALTH’s breaches of Sections 3.1(a) and 4.5(a),
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 25 of 28
plus prejudgment interest from the date Golden Rule paid the additional
consideration. The obligations are related but not identical. Thus, in this instance,
an offset would not be limited to the superfluous exchange of money between the
parties. Instead, it would reduce or extinguish a separately adjudicated prejudgment
award.
Another argument that Golden Rule advances is that the equities of the present
circumstances demand offset because only $44.6 million remains in the Escrow
Funds, making the Escrow Funds insufficient to satisfy Golden Rule’s judgment.47
But the requested offset risks circumventing the Merger Agreement’s remedial
structure. The Merger Agreement provides that, subject to specified exceptions, the
Escrow Funds are Golden Rule’s sole source of recovery and exclusive remedy for
indemnification claims. 48 “Delaware courts are ‘especially chary about relieving
sophisticated business entities of the burden of freely negotiated contracts.’” New
Enter. Assocs. 14, L.P. v. Rich, 295 A.3d 520, 566 (Del. Ch. 2023) (quoting Abry
P’rs V, L.P. v. F & W Acq. LLC, 891 A.2d 1032, 1061–62 (Del. Ch. 2006)). Golden
Rule’s requested offset would reduce an independent obligation owed to SRS and
47
Pl.’s Opening Br. 17.
48
See Merger Agreement § 9.3(b)‒(c).
Golden Rule Fin. Corp. v. S’holder Representative Servs. LLC,
C.A. No. 2022-0065-PAF
November 18, 2026
Page 26 of 28
would contravene the contractual limitation of Golden Rule’s indemnification
recovery to the Escrow Funds.
As this court observed in FdG Logistics LLC v. A&R Logistics Holdings, Inc.,
the buyer, “a sophisticated contracting party, could have bargained for the right to
delay payment . . . pending the resolution of its indemnification or other claims
arising out of [the] Merger Agreement. It did not do so.” 131 A.3d 842, 866 (Del.
Ch. 2016), aff’d, 148 A.3d 1171 (Del. 2016) (TABLE). The same is true here.
Golden Rule could have bargained for a right to delay an upward true-up payment
pending resolution of its indemnification claims. In the absence of such a provision,
Golden Rule remained obligated to make the Section 3.4(a) payment when due. Its
later success on its indemnification claims does not supply an entitlement to offset.
Moreover, Golden Rule’s further contention that SRS’s conduct in this litigation
warrants the requested offset is equally unpersuasive for the same reasons grounded