Oman Aluminium Rolling Co. SPC v. United States
CourtUnited States Court of International Trade
Date FiledNovember 19, 2026
Docket25-00215
JudgeChoe-Groves
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Slip Op. 26-140
UNITED STATES COURT OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE
OMAN ALUMINIUM ROLLING
COMPANY SPC,
Plaintiff,
and
DAIKIN COMFORT
TECHNOLOGIES NORTH
AMERICA, INC.,
Plaintiff-Intervenor,
Before: Jennifer Choe-Groves, Judge
v.
Court No. 25-00215
UNITED STATES,
Defendant,
and
ALUMINUM ASSOCIATION
TRADE ENFORCEMENT
WORKING GROUP AND ITS
INDIVIDUAL MEMBERS,
GRӒNGES AMERICAS, AND JW
ALUMINUM,
Defendant-Intervenors.
Court No. 25-00215 Page 2
OPINION AND ORDER
[Remanding the U.S. Department of Commerce’s Final Results of Antidumping
Duty Administrative Review in Certain Aluminum Foil From the Sultanate of
Oman.]
Dated: November 19, 2026
Bernd G. Janzen and Sarah P. Tinaphong, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP,
of Washington, D.C., argued for Plaintiff Oman Aluminium Rolling Company
SPC. With them on the brief were Yujin K. McNamara, Devin S. Sikes, and
Sydney L. Stringer.
Daniel R. Wilson, Carrie B. Connolly, Richard P. Ferrin, and Morgan A. Howard,
Faegre Drinker Biddle & Reath, LLP, of Washington, D.C., for Plaintiff-Intervenor
Daikin Comfort Technologies North America, Inc.
Samuel J. Harrison, Trial Attorney, Commercial Litigation Branch, Civil Division,
U.S. Department of Justice, of Washington, D.C., and Jack Dunkelman, Attorney,
Office of the Chief Counsel for Trade Enforcement and Compliance, U.S.
Department of Commerce, of Washington, D.C., argued for Defendant United
States. Also on the brief were Brett A. Shumate, Principal Deputy Assistant
Attorney General, Patricia M. McCarthy, Director, and Claudia Burke, Deputy
Director, U.S. Department of Justice, of Washington, D.C.
R. Alan Luberda, Kelley Drye & Warren, LLP, of Washington, D.C., argued for
Defendant-Intervenors Aluminum Associate Trade Enforcement Working Group
and its Individual Members, Grӓnges Americas, and JW Aluminum. Also on the
brief were John M. Herrmann and Matthew G. Pereria.
Choe-Groves, Judge: This action concerns the U.S. Department of
Commerce’s (“Commerce”) final determination in Certain Aluminum Foil From
the Sultanate of Oman: Final Results of Antidumping Duty Administrative
Review; 2022-2023 (“Final Results”), 90 Fed. Reg. 44,162 (Dep’t of Commerce
Sept. 12, 2025) (final results of antidumping duty administrative review; 2023) (PR
Court No. 25-00215 Page 3
129) and accompanying Issues & Decision Memorandum for the Final Results of
the Administrative Review of the Antidumping Duty Order on Certain Aluminum
Foil from the Sultanate of Oman; 2022–2023 (Dep’t of Commerce Sept. 8, 2025)
(“Final IDM”), PR 117.1
Before the Court is the Memorandum in Support of Plaintiff’s Rule 56.2
Motion for Judgment on the Agency Record by Oman Aluminium Rolling
Company SPC (“Plaintiff” or “Oman Aluminium”). Mem. Law Supp. Pl.’s R.
56.2 Mot. J. Agency R. (“Plaintiff’s Motion for Judgment Upon the Agency
Record” or “Pl.’s Br.”), ECF Nos. 37, 38. Daikin Comfort Technologies North
America, Inc. (“Plaintiff-Intervenor”) moved for the same. Mem. Law Supp. Pl.-
Interv.’s R. 56.2 Mot. J. Agency R. (“Plaintiff-Intervenor’s Motion for Judgment
Upon the Agency Record” or “Pl.-Interv.’s Br.”), ECF No. 36. The United States
(“Defendant”) filed Defendant’s Response to Plaintiff’s and Plaintiff-Intervenor’s
Motions for Judgment Upon the Agency Record. Def.’s Resp. Opp’n Pl.’s and Pl.-
Interv.’s Mot. J. Agency R. (“Def.’s Resp. Br.”), ECF No. 42, 43. Defendant-
Intervenors Aluminum Associate Trade Enforcement Working Group and its
Individual Members, Grӓnges Americas, and JW Aluminum (collectively,
“Defendant-Intervenors”) filed a response brief. Def.-Intervs.’ Resp. Opp’n Pl.’s
1
Citations to the administrative record reflect the public record (“PR”) and
confidential record (“CR”) numbers filed in this case, ECF Nos. 50, 51.
Court No. 25-00215 Page 4
and Pl.-Interv.’s Mem. Supp. R. 56.2 Mot. J. Agency R. (“Def.-Intervs.’ Resp.
Br.”), ECF No. 44, 45. Both Plaintiff and Plaintiff-Intervenor filed reply briefs.
Pl.’s Reply Br., ECF No. 49; Pl.-Interv.’s Reply Br., ECF No. 47, 48. The Court
held oral argument on September 17, 2026. Oral Argument (Sept. 17, 2026), ECF
No. 54.
For the reasons discussed below, the Court remands Commerce’s Final
Results.
BACKGROUND
In December 2023, Commerce initiated an antidumping administrative
review of certain aluminum foil from the Sultanate of Oman (“Oman”). Initiation
of Antidumping and Countervailing Duty Administrative Reviews, 88 Fed. Reg.
90,168 (Dec. 29, 2023).
Commerce issued questionnaires to Oman Aluminium on March 25, 2024,
June 5, 2024, October 1, 2024, and October 10, 2024. See Administrative Review
of the Antidumping Duty Order on Aluminum Foil from Oman: Request for
Information (Mar. 25, 2024) (“Initial Questionnaire”), PR 12; Letter from Brendan
Quinn to Oman Aluminum Rolling Company, Oman Aluminum Rolling Company
First Supp. Questionnaire (June 5, 2024), PR 40; Letter from Brendan Quinn to
Oman Aluminum Rolling Company, Oman Aluminum Rolling Company Second
Supp. Questionnaire (Oct. 1, 2024) (“Second Supp. Questionnaire”), PR 52; Letter
Court No. 25-00215 Page 5
from Brendan Quinn to Oman Aluminum Rolling Company, Oman Aluminum
Rolling Company Third Supp. Questionnaire (Oct. 10, 2024) (“Third Supp.
Questionnaire”), PR 77. Throughout this time, Defendant-Intervenors filed
comments identifying alleged issues with Oman Aluminium’s responses regarding
calculation or allocation of certain freight expenses. See Letter from Kelley Drye
& Warren LLP to the Honorable Gina M. Raimondo, Petitioners’ Deficiency
Comments on the Sections C and D Questionnaire Resp. of Oman Aluminium
Rolling Company LLC (June 14, 2024) (“Def.-Intervs.’ Section C Comments”), at
11–13, PR 42; Letter from Kelley Drye & Warren LLP to the Honorable Gina M.
Raimondo, Petitioners’ Pre-Preliminary Comments Regarding the Oman
Aluminum Rolling Company LLC (Nov. 12, 2024) (“Def.-Intervs.’ Pre-
Preliminary Comments”), at 29–34, PR 82.
Commerce published its Preliminary Determination Memorandum on
December 6, 2024, and published its Preliminary Results on December 13, 2024.
Certain Aluminum Foil From the Sultanate of Oman: Preliminary Results of
Antidumping Duty Administrative Review; 2022-2023, 89 Fed. Reg. 100,976
(Dep’t of Commerce Dec. 13, 2024) (“Preliminary Results”), PR 95; Decision
Mem. for the Preliminary Results of the Administrative Review of the
Antidumping Duty Order on Certain Aluminum Foil from the Sultanate of Oman;
2022-2023 (Dep’t of Commerce Dec. 6, 2024) (“PDM”), PR 87. On December 9,
Court No. 25-00215 Page 6
2024, Commerce tolled the statutory and regulatory deadlines in this proceeding
and others for 90 days in order to shift agency resources to handle an
“unprecedented number of petitions for investigations,” “make available sufficient
staff for in-person verifications,” and “address complex and novel issues in less-
than-fair-value and countervailing duty investigations.” Mem. from Abdelali
Elouaradia to The Record, Tolling of Deadlines for Antidumping and
Countervailing Duty Proceedings (Dec. 9, 2024) (“Tolling Mem.”), at 2, PR 88.
One month later, Defendant-Intervenors filed a letter requesting that Commerce
extend the briefing schedule and urging that Commerce issue a supplemental
questionnaire regarding Oman Aluminium’s freight expenses. Letter from Kelley
Drye & Warren LLP to the Honorable Gina M. Raimondo, Administrative Review
of Certain Aluminum Foil from Oman – Request for Extension of Briefing
Schedule and Supplemental Questionnaire” (Jan. 7, 2025) (“Def.-Intervs.’ Jan. 7,
2025 Request”), at 3–9, PR 96. Commerce suspended the briefing schedule on
January 10, 2025, in response to Defendant-Intervenors’ January 7, 2025 Request.
Mem. from Alex Cipolla to The File, Suspension of Briefing Schedule (Jan. 10,
2025) (“Suspension Mem.”), PR 97. Oman Aluminium filed a response protesting
the suspension and disputing Defendant-Intervenors’ allegations, including an
Excel spreadsheet labeled Attachment 1 that illustrated calculations described in
the letter. Letter from Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP to the Honorable
Court No. 25-00215 Page 7
Gina M. Raimondo, Response to Petitioners’ Request for Extension of Briefing
Schedule and Supp. Questionnaire and the Department’s Suspension of Briefing
Schedule (Jan. 10, 2025) (“January 10, 2025 Letter” or “Pl.’s Jan. 10, 2025
Letter”), PR 98.
Upon review of the January 10, 2025 Letter, Commerce determined that
Attachment 1 disclosed new information that was not previously submitted on the
record. See Administrative Review of the Antidumping Duty Order on Certain
Aluminum Foil from the Sultanate of Oman: Accepting Untimely New Factual
Information on the Record and Resumption of Briefing Schedule (Dep’t of
Commerce Apr. 23, 2025) (“UNFI Order”), at 1, PR 104. Commerce ultimately
accepted Plaintiff’s January 10, 2025 Letter as new information, and explained that
there was good cause to accept the submission “[b]ased on [Commerce’s] intent to
inquire further regarding movement expenses, allocations, and revenue and [Oman
Aluminium’s] submission of limited information to this effect.” UNFI Order at 1–
2. Commerce did not establish an additional deadline for rebuttal information,
reasoning that the Parties had “already provided comments to rebut, clarify or
correct this [new factual information].” UNFI Order at 2. Commerce proceeded to
extend the briefing schedule from January 13, 2025 to April 30, 2025 for case
briefs and May 5, 2025 for rebuttal briefs. Id. Commerce later extended the
deadline for the Final Results from July 8, 2025 to September 8, 2025. See
Court No. 25-00215 Page 8
Administrative Review of the Antidumping Duty Order on Certain Aluminum Foil
from the Sultanate of Oman: Extension of Deadline for the Final Results of
Antidumping Duty Administrative Review (June 30, 2025) (“Results Extension
Order”), at 2, PR 110. Commerce issued the Final IDM on September 8, 2025 and
published the Final Results on September 12, 2025. Final IDM; Final Results, 90
Fed. Reg. 44,162.
JURISDICTION AND STANDARD OF REVIEW
The Court has jurisdiction pursuant to Section 516A(a)(2)(B)(iii) of the
Tariff Act of 1930, as amended, 19 U.S.C. § 1516a(a)(2)(B)(iii), and 28 U.S.C.
§ 1581(c). The Court shall hold unlawful any determination found to be
unsupported by substantial evidence on the record or otherwise not in accordance
with law. 19 U.S.C. § 1516a(b)(1)(B)(i).
DISCUSSION
I. Commerce’s Application of Facts Otherwise Available
Section 776 of the Tariff Act states that if “necessary information is not
available on the record,” then the agency shall “use the facts otherwise available in
reaching” its determination. 19 U.S.C. § 1677e(a)(1). 19 U.S.C. § 1677e(a)(2)
permits Commerce to select from facts otherwise available if an interested
party: (A) withholds information; (B) fails to provide such information by the
deadlines for submission, or in the form and manner requested; (C) significantly
Court No. 25-00215 Page 9
impedes a proceeding; or (D) provides such information but the information cannot
be verified. 19 U.S.C. § 1677e(a)(2). Commerce’s authority to use facts otherwise
available under 19 U.S.C. § 1677e(a) is subject to 19 U.S.C. § 1677m(d), which
states that:
If the administering authority or the Commission determines that a
response to a request for information under this subtitle does not
comply with the request, the administering authority or the Commission
(as the case may be) shall promptly inform the person submitting the
response of the nature of the deficiency and shall, to the extent
practicable, provide that person with an opportunity to remedy or
explain the deficiency in light of the time limits established for the
completion of investigations or reviews under this subtitle.
19 U.S.C. § 1677m(d).
If Commerce determines that “an interested party has failed to cooperate by
not acting to the best of its ability to comply with a request for information” from
the agency, then Commerce “may use an inference that is adverse to the interests
of that party in selecting from among the facts otherwise available.” Id.
§ 1677e(b)(1)(A). The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has
interpreted these two subsections to have different purposes. See Mueller
Comercial de Mexico, S. de R.L. De C.V. v. United States, 753 F.3d 1227, 1232
(Fed. Cir. 2014). Subsection (a) applies “whether or not any party has failed to
cooperate fully with the agency in its inquiry.” Id. (citing Zhejiang DunAn Hetian
Metal Co. v. United States, 652 F.3d 1333, 1346 (Fed. Cir. 2011)). Subsection (b)
applies only when Commerce makes a separate determination that the respondent
Court No. 25-00215 Page 10
failed to cooperate “by not acting to the best of its ability. Id. (quoting Zhejiang
DunAn Hetian Metal Co., 652 F.3d at 1346).
When determining whether a respondent has complied to the “best of its
ability,” Commerce “assess[es] whether [a] respondent has put forth its maximum
effort to provide Commerce with full and complete answers to all inquiries in an
investigation.” Nippon Steel v. United States, 337 F.3d 1373, 1382 (Fed. Cir.
2003). This determination requires both an objective and subjective showing. Id.
Commerce must determine objectively “that a reasonable and responsible
[respondent] would have known that the requested information was required to be
kept and maintained under the applicable statutes, rules, and regulations.” Id.
(citing Ta Chen Stainless Steel Pipe, Inc. v. United States, 298 F.3d 1330, 1336
(Fed. Cir. 2002)). Next, Commerce must demonstrate subjectively that the
respondent’s “failure to fully respond is the result of the respondent’s lack of
cooperation in either: (a) failing to keep and maintain all required records,
or (b) failing to put forth its maximum efforts to investigate and obtain the
requested information from its records.” Id. at 1382–83.
Adverse inferences are not warranted “merely from a failure to respond,” but
rather in instances when Commerce reasonably expected that “more forthcoming
responses should have been made.” Id. at 1383. “The statutory trigger for
Commerce’s consideration of an adverse inference is simply a failure to cooperate
Court No. 25-00215 Page 11
to the best of respondent’s ability, regardless of motivation or intent.” Id. To use
an adverse inference when selecting among the facts otherwise available under
Section 1677e(b), Commerce must assess whether the party used its maximum
efforts to secure the missing information. Id. at 1382.
A. Commerce’s Determinations That Oman Aluminium Misreported
Freight Expenses and Freight Revenues Are Not Supported by
Substantial Evidence
Pursuant to 19 U.S.C. § 1677e(a)(2), Commerce may use facts otherwise
available if an interested party: (A) withholds information; (B) fails to provide
such information by the deadlines for submission, or in the form and manner
requested; (C) significantly impedes a proceeding; or (D) provides such
information but the information cannot be verified. 19 U.S.C. § 1677e(a)(2).
In the Final IDM, Commerce determined that the use of facts otherwise
available was warranted pursuant to 19 U.S.C. § 1677e(a)(2)(A), (B), (C), and (D).
Final IDM at 6. This was a change from the Preliminary Results, in which
Commerce did not state concerns regarding the accuracy or completeness of Oman
Aluminium’s responses to date, including the issues established in Defendant-
Intervenors’ Section C Comments or Pre-Preliminary Comments. See generally
PDM. Commerce explained that the shift in the Final IDM was a result of Oman
Aluminium’s failure to provide “detailed allocation information supporting its
claimed movement expenses, by the deadlines established and [failure] to provide
Court No. 25-00215 Page 12
any information on its collection of freight revenues related to specific freight
expenses.” Final IDM at 6. In other words, Commerce determined that Plaintiff’s
new information submitted on January 10, 2025 was untimely and was information
that had been previously requested but not provided earlier in the administrative
review. As a result, Commerce determined that Oman Aluminium “ha[d] not
provided necessary information to the record” and “it [was] necessary to use facts
otherwise available.” Id. Without separately reported freight and associated
freight expenses, Commerce stated that it was unable to “apply[] its established
methodology of capping any service-related revenues when calculating U.S.
price.” Id. Commerce thus “appl[ied] a partial adverse facts available inference
with respect to the affected expenses (and revenues).” Id. at 7.
Plaintiff claims that the record does not show that Oman Aluminium
withheld requested information, asserting that Commerce’s determination is
contrary to law and not based on record evidence. Pl.’s Br. at 24–27, 32.
Defendant argues that Commerce reasonably exercised its discretion to determine
that Oman Aluminium withheld the information requested, failed to provide
information by the deadlines requested, and significantly impeded the proceeding.
Def.’s Resp. Br. at 12; see Final IDM at 6. Defendant-Intervenor asserts that
Commerce correctly determined that the use of facts otherwise available was
Court No. 25-00215 Page 13
reasonable pursuant to 19 U.S.C. § 1677e(a)(2)(A)–(D). See Def.-Intervs.’ Br. at
10, 29.
Among other requests in the Initial Questionnaire, Section A instructed that
the respondent should:
Report all price adjustments, sales expenses, and cost data in the
computer data files requested in sections B, C, and D of this
questionnaire. Report price adjustments and expenses on an allocated
basis (e.g., on an average basis) only when price adjustments and
expenses cannot be tied to a specific sale (e.g., indirect selling
expenses).
Initial Questionnaire at G-10. Given that the General Instructions to the Initial
Questionnaire requested allocation reporting “only when price adjustments and
expenses cannot be tied to a specific sale,” or when necessary to do so “when more
than one type or size of merchandise was shipped,” Oman Aluminium claims that
it did not need to report an allocation methodology. See Pl.’s Br. at 18–19; Initial
Questionnaire at G-10, C-18 to C-19; Letter from Akin Gump Strauss Hauer &
Feld LLP to the Honorable Gina M. Raimondo, Resp. to Sections C-D of the
Department’s Initial Questionnaire (May 15, 2024) (“Respondent CDQR”) at C-
23, PR 31 to 38. In its Section C responses, Oman Aluminium stated that it
provided transaction-specific expense reporting using expense data maintained in
three “stages” within its Systems, Applications, and Products in Data Processing
(“SAP”) system. Respondent CDQR at C-21. Oman Aluminium explained that
the stages of freight expenses were reported in the applicable freight fields on a
Court No. 25-00215 Page 14
per-unit basis, either in Omani Rial per metric ton or U.S. dollars per metric ton.
See id. at C-23 (Inland Freight to the Port of Exportation, “DINLFTPU”), C-24 to
C-25 (International Freight, “INTNFRU”), and C-27 (U.S. Inland Freight from
Warehouse to the Unaffiliated Customer, “INLFWCU”). For each field, Oman
Aluminium reported that the sample sale documentation provided in Exhibit A-8
did not have associated freight data in their SAP system, and thus Oman
Aluminium calculated and reported average freight expenses for that sale. See id.
The Exhibit A-8 package of sales trace documents was submitted as an example of
the documentation maintained for a single U.S. sale. Letter from Akin Gump
Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP to the Honorable Gina M. Raimondo, Resp. to Section
A of the Department’s Initial Questionnaire (Apr. 26, 2024) (“Respondent AQR”)
at A-16, PR 19 to 27.
Commerce determined that Oman Aluminium failed to provide necessary
information on the record regarding the allocation methodology because the
explanation in the January 10, 2025 submission was not previously disclosed. See
Final IDM at 6; UNFI Order at 1. Commerce’s determination relied on two
assertions: (1) that Attachment 1 reflected an allocation methodology that was
required to be disclosed; and (2) that such methodology was not disclosed prior to
the closing of the record. The record evidence does not support these assertions.
Court No. 25-00215 Page 15
First, Attachment 1 did not reflect an allocation methodology that should
have been disclosed. Section A of the Initial Questionnaire requested that
expenses be reported on an allocated basis “only when price adjustments and
expenses cannot be tied to a specific sale (e.g., indirect selling expenses).” Initial
Questionnaire at G-10. Plaintiff asserts that Attachment 1 was a demonstration of
how the sales trace documents submitted in Exhibit A-8 to Commerce on April 26,
2024 tied to the specific sales expense reporting for the single shipment at issue in
the exhibit. See Pl.’s Br. at 22. The Court agrees. Attachment 1 reflected a
calculation of dividing the total expenses for a single shipment containing two
orders of subject merchandise by the total quantity of the shipment to report the
freight expenses for each of the two sales. Comparing the documents in Exhibit A-
8 to the figures in Attachment 1, the claimed freight expenses in Attachment 1
appear to be tied to the specific sales in Exhibit A-8.2 See Respondent AQR at
Exhibit A-8; Pl.’s Jan. 10, 2025 Letter at Attachment 1. Because the expenses
were able to be tied to specific sales, the General Instructions did not require Oman
Aluminium to report the freight expenses for the shipment in Attachment 1 on an
2
The Court observes that the Invoice Number provided for the first sale in
Attachment 1 contained a typographical error in the last digit, but that all other
information regarding the details of the merchandise in the sale tied to the
documents in Exhibit A-8. Compare Pl.’s Jan. 10, 2025 Letter at Attachment 1,
with Respondent AQR at Exhibit A-8 at 9, 11–14, 22, 29.
Court No. 25-00215 Page 16
allocated basis, and therefore Oman Aluminium did not fail to disclose an
allocation methodology.
Second, the record reflects that the methodology reproduced in Attachment 1
was disclosed prior to the closing of the record. Defendant concedes that the
figures in Attachment 1 that were derived from the sales trace documents in
Exhibit A-8 were already on the record at the time of the January 10, 2025 Letter,
but contends that the explanation regarding the methodology was not disclosed.
Def.’s Br. at 17. Defendant specifically claims that Oman Aluminium had not
previously disclosed the allocation methodology that it “took the total expenses
and divided them by the total quantity of the shipment, and reported that resulting
figure for each sale included in the shipment.” Def.’s Br. at 17. The Court
disagrees. Oman Aluminium’s narrative responses to specific freight expenses
specifically noted that for the sample sale, the reported expenses were calculated as
an average. See Respondent CDQR at C-23 (DINLFTPU), C-25 (INTNFRU), C-
27 (INLFWCU). The calculations in Attachment 1 reflected the averaging of the
reported expenses for the two sales in the shipment. See Pl.’s Jan. 10, 2025 Letter
at Attachment 1. Given that Oman Aluminium’s initial responses addressed the
instruction and Defendant concedes that the figures in Attachment 1 were already
on the record at the time Attachment 1 was submitted to Commerce, the Court
Court No. 25-00215 Page 17
concludes that Oman Aluminium did not withhold the methodology information
from Commerce.
The Court observes that only one of the four relevant freight expense fields
included instructions regarding when allocation methodologies were required. The
instructions for the DINLFTPU field instructed Oman Aluminium that “[i]f you
shipped by common carrier, please submit the specific freight charges incurred on
each transaction and the method of allocation, when more than one type or size of
merchandise was shipped.” Initial Questionnaire at C-19. Oman Aluminium’s
response disclosed inland freight expenses reporting on a per-unit basis except for
the sample sale in Exhibit A-8. Respondent CDQR at C-23. Oman Aluminium
explained that it was reporting the “POR [period of review] average freight
expenses” for the sample sale because freight data was not available in its SAP
system. See id. The sample sale documents showed that the two sales included in
the single shipment involved the same type and size of merchandise. Compare
Respondent AQR at Exhibit A-8 at 49 (reflecting alloy, temper, gauge, and width
of merchandise), with id. at 63 (reflecting alloy, temper, gauge, and width of
merchandise). Oman Aluminium’s submission for the DINLFTPU field did not
require disclosure of an allocation methodology and was responsive to
Commerce’s instructions. Therefore, Commerce’s determination that Oman
Court No. 25-00215 Page 18
Aluminium withheld necessary information regarding its DINLFTPU expenses is
not supported by substantial evidence or in accordance with law.
For the INTNFRU, INLFWCU, and U.S. Customs Duty (“USDUTYU”)
fields, Commerce’s instructions required Oman Aluminium to report unit costs,
“[d]escribe how you calculated the unit cost,” and “include your worksheets as
attachments to the narrative response.” See Respondent CDQR at C-24, C-27 to
C-28. None of the instructions for reporting INTNFRU, INLFWCU, or
USDUTYU provided guidance or explained when reporting of allocation methods
would be required. See id. at C-24 to C-25, C-27 to C-28. Commerce stated that
Oman Aluminium “failed to plainly identify that such expenses reflected
allocations, not transaction-specific unit costs.” Final IDM at 5. Commerce’s
determination that Oman Aluminium misreported its INTNFRU (reported as
“INTNFR1U” and “INTNFR2U”), INLFWCU, and USDUTYU expenses was
premised on the assertion that Attachment 1 revealed an undisclosed allocation
methodology. See id. at 5–6. Commerce provided no further explanation as to
how or why Commerce reasonably concluded that the reporting of these expenses
reflected undisclosed allocations. The Court holds that Commerce’s determination
that Oman Aluminium failed to provide necessary information regarding its
INTNFR1U, INTNFR2U, INLFWCU, and USDUTYU expenses is not supported
by substantial evidence or in accordance with law.
Court No. 25-00215 Page 19
Commerce also determined that the January 10, 2025 Letter and Attachment
1 “revealed that freight revenues were included in the gross unit price for certain
sales, but not separately broken out as a variable in the sales database.” Final IDM
at 6, 11. Commerce asserted that Oman Aluminium “did not provide separate
reporting of expenses and any associated revenues, preventing further scrutiny of
the reported movement expenses and related revenues, and therefore, [Oman
Aluminium] failed to meet its burden of demonstrating its entitlement to such an
adjustment.” Id. at 8. However, Commerce provided no discussion in the Final
IDM to show why Commerce reasonably concluded that the January 10, 2025
Letter and Attachment 1 “revealed” that freight revenues were being included in
the gross unit price. Id. at 6. The available citations were only to discussion in the
January 10, 2025 Letter of how Oman Aluminium’s reported freight charges tied to
the documents in Exhibit A-8, and generally to Attachment 1. See id. at 6 & 6
n.35–37. Further, the Court observes that in responding to Oman Aluminium’s
rebuttal comments, Commerce disagreed with Oman Aluminium’s claim that it had
no freight revenues to report, and stated:
What is relevant is whether the service was provided, that the record
contains evidence that the service was negotiated between seller and
buyer, and that the revenues do not exceed the expenses to avoid a
violation of the requirements of section 772(c)(2) of the Act. Due to
[Oman Aluminium]’s failure to provide this information, the record
does not offer any such information to confirm the veracity of [Oman
Aluminium]’s claims.
Court No. 25-00215 Page 20
Id. at 12. Commerce articulated a standard but did not provide further explanation
for its determination. Commerce asserted that “the record contains evidence that
the service was negotiated between seller and buyer,” but provided no citation to
the relevant record evidence. Id. This Court has emphasized previously that “it is
not the Court’s responsibility to sift through the record to attempt to identify which
documents, if any, support Commerce’s determinations.” Jiangsu Senmao
Bamboo and Wood Industry Co. v. United States, 47 CIT __, __, 651 F. Supp. 3d
1348, 1358 (2023). Because Commerce failed to cite any record evidence to
support its assertion that service was negotiated between the seller and buyer, and
Commerce failed to explain why the January 10, 2025 Letter and Attachment 1
reasonably supported the determination that Oman Aluminium had concealed its
freight revenues, the Court concludes that Commerce’s determination that Oman
Aluminium concealed freight revenues is not supported by substantial evidence
and not in accordance with law.
Based on Commerce’s explanation in the Final IDM and a review of the
record documents, the Court concludes that Commerce’s determinations that
Plaintiff withheld information regarding its freight expense allocation methodology
and its freight revenue reporting were neither supported by substantial evidence
nor in accordance with law. The Court remands this issue for further review and
explanation consistent with this Opinion.
Court No. 25-00215 Page 21
B. Commerce’s Lack of Notice and Opportunity to Remedy or
Explain Deficiencies
Commerce’s authority under 19 U.S.C. § 1677e(a) to use facts otherwise
available is subject to a statutory obligation under 19 U.S.C. § 1677m(d) that
requires Commerce, when practicable, to notify a respondent promptly of the
nature of a deficiency in the record and to provide the respondent with an
opportunity to remedy or explain the deficiency. 19 U.S.C. §§ 1677e(a),
1677m(d). If the party submits a response that Commerce determines is
unsatisfactory or the response is not filed by the deadline set by Commerce, then
Commerce may disregard all or part of the original and subsequent responses. 19
U.S.C. § 1677m(d). Commerce can satisfy its obligations under 19 U.S.C.
§ 1677m(d) when it issues a supplemental questionnaire specifically pointing out
and requesting clarification on deficient responses. NSK Ltd. v. United States, 481
F.3d 1355, 1360 n.1 (Fed. Cir. 2007).
The issue of notice turns on whether the issuance of supplemental
questionnaires pursuant to 19 U.S.C. § 1677m(d) was practicable under the statute.
Defendant admits that Commerce did not provide a notice of deficiency regarding
Oman Aluminium’s movement expense reporting, but argues that Commerce was
not aware of issues with Oman Aluminium’s responses until January 10, 2025
(after the administrative record was closed and the Preliminary Results had been
issued), and that providing Oman Aluminium with an opportunity to remedy at that
Court No. 25-00215 Page 22
late stage of the administrative review was not “practicable.” See Def.’s Resp. Br.
at 10, 19–22. Plaintiff and Plaintiff-Intervenor claim that Commerce failed to
provide Oman Aluminium with notice of any deficiencies as required by 19 U.S.C.
§ 1677m(d). Pl.’s Br. at 23–24, 28–30, 33–34; Pl.’s Reply Br. at 3–7; Pl.-Interv.’s
Br. at 10–12. Plaintiff-Intervenor asserts that the burden was on Commerce to
request additional information in follow up to the broad questions of the Initial
Questionnaire. Pl.-Interv.’s Reply Br. at 2. Plaintiff and Plaintiff-Intervenor argue
that Commerce had ample time to send supplemental questionnaires regarding the
movement expenses prior to the Preliminary Results and prior to the issuance of
the Final Results. See Pl.’s Br. at 23, 26; Pl.-Interv.’s Reply Br. at 5–6. Plaintiff
and Plaintiff-Intervenor assert that Commerce was aware of issues with Oman
Aluminium’s movement expense reporting based on Defendant-Intervenors’
comments as of June 10, 2024, fifteen months prior to publication of the Final
Results. Pl.-Interv.’s Br. at 12–13, 15–16; Pl.’s Br. at 5, 23. Plaintiff contends that
even if Defendant-Intervenors’ repeated comments raising concerns regarding
Oman Aluminium’s movement expenses were ignored and Commerce was not
considered to be on notice of potential deficiencies in Oman Aluminium’s
reporting until January 10, 2025, Commerce still had several months to request
supplemental information and conduct its own investigation into Defendant-
Intervenors’ allegations. Pl.’s Br. at 29–30.
Court No. 25-00215 Page 23
Commerce may issue supplemental questionnaires pursuant to 19 U.S.C.
§ 1677m(d) if Commerce determines that a submission does not comply with a
request. Commerce may not need to issue notice, however, if Commerce had
already requested the same information. In Hyundai Heavy Industries v. United
States, which is cited by both Parties, the respondent claimed that Commerce failed
to provide an opportunity to remedy or explain a deficiency in reporting home
market sales. 44 CIT __, __, 485 F. Supp. 3d 1380, 1390–91 (2020), aff’d
following remand sub nom. Hyundai Elec. & Energy Sys. v. United States, 2022
WL 3273811 (Fed. Cir. Aug. 11, 2022). Commerce explained on remand that a
supplemental questionnaire was not necessary because the respondent had already
been given “multiple opportunities” to provide accurate information. Id. at 1398.
Commerce had already sent the respondent a supplemental questionnaire
requesting the information, and Commerce determined that the responses were
deficient. Id. At that point, after Commerce had already sought the information
from the respondent and in consideration of approaching deadlines, Commerce
determined that it was impractical to send another questionnaire. Id. The court
noted that 19 U.S.C. § 1677m(d) is not meant to “override the time-limits for
completing investigations or reviews, [ ] or to allow parties to submit continual
clarifications or corrections of information or to submit information that cannot be
evaluated adequately within the applicable deadlines.” Id. (citing Uruguay Round
Court No. 25-00215 Page 24
Agreements Act, Statement of Administrative Action (“SAA”), H.R. Doc. No.
103–316, vol. 1, at 865 (1994), reprinted in 1994 U.S.C.C.A.N. 4040, 4199).
Unlike Hyundai Heavy Industries, Commerce did not explain why issuance
of a supplemental questionnaire to Oman Aluminium was not “practicable.” See
44 CIT at __, 485 F. Supp. 3d at 1398. Commerce accepted the January 10, 2025
Letter and Attachment 1, noting that the acceptance was based on Commerce’s
“intent to inquire further regarding movement expenses, allocations, and revenue
and [Oman Aluminium’s] submission of limited information to this effect[.]”
UNFI Order at 1–2. Commerce did not request rebuttal briefing, reasoning that the
“parties have already provided comments to rebut, clarify or correct” the new
factual information. Id. at 2. The UNFI Order indicated that Commerce had been
“considering requesting information relating to the allocation of [Oman
Aluminium’s] movement expenses” and used that as the basis for determining
there was good cause to accept the documents. Id. at 1–2. At no point prior to the
issuance of the Final IDM did Commerce directly inform Oman Aluminium that it
considered the original reporting to be deficient. Commerce did not issue any
supplemental questionnaires disclosing the deficiency, and the general description
of Commerce’s consideration in the UNFI Order did not explicitly notify Oman
Aluminium of the deficiency—that Commerce believed that Oman Aluminium had
misreported its freight expenses and failed to disclose an allocation methodology.
Court No. 25-00215 Page 25
See Fuzhou Hengli Paper Co., Ltd. v. United States, 50 CIT __, __, 837 F. Supp.
3d. 1338, 1351 (2026) (holding that Commerce failed to comply with its obligation
under 19 U.S.C. § 1677m(d) when the supplemental questionnaire did not notify
the respondent of a deficiency nor instruct the respondent how to cure the
deficiency).
Plaintiff-Intervenor asserts that it would not have been unusual for
Commerce to issue supplemental questionnaires following the issuance of a
preliminary determination, as indicated by several examples in briefing. Pl.-
Interv.’s Br. at 8–9. Defendant argues that Commerce determined that it was not
practicable to provide Oman Aluminium with an opportunity to cure the deficiency
when the information “cannot be evaluated adequately within the applicable
deadlines.” Def.’s Br. at 22 (citing Hyundai Heavy Indus., 485 F. Supp. 3d at
1398–99 (citing SAA at 865)). During oral argument, Commerce explained that it
would not have been practicable for Commerce to provide notice to Oman
Aluminium because additional investigation would have involved substantial
additional processes, including issuance of the supplemental questionnaire,
allowance of time for parties to file responses and rebuttal, time for Commerce to
analyze those case briefs, and potentially issuance of additional supplemental
questionnaires. See Oral Arg. 01:04:10–01:05:22. However, none of the reasons
asserted by Defendant or Commerce appear in the Final IDM. Post-hoc
Court No. 25-00215 Page 26
explanations at oral argument cannot cure the lack of explanation by Commerce in
the Final IDM. See YDD Corp. LLP v. United States, 50 CIT