Full Opinion

Slip Op. 26-139 UNITED STATES COURT OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE KAPTAN DEMIR ÇELIK ENDÜSTRISI VE 7,&$5(7$ù, Plaintiff, and d2/$.2ö/80(7$/85-,$ùDQG d2/$.2ö/8',ù7,&$5(7$ù Plaintiff-Intervenors, Before: Gary S. Katzmann, -XGJH v. &RXUW1R25-00225 UNITED STATES, Defendant, and REBAR TRADE ACTION COALITION, Defendant-Intervenor. OPINION [ Plaintiff and Plaintiff-Intervenors’ Motions for Judgment on the Agency Record are denied. ] Dated: November 16, 2026 Daniel L. Delnero, BGD Legal & Consulting LLC, of Atlanta GA, argued for Plaintiff Kaptan 'HPLUdHOLN(QGVWULVLYH7LFDUHW$ù Jessica R. DiPietro, Matthew M. Nolan, and Tyler J. Kimberly, ArentFox Schiff LLP, of Washington, D.C., for Plaintiff-Intervenors dRODNR÷OX0HWDOXUMÕ$ùDQGdRODNR÷OX'Õú7LFDUHW $ù Natalee A. Allenbaugh, Trial Attorney, Commercial Litigation Branch, Civil Division, U.S. Department of Justice, of Washington, D.C., argued for Defendant the United States. With her on the briefs were Brett A. Shumate, Assistant Attorney General, Patricia M. McCarthy, Director, Franklin E. White, Jr., Assistant Director. Of counsel on the briefs was Heather Holman, Attorney, Court No. 25-00225 Page 2 Office of the Chief Counsel for Trade Enforcement and Compliance, U.S. Department of Commerce, of Washington, D.C. Maureen E. Thorston, Wiley Rein, LLP, of Washington, D.C., argued for Defendant-Intervenor Rebar Trade Action Coalition. With her on the brief were Alan H. Price, John R. Shane, Stephanie M. Bell, and Stephan A. Morrison. Katzmann, Judge: 7KLVFDVHLQVSLUHVDIHHOLQJRIGpMjYXFor a fifth time, Plaintiff Kaptan Demir Celik Endustrisi ve Ticaret A.S. (“Kaptan”) 1, a Turkish producer of rebar, 2 challenges an administrative review by the Department of Commerce (“Commerce”) of the countervailing duty order on Turkish rebar. Pl.’s Mot. for J. on the Agency R. and Accompanying Mem. of Points and Authorities Pursuant to Rule 56.2 at 2–3, May 4, 2026, ECF No. 43 (“Pl.’s Br.”); see Steel Concrete Reinforcing Bar from the Republic of Turkiye: Final Results of Countervailing Duty Administrative Review; 2022, 90 Fed. Reg. 44167, 44168 (Dep’t Com. Sep. 12, 2025), P.R. 291 (“Final Results”). 3 And for a third time, Kaptan specifically contests Commerce’s determination to value a rent-free lease of land using a report prepared by Colliers International (“Colliers”) 1 To ensure internal consistency and compatibility with future publication formats, the court represents Turkish language proper names without diacritics. 2 “Rebar is a long-UROOHGVWHHOSURGXFWFRPPRQO\XVHGLQFRQVWUXFWLRQSURMHFWVWRSURYLGHVWUHQJWK to concrete.” Steel Concrete Reinforcing Bar from Mexico and Turkey at 7, Inv. Nos. 701-TA-502 and 731-TA-1227 (Second Review), USITC Pub. 5722 (Apr. 2026). 3 Kaptan challenged four prior administrative reviews of the countervailing duty order on Turkish rebar. See Kaptan Demir Celik Endustrisi ve Ticaret A.S. v. United States, 159 F.4th 1334 (Fed. Cir. 2025) (“Kaptan I”) (2018 administrative review); Kaptan Demir Celik Endustrisi ve Ticaret A.S. v. United States, No. 22-00149 (U.S. Ct. Int’l Trade filed May 12, 2022) (“Kaptan II”) (2019 administrative review); Kaptan Demir Celik Endustrisi ve Ticaret A.S. v. United States, 49 CIT __, 803 F. Supp. 3d 1276 (2025) (“Kaptan III”) (2020 administrative review); Kaptan Demir Celik Endustrisi ve Ticaret A.S. v. United States, 49 CIT __, 803 F. Supp. 3d 1291 (2025) (“Kaptan IV”) (2021 administrative review). Kaptan II and Kaptan IV are presently before the court following remand in each case. See Order, Kaptan II, Feb. 12, 2026, ECF No. 70 (granting the Government’s unopposed motion for voluntary remand); Kaptan IV, 803 F. Supp. 3d at 1296. Kaptan III has been appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (“Federal Circuit”). See Kaptan Demir Celik Endustrisi ve Ticaret A.S. v. United States, No. 26-1229 (Fed. Cir. appeal docketed Dec. 9, 2025). Court No. 25-00225 Page 3 rather than a competing report prepared by Cushman & Wakefield (“C&W”). See Pl.’s Br. at 1– 2; Kaptan III, 803 F. Supp. 3d at 1290; Kaptan IV, 803 F. Supp. 3d at 1304. The court holds Commerce’s selection of a land valuation benchmark to be supported by VXEVWDQWLDOHYLGHQFH7KHFRXUWDFFRUGLQJO\GHQLHV.DSWDQ¶VPRWLRQIRUMXGJPHQWRQWKHDJHQF\ record. The court also denies D UHODWHG PRWLRQ IRU MXGJPHQW RQ WKH DJHQF\ UHFRUG EURXJKW E\ Plaintiff-Intervenors ColakogOX 0HWDOXUMi A.S. and Colakoglu Dis Ticaret A.S.’s (collectively, “Colakoglu”). See Pl.-Inters.’ Mot. for J. on the Agency R. Pursuant to Rule 56.2 of the Rules of the U.S. Ct. of Int’l Trade at 1, May 11, 2026, ECF No. 44 (“Pl.-Inters.’ Br.”). 4 BACKGROUND I. Legal Background The Tariff Act of 1930 provides a mechanism to level the playing field in international trade by empowering Commerce to address unfair trade practices. See LA Molisana S.p.A v. United States, 138 F.4th 1353, 1355 (Fed. Cir. 2025). One of these remedies, the imposition of a countervailing duty, is “directed towards the unfair conduct of foreign governments.” Guangdong Wireking Housewares & Hardware Co. v. United States, 745 F.3d 1194, 1196 (Fed. Cir. 2014). Foreign governments sometimes “subsidize[] the manufacture, production, or export of . . . merchandise.” Kaptan I, 159 F.4th at 1337. Such subsidies are considered “countervailable” unfair trade practices if they meet certain statutory criteria. See Gov't of Quebec v. United States, 105 F.4th 1359, 1362 (Fed. Cir. 2024) (citing 19 U.S.C. §§ 1677(5), (5A)). If Commerce determines that a countervailable subsidy exists—and the U.S. International Trade Commission GHWHUPLQHVWKDWDGRPHVWLFLQGXVWU\LVPDWHULDOO\LQMXUHGRULVWKUHDWHQHGZLWK PDWHULDOLQMXU\E\WKHVXEVLGL]HGLPSRUWV—“Commerce may impose countervailing duties on the 4 &RODNRJOXLVD7XUNLVKSURGXFHUDQGH[SRUWHURIUHEDUVXEMHFWWRWKHFRXQWHUYDLOLQJGXW\RUGHU at issue. See Pl.-Inter.’s Br. at 2. Court No. 25-00225 Page 4 VXEMHFW LPSRUWV HTXDO WR WKH DPRXQW RI WKH QHW FRXQWHUYDLODEOH VXEVLG\” Id. (citing 19 U.S.C. § 1671(a)). Countervailable subsidies may take the form of a foreign government’s provision of “goods or services . . . IRUOHVVWKDQDGHTXDWHUHPXQHUDWLRQ.” 19 U.S.C. § 1677(5)(E)(iv). Commerce’s regulations provide a framework for assessing DGHTXDWHremuneration. See Nucor Corp. v. United States, 927 F.3d 1243, 1246 (Fed. Cir. 2019) (citing 19 C.F.R. § 351.511(a)(2)). Commerce’s preferred approach is to PHDVXUH WKH DGHTXDF\ RI UHPXQHUDWLRQ E\ FRPSDULQJ WKH JRYHUQPHQW SULFH WR D market-determined price for the good or service resulting from actual transactions LQWKHFRXQWU\LQTXHVWLRQ Such a price could include prices stemming from actual transactions between private parties or actual imports. In choosing such transactions or sales, [Commerce] ZLOOFRQVLGHUSURGXFWVLPLODULW\TXDQWLWLHVVROG or imported; and other factors affecting comparability. 19 C.F.R. § 351.511(a)(2)(i). Each year after the publication of a countervailing duty order, Commerce (upon a party’s UHTXHVW PXVW³UHYLHZDQGGHWHUPLQH the amount of any . . . countervailable subsidy.” 19 U.S.C. § 1675(a)(1). “Each administrative review is a separate exercise of Commerce's authority that allows for different conclusions based on different facts in the record.” Qingdao Sea-Line Trading Co. v. United States, 766 F.3d 1378, 1387 (Fed. Cir. 2014). In countervailing duty proceedings, Commerce “obtains most of its factual information . . . from submissions made by interested parties during the course of the proceeding.” 19 C.F.R. § 351.301(a). “Although Commerce has authority to place documents in the administrative record that it deems relevant, ‘WKHEXUGHQRIFUHDWLQJDQDGHTXDWHUHFRUGOLHVZLWK [interested parties] and not with Commerce.’ ” QVD Food Co. v. United States, 658 F.3d 1318, 1324 (Fed. Cir. 2011) DOWHUDWLRQLQRULJLQDO  TXRWLQJ7LDQMLQ0DFK,PS ([S&RUSY8QLWHG States, 16 CIT 931, 936, 806 F. Supp. 1008, 1015 (1992)). Court No. 25-00225 Page 5 II. Factual Background Commerce issued a countervailing duty order on Turkish rebar in 2014. See Steel Concrete Reinforcing Bar From the Republic of Turkey: Countervailing Duty Order, 79 Fed. Reg. 65926, 65927 (Dep’t Com. Nov. 6, 2014). On December 29, 2023, Commerce initiated the administrative review for the period from January 1, 2022, through December 31, 2022. See Initiation of Antidumping and Countervailing Duty Administrative Reviews, 88 Fed. Reg. 90168, 90173 (Dep’t Com. Dec. 29, 2023), P.R. 12. 5 Commerce selected Kaptan and another company, Icdas Celik (QHUML7HUVDQHYH8ODVLP6DQD\L$6. (“Icdas”), as mandatory respondents. 6 See Mem. from A. Menon to E. Eastwood, re: Respondent Selection at 1 (Dep’t Com. Mar. 6, 2024), P.R. 25, C.R. 6. In its preliminary results, Commerce found that Nur Gemicilik ve Ticaret A.S. (“Nur”), Kaptan’s cross-RZQHG DIILOLDWH HQMR\HGDUHQW-free lease of government-owned land during the 2022 period of review. See Mem. from S. Fullerton to A. Elouaradia, re: Decision Memorandum for the Preliminary Results of the Countervailing Duty Administrative Review of Steel Concrete Reinforcing Bar from the Republic of Turkiye; 2022 at 11 (Dep’t Com. Dec. 6, 2024), P.R. 240 (“Prelim. IDM”). Consistent with previous determinations, Commerce found the program to be countervailable as a “regionally specific” “financial contribution in the form of land provided for >OHVVWKDQDGHTXDWHUHQXPHUDWLRQ@´ Prelim. IDM at 11–12 (citing 19 U.S.C. §§ 1677(5)(D)(iii), (5)(E)(iv), (5A)(D)(iv)). 5 “P.R” and “C.R.” refer to the index numbers of public and confidential documents in the amended MRLQWappendix. See Am. Public J.A., Oct. 23, 2026, ECF No. 63; Am. Confidential J.A., Oct. 23, 2026, ECF No. 64. 6 In antidumping duty administrative reviews, Commerce is charged with “determin[ing] the individual . . . dumping PDUJLQIRUHDFKNQRZQH[SRUWHUDQGSURGXFHURIWKHVXEMHFWPHUFKDQGLVH´ 19 U.S.C. § 1677f-1(c)(1). However, where determining individual margins is “not practicable” due to the “large number of exporters” involved in the review, Commerce may limit its examination to a “reasonable number” of exporters, referred to as mandatory respondents. Id. § 1677f-1(c)(2); see also 19 C.F.R. § 351.109. Court No. 25-00225 Page 6 Lacking any direct valuation method for how much Nur would otherwise have paid for the rent-free land, Commerce evaluated potential benchmarks submitted by interested parties. See id. at 12. Kaptan submitted a report prepared by C&W. See Letter from D. Simon to Sec’y Com., re: Kaptan Benchmark Submission at Ex. 1 (Nov. 6, 2024), P.R. 214, C.R. 255 (“C&W Report”); see also Letter from D. Simon to Sec’y Com., re: Kaptan Benchmark Submission at Ex. 4 (Nov. 6, 2024), P.R. 217, C.R. 258 (“Engagement Agreement”) (containing excerpt of the agreement between Kaptan and C&W). The Rebar Trade Action Coalition (“RTAC”), a group of domestic rebar producers that participated in the administrative review, submitted a report prepared by Colliers. Letter from Wiley Rein LLP to Sec’y Com., re: RTAC Benchmark Submission at Ex. 1 (Nov. 7, 2024), P.R. 221 (“Colliers Report”); see also Letter from Wiley Rein LLP to Sec'y Com., re: Rebar Trade Action Coalition (RTAC) 5HTXHVWIRU5HYLHZ 1RY 35 UHTXHVWLQJ administrative review). Commerce preliminarily relied on the Colliers report to “compute[] the amount Nur should have paid for its rent-free land during the [period of review]” using “rental prices from Cerkezkoy, Tekirdag.” Prelim. IDM at 12. On January 21, 2025, Kaptan submitted a case brief arguing that Commerce should use the C&W report, not the Colliers report, as a land valuation benchmark. See Letter from D. Simon to Sec’y Com., re: Kaptan’s Case Brief at 8–28 (Jan. 21, 2025), P.R. 268, C.R. 284 (“Kaptan’s Case Br.”). In particular, Kaptan challenged Commerce’s reliance on rental prices for “properties in an ‘industrial zone’ in Cerkezkoy, in Tekirdag province, within the ‘Greater Istanbul Industrial Area,’ ” id. at 8, arguing that “the area in which [the properties in the Colliers report] are located is so different, geographically and economically, from the Trabzon area of Nur’s property as to GLVTXDOLI\WKHPDVEHQFKPDUNV´id. at 10. On February 3, 2025, RTAC submitted a rebuttal brief, in which it argued that Commerce should continue to use the Colliers report. See Letter from Court No. 25-00225 Page 7 Wiley Rein LLP to Sec'y Commerce, re: Steel Concrete Reinforcing Bar from the Republic of Turkiye: RTAC's Rebuttal Brief (Feb. 3, 2025), P.R 278; C.R 286. In the Final Results, Commerce UHMHFWHG .DSWDQ¶V DUJXPHQWV DQG continued to use the Colliers report as a benchmark to value Nur’s rent-free lease. See Mem. from S. Fullerton to C. Abbott, re: Issues and Decision Memorandum for the Final Results of the Countervailing Duty Administrative Review of Steel Concrete Reinforcing Bar from the Republic of Türkiye; 2022 at 4, 9–11 (Dep’t Com. Sep. 8, 2025), P.R. 286 (“IDM”). Commerce calculated a subsidy rate of SHUFHQWIRUWKHSURYLVLRQRIODQGIRUOHVVWKDQDGHTXDWHUHQXPHUDWLRQ. Id. at 4. Commerce applied an overall countervailing duty rate of 2.43 percent to Kaptan and assigned the same rate to Colakoglu as a non-selected respondent. See Final Results, 90 Fed. Reg. at 44168; 19 U.S.C. § 1671d(c)(5). PROCEDURAL HISTORY Kaptan initiated the instant case against Defendant the United States (“the Government”) on October 10, 2025, challenging the Final Results. See Summons, Oct. 10, 2025, ECF No. 1; Compl., Oct. 11, 2025, ECF No. 8. Colakoglu intervened as Plaintiff-Intervenor. See Partial Consent Mot. to Intervene as a Matter of Right, Nov. 5, 2025, ECF No. 10; Order, Dec. 2, 2025, ECF No. 24 (granting Colakoglu’s motion to intervene). And RTAC intervened as Defendant- Intervenor. See Partial Consent Mot. to Intervene as a Matter of Right, Nov. 6, 2025, ECF No. 15; Order, Dec. 2, 2025, ECF No. 25 (granting RTAC’s motion to intervene). On May 4, 2026, .DSWDQILOHGDPRWLRQIRUMXGJPHQWRQWKHDJHQF\UHFRUG, followed by &RODNRJOX¶V PRWLRQ IRU MXGJPHQW RQ WKH DJHQF\ UHFRUG RQ 0D\  . See Pl.’s Br. at 3; Pl.-Inters.’ Br. at 1. On July 6, 2026, the Government and RTAC filed response briefs to Kaptan and Colakoglu’s motions. See Def.’s Resp. to Pl.’s Mot. for J. on the Agency R. at 1, July 6, 2026, ECF No. 47 (“Gov’t Br.”); Rebar Trade Action Coalition’s Resp. Br. at 1, July 6, 2026, ECF No. Court No. 25-00225 Page 8 45 (“Def.-Inter.’s Br.”). On August 3, 2026, and August 10, 2026, Kaptan and Colakoglu filed their respective reply briefs. See Reply Br. for Pl. Kaptan Demir Celik Endustrisi ve Ticaret A.S., Aug. 3, 2026, ECF No. 48 (“Pl.’s Reply”); Pl.-Inters.’ Reply Br. in Supp. of Their Mot. for J. on the Agency R., Aug. 10, 2026, ECF No. 49. 7KHFRXUWLVVXHGZULWWHQTXHVWLRQVto which the parties responded. See Qs for Oral Arg., Sep. 25, 2026, ECF No. 55; Pl. Kaptan Demir Celik Endustrisi ve Ticaret A.S. Answer to the Ct.’s Oral Arg. Qs, Oct. 9, 2026, ECF No. 58 (“Pl’s OAQ Resp.”); Def-Inter. Rebar Trade Action Coalition’s Resp. to the Ct.’s Qs for Oral Arg, Oct. 9, 2026, ECF No. 59 (“Def.-Inter.’s OAQ Resp.”); Def.’s Resp. to Oral Arg. Qs, Oct. 9, 2026, ECF No. 60 (“Def.’s OAQ Resp.”). The court held oral argument on October 14, 2026. ECF No. 61. At the court’s invitation, Kaptan and the Government submitted supplemental briefs following oral argument. See Pl. Kaptan Demir Celik Endustrisi ve Ticaret A.S.’s Post-Arg. Br., Oct. 23, 2026, ECF No. 65 (“Pl.’s Suppl. Br.”); Def.’s Post-Oral Arg. Submission, Oct. 23, 2026, ECF No. 66. All relevant filings are now before the court. -85,6',&7,21$1'67$1'$5'2)5(9,(: The cRXUWKDVMXULVGLFWLRQRYHUWKLVDFWLRQSXUVXDQWWR28 U.S.C. § 1581(c) and 19 U.S.C. § 1516a(a)(2). The standard of review is set forth in 19 U.S.C. § 1516a(b)(l)(B)(i): “[t]he court shall hold unlawful any determination, finding, or conclusion found . . . to be unsupported by substantial evidence on the record, or otherwise not in accordance with law . . . .” “A finding is supported by substantial evidence if a reasonable mind might accept the evidence as sufficient to support the finding.” Maverick Tube Corp. v. United States, 857 F.3d 1353, 1359 (Fed. Cir. 2017) (citing Consol. Edison Co. of N.Y. v. NLRB, 305 U.S. 197, 229 (1938)). ,QPDNLQJDQ\GHWHUPLQDWLRQ&RPPHUFHLVUHTXLUHGby statute to provide “an explanation of the basis for its determination that addresses relevant arguments, made by interested parties who Court No. 25-00225 Page 9 are parties to the investigation or review . . . .” 19 U.S.C. § 1677f(i)(3)(A). Commerce’s explanation should account for “contradictory evidence or evidence from which conflicting inferences could be drawn.” Suramerica de Aleaciones Laminadas, C.A. v. United States, 44 F.3d 978, 985 (Fed. Cir. 1994) (internal TXRWDWLRQ PDUNV DQG citation omitted). “[W]hile its explanations do not have to be perfect, the path of Commerce’s decision must be reasonably discernable to a reviewing court.” NMB Sing. Ltd. v. United States, 557 F.3d 1316, 1319 (Fed. Cir. 2009). The court will “refuse to consider” arguments challenging Commerce’s determination that a party did not present to Commerce in its case brief because “a party’s failure to raise an argument before Commerce constitutes a failure to exhaust its administrative remedies.” Qingdao Sea-Line, 766 F.3d at 1388 (first citing 19 C.F.R. § 351.309(c)(2); and then citing Dorbest Ltd. v. United States, 604 F.3d 1363, 1375 (Fed. Cir. 2010)) 7KH H[KDXVWLRQ UHTXLUHPHQW, as set forth in 28 U.S.C. § 2637(d), embodies “congressional intent that, absent a strong contrary reason, the court should insist that parties exhaust their remedies before the pertinent administrative agencies.” Boomerang Tube LLC v. United States)G )HG&LU  TXRWLQJ Corus Staal BV v. United States, 502 F.3d 1370, 1379 (Fed. Cir. 2007)). Additionally, arguments not included in a party’s opening brief are waived for purposes of the court’s review. See Novosteel SA v. U.S., Bethlehem Steel Corp., 284 F.3d 1261, 1274 (Fed. Cir. 2002). DISCUSSION I. Commerce’s Selection of a Land Valuation Benchmark Is Supported by Substantial Evidence and In Accordance with Law “Where Commerce must choose between two imperfect valuation reports, it had discretion to evaluate which report is generally more accurate . . . .” Kaptan III, 803 F. Supp. 3d at 1289–90 (first citing Timken Co. v. United States, 16 CIT 142, 147, 788 F. Supp. 1216, 1220 (1992); and Court No. 25-00225 Page 10 then citing Borusan Mannesmann Boru Sanayi Ve Ticaret A.S. v. Am. Cast Iron Pipe Co., 5 F.4th 1367, 1375 (Fed. Cir. 2021)). The court’s role is to evaluate whether Commerce’s selection is supported by substantial evidence and in accordance with law. See Borusan, 5 F.4th at 1374–1375. In making its selection, “[w]hen confronted with a colorable claim that the data that Commerce is considering is aberrational, Commerce must examine the data and provide a reasoned explanation as to why the data it chooses is reliable and non-distortive.” Mittal Steel Galati S.A. v. United States, 31 CIT 1121, 1135, 502 F. Supp. 2d 1295, 1308 (2007). In exercising its discretion, Commerce supported its selection of the Colliers report over the C&W report with substantial evidence and addressed relevant arguments made by interested parties that the data it relied upon is aberrational. The court finds Kaptan’s arguments to the contrary unpersuasive and denies Kaptan’s motion IRUMXGJPHQWRQWKHDJHQF\UHFRUG. A. Commerce’s Selection of the Colliers Report Based on Its Preference for Independent Reports Is Supported by Substantial Evidence Commerce “selects a ‘market-determined price for the good or service resulting from DFWXDOWUDQVDFWLRQVLQWKHFRXQWU\LQTXHVWLRQ¶ ´,'0DW TXRWLQJ&)5† 351.511(a)(2)(i)). Commerce stated that it “prefers to use benchmarks from independent, third-party sources, which is why Commerce used the Colliers report for [the] benchmark.” IDM at 10. Commerce cited previous administrative proceedings where it articulated a preference for independent reports, including proceedings in which Commerce “used information from Colliers International as a benchmark source . . . .” Id. 7 Commerce acknowledged Kaptan’s position that “there is nothing 7 In support, Commerce cited Certain New Pneumatic Off-the-Road Tires from India: Preliminary Affirmative Countervailing Duty Determination, Preliminary Affirmative Critical Circumstances Determination, in Part, and Alignment of Final Determination with Final Antidumping Determination, 81 Fed. Reg. 39903 (Dep’t Com. June 20, 2016), and accompanying preliminary decision memorandum at 32, unchanged in Countervailing Duty Investigation of Certain New Pneumatic Off-the-Road Tires from India: Final Affirmative Determination, and Final Affirmative Critical Circumstances Determination, in Part, 82 Fed. Reg. 2946 (Dep’t Com. Jan. 10, 2017). Court No. 25-00225 Page 11 to suggest that the C&W report was prepared for the purposes of this proceeding” as “its agreement with C&W instructed C&W to provide a valuation report for internal use for Kaptan’s accounts . . . .” Id. But Commerce nevertheless determined that “the C&W report . . . was prepared for the purposes of this proceeding . . . .” Id. at 9. Commerce therefore “continue[d] to find [the C&W report] incorporates a risk of litigation inspired fabrication or exaggeration” and “continue[d] to find it inappropriate to use the C&W report” to value Nur’s lease. Id. at 10 (internal TXRWDWLRQPDUNVDQGFLWDWLRQRPLWWHG  In contrast, Commerce determined that, “as the Colliers report is independently produced, there is not the concern that the report was biased and tailored to generate certain results for this proceeding.” Id. at 11. Kaptan does not challenge Commerce’s preference to use an independent report rather than a report commissioned by an interested party as a benchmark. See Pl.’s Br. at 2 (“Kaptan agrees with Commerce and the RTAC that an independent report valuing the Nur Leasehold should be accepted over a report prepared by an interested party.”). Nor does Kaptan dispute Commerce’s determination that the Colliers report is “a report prepared by an independent third party.” Kaptan’s Case Br. at 8; see Pl.’s Br. Kaptan instead argues that Commerce’s preference for the Colliers report “is not based on DQ\DFWXDOHYLGHQFHWRMXVWLI\WKHDFFXVDWLRQWKDWWKH>& :@[r]eport is in any way fabricated or exaggerated.” Pl.’s Br. at 18. RTAC and the Government counter Commerce’s did not determine that the C&W report is actually fabricated, rather “[Commerce] simply stated that the fact that [the C&W report] was commissioned for this proceeding increased [the] risk [of litigation-inspired IDM at 10 n.32. Commerce also cited Certain Softwood Lumber Products from Canada: Final Results and Final Rescission, in Part, of the Countervailing Duty Administrative Review; 2021, 88 Fed. Reg. 50103 (Dep’t Com. Aug. 1, 2023) and accompanying issues and decision memorandum at Comment 12 and Coated Free Sheet Paper from Indonesia: Final Affirmative Countervailing Duty Determination, 72 Fed. Reg. 60642 (Dep’t Com. Oct. 25, 2007). Id. at 10 n.31. Court No. 25-00225 Page 12 exaggeration] . . . .” Def.-Inter.’s OAQ Resp. at 3 (emphasis omitted); see also Gov’t Br. at 10 (“Commerce is not, as Kaptan argues, ‘accusing the internationally respected company Cushman & Wakefield of misrepresent[ation].’ ´ DOWHUDWLRQLQRULJLQDO  TXRWLQJ3O¶V%UDW  Record evidence supports Commerce’s determination that the C&W report was commissioned by Kaptan for purposes of this proceeding. The cover page of the C&W report states that the report was prepared for Kaptan. See C&W Report at 1. As noted by the Government, the C&W report was completed in June 2023, see id., “shortly before these proceedings” were initiated in December 2023 to retrospectively value the Nur leasehold in 2022. Gov’t Br. at 9 (emphasis omitted) TXRWLQJKaptan III, 803 F. Supp. 3d at 1290). The C&W report indicates that C&W relied in part on information “received from [the] client,” Kaptan, in conducting its analysis. C&W Report at 2. Additionally, Kaptan’s agreement with C&W specifies that “C&W will make an Assumption that the information provided by the Client and/or its professional advisers . . . in respect of the Property to be valued is both full and correct.” Engagement Agreement at 28. The C&W report’s stated reliance on data provided by Kaptan supports Commerce’s determination because, as the Government explains, “the report was based on data Kaptan may have changed or cherry picked and the underlying data on which the report ZDVEDVHGDUHQRWRQWKHUHFRUGWKHUHE\FDOOLQJLQWRTXHVWLRQWKHRYHUDOOUHOLDELOLW\RIWKHUHSRUW.” Gov’t Br. at 10. It is reasonably discernible that Commerce’s determination was based on the contents of the C&W report and Kaptan’s engagement agreement with C&W. See NMB Sing., 557 F.3d at 1319; see also Gov’t OAQ Resp. at 3 (arguing that Commerce’s rationale is reasonably discernible “based on Commerce’s reference to the dated C&W [r]eport´ &RPPHUFHFRQVLGHUHGDQGUHMHFWHG Kaptan’s assertion that “its agreement with C&W instructed C&W to provide a valuation report Court No. 25-00225 Page 13 for internal use for Kaptan’s accounts,” which indicates that Commerce considered the contents of that agreement. See IDM at 10. Commerce further explained that its determination is consistent with prior administrative reviews. See id. at 9 n.27 (citing administrative review at issue in Kaptan III); see also Kaptan III, 803 F. Supp. 3d at 1288–91 (sustaining Commerce’s determination that “the C&W report bore higher risk of litigation-inspired fabrication”). Kaptan’s counterargument regarding the timing of the C&W report undermines its position. Kaptan contends that “there would be no need to determine average real estate prices in Trabzon prior to Commerce’s decision to countervail the Nur Leasehold for the 2022 period of review.” Pl.’s Reply at 8–9. This representation suggests that Kaptan was prompted to commission the C&W rHSRUW E\ WKH DGPLQLVWUDWLYH UHYLHZ LQ TXHVWLRQ ZKLFK LV FRQVLVWHQW ZLWK &RPPHUFH¶V determination that it was prepared for purposes of the proceeding. Kaptan does not present any RWKHUEXVLQHVVMXVWLILFDWLRQIRUFRPPLVVLRQLQJDUHSRUWLQDVVHVVLQJDYHUDJHUHDOHVWDWHSULFHV for the preceding year. See id; Pl.’s Br.; see also Def.-Inter.’s Br. at 13 (“[T]here is no apparent reason why Kaptan would commission [a] report[] in . . . 2023 to estimate the market rental value of Nur’s . . . land in prior years, beyond use in Commerce’s benchmarking exercise.”). Kaptan remaining arguments that the C&W report is reliable do not alter the analysis. Kaptan argues that the C&W report is reliable because “it is based on independent standards in the valuation industry; specifically, the RICS Valuation Standards . . . .” Pl.’s Br. at 7. The Government counters that regardless of the use of the RICS Valuation Standards, Commerce’s determination was reasonable because the C&W report relied on information obtained from Kaptan. See Gov’t Br. at 9–10. C&W’s use of industry standard practices in preparing the report does not undermine Commerce’s determination that the C&W report “was prepared for the purposes of this proceeding” or Commerce’s “preference to use benchmarks from independent, Court No. 25-00225 Page 14 third-party sources” in exercising its discretion. IDM at 9–10. Finally, in reply Kaptan asserts that C&W report relied on rental listings from an “official Turkish Government website” as the source of information about land value in Trabzon. See Pl.’s Reply at 8. The Government responds that Kaptan did not present this argument to Commerce and therefore failed to exhaust its administrative remedies. See Gov’t OAQ Resp. at 5–7. The Government is correct; in its case brief to Commerce, Kaptan stated that “[t]he benchmark in the C&W report is the average of rental rates for 13 individual, privately-owned properties in Trabzon province[,]” but it did not argue that that the source of these rental rates was a Turkish Government website. Kaptan’s Case Br. at 20. Nor did Kaptan argue that the C&W report is reliable because it used official data in its analysis. See id. Kaptan failed to administratively exhaust its argument on this point, and the court therefore declines to consider it. 8 See Boomerang Tube, 856 F.3d at 912–13; see also Tenaris Bay City, Inc. v. United States, 191 F.4th 1370, 1381 (Fed. Cir. 2026) (holding “JHQHUDOREMHFWLRQVWRWKHUHOLDELOLW\RIWKHVRXUFHV&RPPHUFHXVHG” did not exhaust a specific argument that the sources were flawed). In sum, Commerce’s determination that Kaptan commissioned the C&W report “for the purposes of this proceeding” is supported by substantial evidence. IDM at 9. Based on this determination, Commerce’s selection of the Colliers report is consistent with its “prefer[ence] to use reports from independent, third-party sources” articulated in prior administrative proceedings. Id. at 10. As in Kaptan III, “in showing that Commerce has historically preferred to choose reports that were . . . more independent, Commerce acted reasonably in choosing the Colliers report.” 803 8 The Government also argues that Kaptan waived its argument by not including it in the opening brief. See Gov’t OAQ Resp. at 5–7. And RTAC asserts that the cited website pertains only to a portion of the C&W report that is not relevant to the benchmark selection. See Def.-Inter.’s OAQ Resp. at 4. Because the court declines to consider the argument due to Kaptan’s failure to exhaust its administrative remedies, the court does not consider RTAC and the Government’s additional arguments. Court No. 25-00225 Page 15 F. Supp. 3d at 1290. B. Commerce Adequately Addressed Kaptan’s Arguments that Reliance on the Colliers Report is Unreasonable Kaptan next argues that Commerce’s selection of the Colliers report is “per se unreasonable” because Commerce relied on data from the Colliers report that valued land in “the higher-developed, suburban Istanbul market of Cerkezkov, a high-rent suburb on the European side of Istanbul,” and the Colliers report “does not take into account any transactions from more remote and less developed markets such as Trabzon, the location of the actual Nur Leasehold at issue.” Pl.’s Br. at 13 (emphasis omitted). Kaptan repeatedly underscores that the Nur leasehold is located approximately 750 miles away from Greater Istanbul. See, e.g., id. at 10, 12–14. Kaptan argues that “property values from Greater Istanbul cannot be used as a proxy for land values 750 miles away, in the distant, rural region of Trabzon.” Id. at 20. 9 Kaptan further argues that “Commerce did not sufficiently address Kaptan’s argument that real estate trends in Greater Istanbul cannot be used to determine the value of land in rural Trabzon, located 750 miles away” because Commerce “refused to credit any of the data and analysis contained in the [C&W] [r]eport . . . .” Pl.’s OAQ Resp. at 2; see also Pl.’s Br. at 11 (arguing that “Commerce did not sufficiently consider Kaptan’s arguments” that Commerce should use the C&W report instead of the Colliers report). 10 9 Neither the Government nor RTAC disputes Kaptan’s characterization that Cerkezkoy is part of the Istanbul region, or that Trabzon is less developed and located approximately 750 miles from Istanbul. See Gov’t Br. at 13; Def.-Inter.’s Br. at 7–9. Kaptan in its case brief provided maps showing the distance between Surmene, Trabzon, the site of Nur’s leasehold, and Cerkezkoy, Tekirdag, near Istanbul, along with economic data for both regions. See Kaptan’s Case Br. at 23–26. Commerce likewise did not dispute the accuracy of these maps or the geographic and economic information presented by Kaptan. See IDM at 9–11. 10 In its post-argument supplemental brief, Kaptan asserts that no authority supports the conclusion “that the fact that two regions are in the same country is a sufficient basis on which to calculate a [countervailing duty] margin.” Pl.’s Suppl. Br. at 3. Kaptan did not present this argument in its Court No. 25-00225 Page 16 In response, the Government asserts that Commerce provided a “ ‘reasoned explanation’ as to why the data Commerce relied upon is reliable and non-distortive.” Gov’t Br. at 13 (TXRWLQJ Mittal Steel Galati, 31 CIT at 1135, 502 F. Supp. 2d at 1308). RTAC argues that Kaptan “failed to provide evidence of the nature of such a relationship, or even its existence,” and “the agency was not obliged to simply take at face value Kaptan’s argument that these factors rendered reliance on the Colliers [r]eport unreasonable.” Def.-Inter.’s Br. at 9–10. RTAC further contends that Kaptan’s argument is flawed because it relies on data contained in the C&W report and thus “reflects a logical fallacy” because, “while a difference in the values provided by two data sets may indicate that one of the data sets is distorted, it does not indicate which one.” Id. at 14. &RPPHUFH UHMHFWHG .DSWDQ¶V DUJXPHQWV UHJDUGLQJ WKH HFRQRPLF DQG JHRJUDSKLF differences between the location of the Nur leasehold and Greater Istanbul on the basis that ³.DSWDQKDVQRWSURYLGHGDQ\HYLGHQFHIRUDTXDQWLILDEOHGLIIHUHQFHLQWKHVHIDFWRUV . . . that would indicate that the Colliers report is not comparable to [Nur’s leasehold].” IDM at 10. Commerce determined that Kaptan did not place evidence on the record demonstrating that regional economic differences “have a specific effect, such as data showing a consistent increase in land values in more distant provinces, provinces with higher GDPs, provinces with high trade levels, or in areas with more developed land.” Id. at 11. Commerce further explained: WKHUHLVQRTXDQWLILDEOHOLQNEHWZHHQWKHSUHVHQFHRIWKHVHIDFWRUVDQGDQHIIHFWRQ industrial rents. 8QOHVV VXFK IDFWRUV DUH DGHTXDWHO\ VXEVWDQWLDWHG &RPPHUFH cannot determine their relevance, and Kaptan has not demonstrated their SURSRUWLRQDOHIIHFWLWMXVWVXSSOLHGGDWDLQGLFDWLQJWKDWWKHUHDUHLQWHUQDOGLIIHUHQFHV in the Turkish economy. Thus, while each of these factors, if substantiated, are ones we would consider in determining whether to select the C&W report or the Colliers opening brief to the court. See Pl.’s Br. “As a matter of litigation fairness and procedure, then, we must treat this argument as waived.” Novosteel, 284 F.3d at 1274. This argument is further unavailing as the relevant regulation states that “[Commerce] will normally seek to measure the DGHTXDF\RIUHPXQHUDWLRQE\FRPSDULQJWKHJRYHUQPHQWSULFHWRDPDUNHW-determined price for the good or service resulting from actual transactions LQ WKH FRXQWU\ LQ TXHVWLRQ.” 19 C.F.R. § 351.511(a)(2)(i) (emphasis added). Court No. 25-00225 Page 17 report, neither the [C&W] report nor Kaptan itself has provided any supporting evidence that these factors result in a measurable difference in comparability such that Commerce should favor the C&W report data. Id. Commerce’s explanation here is substantially similar to the explanation the court sustained in Kaptan III following remand for further explanation. Compare IDM at 10–11, with Final Results of Redetermination Pursuant to Ct. Remand Order at 17–19, 35–36, Kaptan Demir Celik Endustrisi ve Ticaret A.S. v. United States, No. 23-00131 (U.S. Ct. Int’l Trade filed June 21, 2023), Jan. 21, 2025, ECF No. 53 (“Kaptan III Remand Results”)$VLQWKDWFDVH&RPPHUFHKHUHDGHTXDWHO\ addressed Kaptan’s assertions regarding distance and regional economic differences “by showing that the record failed to make them relevant.” Kaptan III, 803 F. Supp. 3d at 1289. Kaptan does not dispute the similarity of Commerce’s explanation to the Kaptan III Remand Results, nor does Kaptan argue that the record evidence in this case differs from the record evidence in Kaptan III. See Pl.’s OAQ Resp. at 6. 11 In arguing that Commerce’s response is deficient, Kaptan relies on differences in average list prices between Trabzon and the Greater Istanbul area contained in the C&W report. See Pl.’s OAQ Resp. at 4 (citing C&W Report at 28). Kaptan cites its own case brief as evidence that “differences in GDP, rental rates, distance, industrialization, and other geographic and economic factors between Trabzon and Greater Istanbul account for the vast difference in land value between the two regions.” Id. Kaptan’s case brief, in turn, cited data on regional GDP, population growth rates, import and export data, and rental rates for unimproved industrial land calculated by the 11 Kaptan states there is “one key difference between” the two proceedings, which relates to the year of the data underlying Kaptan’s benchmark submission in each case. Pl.’s OAQ Resp. at 6. The distinction Kaptan identifies does not pertain to the existence of record evidence to support Kaptan’s assertion that regional economic differences render the Colliers report unreliable. See id. Court No. 25-00225 Page 18 C&W report. See Kaptan’s Case Br. at 24–25.