Tyler Gordon, Michael Craft, and Mary Blakemore v. City of Shreveport
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
Docket57,203-CA
JudgeStephens
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Judgment rendered November 18, 2026.
Application for rehearing may be filed
within the delay allowed by Art. 2166,
La. C.C.P.
No. 57,203-CA
COURT OF APPEAL
SECOND CIRCUIT
STATE OF LOUISIANA
*****
TYLER GORDON, MICHAEL Plaintiffs-Appellants
CRAFT, AND MARY
BLAKEMORE
versus
CITY OF SHREVEPORT Defendant-Appellee
*****
Appealed from the
First Judicial District Court for the
Parish of Caddo, Louisiana
Trial Court No. 661,810
Honorable Ramon Lafitte, Judge
*****
WALTZER WIYGUL GARSIDE & WILD Counsel for Appellants
By: Clay Garside
JACK BAILEY LAW CORPORATION
By: Jack Bailey, III
CARMOUCHE, BOKENFOHR, Counsel for Appellee
BUCKLE & DAY, PLLC
By: Nichole M. Buckle
*****
Before STONE, STEPHENS, and ROBINSON, JJ.
STEPHENS, J.,
This civil appeal arises from the First Judicial District, Parish of
Caddo, State of Louisiana, the Honorable Ramon Lafitte, Judge, presiding.
The plaintiffs, Tyler Gordon, Michael Craft, and Mary Blakemore, have
appealed from the trial court’s judgment affirming the Shreveport City
Council’s decision approving a special use permit. For the reasons
expressed below, we affirm the trial court’s judgment.
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
On October 17, 2025, Bohler Engineering filed a development
application with the Shreveport/Caddo Metropolitan Planning Commission
(“MPC”), seeking a special use permit for a proposed data center. Bohler
requested that the data center be developed on approximately 254 acres
zoned I-1 PUD, Light Industrial Planned Unit Development (“PUD”), an
area known as Resilient Technology Park located off Greenwood Road. The
application requested approval for seven buildings, each measuring 400,000
sq. ft., to be used as a data center, along with various support buildings such
as water storage, a substation, a lift station, and offices. The Bohler Project
Team held a community meeting about the project on November 13, 2025,
where an open floor discussion occurred at the Bill Cockrell Community
Center in Shreveport involving the project’s purpose, design elements, and
anticipated timeline, as well as community considerations and feedback.1
Following Bohler’s development application, the MPC staff issued a
report which included findings that data centers are permitted within the I-1
1
The staff report indicated that 11 members of the neighborhood community were
present as well as elected officials, several members from the applicant team, and two
MPC staff members. The community members raised concerns about the impact to the
water and electrical supply, traffic, and noise generated by the proposed data center. Job
creation potential and other benefits to the community were also discussed.
base zoning district, but that a special use permit is required when the site is
located within 200 feet of a residentially zoned district. The report described
that the proposed site at Resilient Technology Park was rezoned on several
occasions and had previous plan approvals for various developments, but
these prior developments never occurred.2 The report also detailed that the
proposed site abuts residentially zoned districts on the north and east sides;
therefore, a special use permit application was required. The MPC staff
explained that the closest residential dwelling is approximately 250 feet
from the property boundary of the proposed site. The MPC staff report
ultimately concluded that the proposed development properly mitigated the
impact of the proposed use, and approval was warranted. In the report, all
12 criteria of development standards and design specifications were deemed
satisfied as follows:
Section 16.3.E.1: the design, location, and operating plans of an SUP
must be such that the public health, safety and/or welfare is protected.
Since the property in question is part of a PUD, the site plan
incorporates several amenities beyond the minimum requirements
of the code that are intended to protect the public health, safety, and
welfare of the surrounding property owners. The amenities are as
follows: a. Two dense wooded buffers located throughout the site to
shield surrounding properties from activities at the site, including: (1)
2
The MPC staff report detailed the zoning history as follows:
“In 1990, the rear portion of this site was rezoned from R-A to I-2 and
received site plan approval for industrial manufacturing, warehouse &
distribution (C-55-90). There was a stipulation to revert to R-A if
development did not occur. The property reverted to R-A due to this
stipulation. In 2011, the entire lot was rezoned from R-A to R-A-E,
Rural Ag Extended Use for a proposed warehouse and distribution
center. Again, development did not occur, and the zoning reverted to
R-A (C-76-11). In 2016, the property was rezoned from R-A to I-1
(PUD). If development didn’t occur within 2 years, then the only
thing that expired was the preliminary plat. The PUD designation
stayed, along with all stipulations and public amenities. Development
did not occur within two years, and the preliminary site plan expired.
The I-1 PUD designation remained. (C-6-16). In 2020, a new
preliminary site plan was approved for a SWEPCO transmission
control center. (20-197-C).”
2
A 150’ wide forested buffer separating the proposed development
from the residentially zoned property along its western and northern
boundaries shall be maintained and preserved; and (2) A wooded
buffer of an undetermined size at the southern end (front) of the
property to separate it from the existing B-S and I-1 uses along
Greenwood Rd. shall likewise be maintained and preserved; b. Tree
preservation at the site which will leave a substantial wooded area
along the south eastern boundary and serves to separate the property
from the existing I.1 use adjacent to the site; c. Use of building
materials with high solar reflexive indices to minimize heat island
effect; d. Additional landscaping will be provided at the site of the
detention ponds; and e. Signage at the site will be limited to
monument and architectural signage styles.
Section 16.3.E.2: the proposed special use is compatible with the
general land use of adjacent properties and other property within 300
feet. The proposed building area is situated more than 500 feet from
the nearest residential dwelling, providing a substantial spatial
buffer between the use and surrounding neighborhoods mitigating
potential land-use conflicts. The site contains mature vegetation along
its perimeter, which the applicant intends to retain in order to preserve
existing visual screening and reduce potential impacts. Due to the
sites proximity to an interstate and a major highway, ambient noise
levels in the area are already elevated; therefore, noise generated by
the data center’s operations is not anticipated to exceed existing
background conditions. Additionally, the proposed use is
characterized by low trip generation and is not expected to produce
traffic volumes that would negatively affect adjacent roadways or
residential areas. Based on the site’s layout, the retention of existing
buffers, and the low-intensity operational characteristics of the use,
the proposed development is expected to be compatible with
surrounding land uses.
Section 16.3.E.3: the special use conforms to the regulations of the
zoning district where it will be located. The proposal exceeds the
zoning district regulations and all amenities from the approved PUD
are met, as proposed in the site plan.
Section 16.3.E.4: the location and dimensions of all public rights-of-
way on or abutting the proposed special use. Primary access to the
site will be from Resilient Way, which is a recently constructed public
dedication that also serves the SWEPCO transmission control center.
Future access to the site is proposed from Bert Kouns Industrial Loop,
which is currently undeveloped. The site plan proposes a future
extension of the Industrial Loop; however, this will require separate
approval from the subject application. A traffic impact study will be
required prior to the release a building permit. It’s important to note
3
that a traffic impact study will not determine whether a land use
should be denied or not, rather it will determine if changes to the right
of way are necessary to accommodate the proposed use.
Section l6.3.E.5: existing and proposed vehicular and pedestrian
circulation systems; including streets, alleys, walkways, service areas
and loading areas, the location and arrangement of off-street parking
areas and all points of vehicular entrance and exit. Off-street vehicle
parking is no longer required to meet a specific minimum ratio
following the adoption of the recent parking reform code text
amendment. The applicant has proposed 750 vehicle parking spaces,
which they indicate is necessary to support the needs of the facility.
This should not be interpreted as representing the total number of
vehicles expected to be on site at any given time. As indicated, this is
a low traffic generating use; however, due to the scale of the overall
development, each building requires an adequate supply of parking
spaces, resulting in a higher cumulating parking count.
In terms of site access, the primary driveway on Resilient Way is
situated at the far northern end of the property. This configuration
allows vehicles entering the site to be fully removed from Greenwood
Road, minimizing the potential for vehicle stacking or congestion
along the roadway that could interfere with other motorists. The
traffic impact study will reveal whether further mitigation is
warranted.
Section 16.3.E.6: the outdoor surfacing end paving for all parking
and loading areas. The outdoor parking areas will comprise of heavy-
duty concrete, meeting the code requirements.
Section 16.3.E.7: the proposed perimeter treatment of the property,
with indication of screening materials to be used, including fences,
walls, and plants: together with a description of uses, setbacks and
the relationship to surrounding areas. Section 16.3.E.8: a landscape
plan showing proposed treatment of the areas designated as either
buffers or open space. As required by the 2016 PUD approval, a 150’
buffer yard will be preserved at the northern boundary of the site
where it abuts undeveloped residentially zoned property. On the
eastern portion of the site, the proposed buildings will be situated
approximately 443’ from the adjacent undeveloped residential parcel.
While the UDC requires a minimum buffer yard of 30’ when an
industrial district abutting residential, the site plan shows that existing
vegetation at a depth of approximately 300’ will remain on the east
property boundary and 150’ on the north boundary. Given the
proximity to residentially zoned land, these areas warrant heightened
sensitivity with respect to the impact of the proposed use. The
additional vegetated buffer significantly exceeds minimum
4
requirements and provides appropriate mitigation between the
proposed industrial use and the adjoining residential properties.
Section 16.3.E.9: the location and dimensions of all existing and
proposed easements and public improvements on the site. The City of
Shreveport Public Works Department has reviewed the plans. There
are no known easements or public improvements on site.
Section 16.3.E.10: the location and size of all structures, distances
between buildings, and distances from structures to property lines.
Section 16.3.E.12: the proposed use of all structures and their
dimensions, i.e., height, floor areas, entrances, and loading areas. As
previously indicated, there is substantial distance of the proposed
buildings to the property lines, mitigating the impact of the use. Each
building will be 400,000 sf in area and is sited at the interior portions
of the site where visibility from surrounding property and Greenwood
Road is minimal. The I-1 zoning district limits building height to 60’,
measured as the vertical distance from grade to the top of the highest
point of the roof or structure; excluding penthouses to house
mechanical appurtenances; however, the UDC allows the building to
exceed this building height provided that each required front, side, and
rear yard is increased one foot for each foot of such excess height. As
such, the applicants proposal of a 69’ building meets the requirements
of the UDC.
Section 16.3.E.11: the location and description of all signage,
including facade signs on buildings. The applicant is proposing two
monument signs: one along Greenwood Road and one along the
undeveloped portion of Bert Kouns Industrial Loop. The site plan
indicates that both signs will be 8’ in height and 64sf in area, meeting
the requirements of the PUD and the I-1 zoning district sign
dimensional requirements. The sign details will be reviewed during
the sign permitting process. (Emphasis added).
On December 3, 2025, the MPC held a public hearing, and the
minutes reflect that several statements were given for and against the
development of the proposed data center. A representative of Shreveport
Water & Sewerage as well as Southwestern Electric Power Company
(“SWEPCO”) were present at the hearing and informed the MPC that both
companies had the capacity and ability to support the project’s needs as it
relates to supplying water and electricity and dealing with wastewater.
5
Following these statements made by community members, the MPC moved
to approve the application and site plan, but the vote tied. This tied vote was
deemed a denial of the application.
Following this denial, Bohler timely appealed the MPC’s decision to
the Shreveport City Council. A public hearing was conducted on December
18, 2025. During the course of the nearly four-hour hearing, proponents and
opponents of the data center spoke. Shreveport Water & Sewerage and
SWEPCO representatives were present at this hearing and told the City
Council that both companies had the capacity and ability to support the
project’s needs relating to water, wastewater, and electricity. Members of
the City Council also addressed those in attendance and gave their thoughts
and opinions about the proposed data center. Ultimately, the City Council
unanimously voted to reverse the MPC’s denial and approved the special use
permit and site plan.
On January 21, 2026, the plaintiffs filed a petition for judicial review
with the district court seeking a judgment reversing the City Council’s grant
of the special use permit. The petition alleged that the City of Shreveport
violated its constitutional and statutory obligations when it voted to overturn
the MPC’s denial of the special use permit. The plaintiffs urged that the
City Council: 1) failed to provide due process to the citizenry; 2) arbitrarily
overturned the MPC’s decision without an adequate record or basis; 3) failed
to require support for, consider, or properly apply the standard required by
the ordinance; 4) failed to require conditions on the approval that were
acknowledged to be necessary; and 5) failed to adequately consider
environmental impacts. The plaintiffs further alleged that Mayor Tom
6
Arceneaux and the City Council unlawfully withheld public information
from the citizens by entering into nondisclosure agreements.
In reply, the City of Shreveport filed exceptions of no right and no
cause of action and answered the petition on February 18, 2026. The trial
court held a hearing on April 20, 2026, following which it rendered
judgment affirming the City Council’s decision. According to the trial court,
the City Council did not act in an arbitrary and capricious manner. The trial
court also found moot the exceptions of no right and no cause of action since
the court had ruled on the merits of the case. The plaintiffs have appealed
from the trial court’s adverse ruling.
DISCUSSION
The plaintiffs have alleged three assignments of error. First, they urge
that the trial court erred in failing to correctly apply the standard of review
when faced with a decision by the City Council that violated its own
ordinances. Next, the plaintiffs maintain that the trial court erred in failing
to correctly apply the standard of review when faced with inadequate
support in the record for the City Council’s decision. Lastly, the plaintiffs
assert that the trial court erred in failing to apply correctly the standard of
review when faced with a decision by the City Council that violated the
Louisiana Constitution and the positive statute implementing it.
It is the plaintiffs’ position that Unified Development Code (“UDC”)
Article 16.3(E)(1) requires “[t]he design, location, and operating plans of a
special use must be such that the public health, safety, and/or welfare is
protected.” The assertion that operating plans can be “gleaned” from the
entirety of the record is insufficient, according to the plaintiffs. The
7
plaintiffs maintain that nothing in the record addressed the operation of the
data center itself.
Furthermore, the plaintiffs assert that the premise of locating the data
center in an “I-1 zone directly adjacent to a residential zone because it is
simply ‘low-intensity’ ‘warehousing’ is pure fantasy.” Although the
plaintiffs concede that the City Council had authority to impose conditions
on the approval of the special use permit and certain council members
acknowledged these “conditions” needed to be in place, it is the plaintiffs’
position that the City Council gave blanket approval without a single
condition imposed to mitigate and minimize impacts to the community.
Similarly in its failure to mitigate and minimize impacts to the community,
the plaintiffs urge that the City Council failed to adequately consider the
environmental impacts of the proposed data center. Lastly, the plaintiffs
contend that critical information was available to Bohler, the City Council,
and other decision-makers but was withheld from the public when these
decision-makers signed nondisclosure agreements. These agreements,
according to the plaintiffs, violated the Louisiana Constitution.
In response, the City of Shreveport argues that the plaintiffs have
failed to show that the City Council acted without considering the requisite
criteria and the facts and circumstances surrounding the data center project.
The City contends that the City Council was apprised of all 12 factors of
UDC Article 16.3(E) and considered them and a voluminous record in great
detail, conducted a hearing, heard from multiple proponents and opponents
of the project, and then voted unanimously to approve the special use permit
and site plan. Likewise, because the plaintiffs argue that the City Council
withheld information from the public, the City urges that this is a Public
8
Records Act claim. According to the City, the plaintiffs have cited no
authority in support of their argument that the existence of a nondisclosure
agreement invalidates a properly made legislative decision. Consequently,
the public records allegations furnish no basis to vacate the City Council’s
approval of the permit.
Article VI, § 17 of Louisiana’s Constitution explicitly grants parishes
and municipalities not only the power to adopt land use regulations, but also
the power to implement those regulations through the creation of
commissions, and the power to review the land use decisions of any such
commission. Specifically, La. Const. art. VI, § 17 provides:
Subject to uniform procedures established by law, a local
governmental subdivision may (1) adopt regulations for land use,
zoning, and historic preservation, which authority is declared to be a
public purpose; (2) create commissions and districts to implement
those regulations; (3) review decisions of any such commission; and
(4) adopt standards for use, construction, demolition, and modification
of areas and structures. Existing constitutional authority for historic
preservation commissions is retained.
Because a land use decision is an exercise of the parish or
municipality’s legislative power and function, it is not subjected to the same
standard of judicial review as a typical civil decision by a court or similar
tribunal. Jurisprudence reflects that courts have historically afforded
deference to local government land use decisions. See Toups v. City of
Shreveport, 10-1559 (La. 3/15/11), 60 So. 3d 1215; King v. Caddo Par.
Comm’n, 97-1873 (La. 10/20/98), 719 So. 2d 410; Palermo Land Co., Inc. v.
Planning Comm’n of Calcasieu Par., 561 So. 2d 482 (La. 1990).
In Palermo, supra, the Supreme Court explained in part:
Zoning is a legislative function. The authority to enact zoning
regulations flows from the police power of the various governmental
bodies. As the local governing body with final zoning authority, the
9
Police Jury of Calcasieu Parish has the authority to amend,
supplement, change, modify or repeal existing zoning ordinances.
....
A challenge to a zoning decision in Louisiana is a de novo proceeding
in which the issue is whether the result of the legislation is
arbitrary and capricious, and therefore a taking of property without
due process of law. Whether an ordinance bears the requisite
relationship to the health, safety and welfare of the public is a factual
question which must be determined from the evidence in the record.
If it appears appropriate and well-founded concerns for the public
could have been the motivation for the zoning ordinance, it will be
upheld.
The differing needs of each parish, according to its size, population,
level of industrial and commercial development, and the rapidity of
growth of such development, will naturally result in different planning
and zoning regulations in each parish. The need for change through
rezoning or reclassification will depend on the same factors, thus
rezoning decisions are properly left to those officials who are most
familiar with the needs of each community. Judicial review of
zoning decisions acts merely as a check on this legislative power
granted to parish officials to ensure that there is no abuse of the
power. Courts will not and cannot substitute their judgment for
that of the legislative authority. (Emphasis added).
Id. at 491.
Likewise, in King, supra, the Court recognized the “broad powers” to
adopt regulation for land use, zoning, and historic preservation, as well as
confirmed the arbitrary and capricious standard relative to review of land use
decisions:
Because zoning falls under the jurisdiction of the legislature, courts
will not interfere with their prerogative unless their action is palpably
erroneous and without any substantial relation to the public health,
safety or general welfare.
The terms “arbitrary and capricious action” when used in a manner
like the instant one, must mean willful and unreasoning action, absent
consideration and in disregard of the facts and circumstances of the
case. On the other hand, when there is room for two opinions, action
is not arbitrary or capricious when exercised honestly and upon due
10
consideration, even though it may be believed that an erroneous
conclusion has been reached.
The test of whether a zoning board’s action is arbitrary and capricious
is whether the action is reasonable under the circumstances. A
reviewing court does not consider whether the district court
manifestly erred in its findings, but whether the zoning board
acted arbitrarily, capriciously or with any calculated or
prejudicial lack of discretion.
King, 97-1873, p. 14-15, 719 So. 2d at 418.
Similarly, the Louisiana Supreme Court in Toups, supra, reiterated
these principles and further explained that a court may not constitute itself as
a zoning commission, or ‘super-zoning’ commission, or zoning board.
Courts have recognized it is not within the province of the appellate court to
second guess a zoning decision that appears to have been based on
appropriate and well-founded concerns for the public. Toups, 10-1559, p. 5,
60 So. 3d at 1218.
In its most recent decision relating to an appellate court’s review of
land use decisions, the Supreme Court in Alexander v. St. James Parish, 25-
0866 (La. 3/6/26), 429 So. 3d 255, determined that this arbitrary and
capricious standard of judicial review is not limited to zoning decisions. The
same standard applies to other land use decisions by a governmental entity,
as those decisions derive from the same constitutionally bestowed police
power. Id., 25-0866, p. 16, 429 So. 3d at 267; Glomax, LLC v. Lafayette
Consol. Gov’t, 24-183 (La. App. 3 Cir. 11/27/24), 403 So. 3d 32, writ
denied, 24-01587 (La. 4/8/25), 405 So. 3d 573; Garber v. City of New
Orleans Through City Planning Comm’n, 16-1298 (La. App. 4 Cir.
12/13/17), 234 So. 3d 992, writ denied sub nom. Garber v. City of New
Orleans, 18-0351 (La. 4/20/18), 240 So. 3d 924. Moreover, this standard of
11
review is applicable regardless of whether a court is reviewing the validity
of a zoning or land use regulation, or reviewing the governmental entity’s
decision after application of its regulation. Alexander, supra; Toups, supra.
Enactment, implementation, decision making, and review are all powers
constitutionally conferred to parishes and municipalities under Article VI, §
17. Alexander, supra.
A special use permit is a dispensation whereby a landowner may vary
from the strict terms of a zoning ordinance. King, supra; Gladstone Area
P’ship, Inc. v. City of Shreveport, 54,349 (La. App. 2 Cir. 4/13/22), 337 So.
3d 589. The standards for granting a SUP must ensure equal treatment for
all applicants to prevent the governing authority from exercising its power
arbitrarily. Id.
As articulated in Alexander, a court’s review in land use cases simply
examines whether the governmental entity’s administrative decision was
made within the confines of the constitutional or statutory police power and
whether the result of the decision was arbitrary or capricious. Alexander,
supra; Palermo Land Co., supra. In Palermo Land Co., supra, the Court
emphasized that the role of judicial review is to ensure there is no abuse of
the municipality’s legislative power. Id. “When the propriety of a zoning
decision is debatable, it will be upheld. It is only when an action of a zoning
commission is found on judicial review to be palpably unreasonable,
arbitrary, an abuse of discretion, or an unreasonable exercise of police power
that such action will be disturbed.” Alexander, 25-0866, p. 17-18, 429 So.
3d at 267; City of Baton Rouge/Par. of E. Baton Rouge v. Myers, 13-2011, p.
6 (La. 5/7/14), 145 So. 3d 320, 327-28.
12
The intent of the UDC is to establish land use regulations for the City
of Shreveport.3 UDC Article 4.5(A)(3) states that the purpose of the I-1
Light Industrial Zoning District is to provide for a wide variety of light
manufacturing, fabricating, processing, wholesale distributing, and
warehousing uses. Light industrial uses are enclosed, low-intensity, non-
nuisance light fabrication and assembly-type manufacturing, as well as
office and research and development facilities with little to no outside
impacts. UDC Article 5.2 indicates that the use of a data center is permitted
by right in the I-1 Light Industrial Zoning district.4 UDC Article 6.1(L)
states that all data centers shall only operate in allowable zoning districts,
and any data center located within 200 feet of a residentially zoned district
3
UDC Article 1.2 further states that the purpose of the UDC is to: (A) promote
the public health, safety, and welfare; (B) promote the orderly development of the City of
Shreveport in accordance with the Shreveport-Caddo 2030 Master Plan, hereby
referenced as “Master Plan,” and adopted land use policies; (C) divide the City of
Shreveport into zoning districts, according to use of land and structures, bulk of
structures, intensity of the use of the lot, or other classification, as deemed best suited to
carry out the purposes of this Code; (D) preserve and enhance the value of structures,
communities, and neighborhoods that constitute the distinct places within the City of
Shreveport; (E) promote economic development throughout the City of Shreveport that
balances the needs of the current and future economy with a high quality of life standard;
(F) provide for preservation, protection, and conservation of natural resources; (G)
promote the principles of sustainability, as described and defined in the Shreveport-
Caddo 2030 Master Plan; (H) maintain, develop, and plan for public facilities and utilities
in an economical and environmentally sound manner; (I) provide for the protection of
public investment in transportation, water, stormwater management systems, sewage
treatment and disposal, solid waste treatment and disposal, schools, recreation, public
facilities, open space, and other public requirements; (J) focus growth to support the
principles of smart growth by preserving open space and natural areas, reducing traffic
congestion, utilizing existing infrastructure and resources, and preserving quality of life;
(K) plan, construct, and maintain an accessible, efficient, multi-modal, transportation
system that meets the needs of the public and commerce, while minimizing risks to
health, safety and the environment; (L) provide for efficiency and economy in the process
of development; and (M) provide for the gradual elimination of nonconformities.
4
A data center is defined in UDC Article 5.3 as a facility used primarily for the
storage, management, processing, and transmission of digital data, which houses
computer and/or network equipment, systems, servers, appliances and other associated
components related to digital data operations. Such facility may also include air
handlers, power generators, water cooling and storage facilities, utility substations, and
other associated utility infrastructure to support sustained operations at a data center.
13
shall require a special use permit approved by the Metropolitan Planning
Commission.
In compliance with UDC Article 16.3, the MPC shall take formal
action on requests for special use permits. Article 16.3(E) explains that the
listing of a use as a special use within a zoning district does not constitute an
assurance or presumption that such special use will be approved. Rather,
each special use permit must be evaluated on an individual basis in relation
to all applicable standards of this Code. In considering each special use
permit application, the MPC or, on appeal, the City Council will review the
overall compatibility of the proposed special use with surrounding property
as well as such specific items, including but not limited to screening,
parking, and landscaping, to make sure that the impact of the special use is
minimal and that little or no adverse effects occur to nearby property.
The MPC or, on appeal, the City Council must consider the following
development standards and design specifications. UDC Article 16.3(E).
The approval of a special use permit is based on a balancing of these
development standards and design specifications:
1. The design, location, and operating plans must be such that the
public health, safety and/or welfare is protected.
2. The proposed special use is compatible with the general land use of
adjacent properties and other property within 300 feet.
3. The special use conforms to the regulations of the zoning district
where it will be located.
4. The location and dimensions of all public rights-of-way on or
abutting the proposed special use.
5. Existing and proposed vehicular and pedestrian circulation systems,
including streets, alleys, walkways, service areas and loading areas,
the location and arrangement of off-street parking areas and all points
of vehicular entrance and exit.
6. The outdoor surfacing and paving for all parking and loading areas.
7. The proposed perimeter treatment of the property, with indication
of screening materials to be used, including fences, walls, and plants,
14
together with a description of uses, setbacks and the relationship to
surrounding areas.
8. A landscape plan showing proposed treatment of the areas
designated as either buffers or open space.
9. The location and dimensions of all existing and proposed easements
and public improvements on the site.
10. The location and size of all structures, distances between
buildings, and distances from structures to property lines.
11. The location and description of all signage, including facade signs
on buildings.
12. The proposed use of all structures and their dimensions, i.e.,
height, floor areas, entrances, and loading areas.
In this matter, validating the imaginary harms versus the imaginary
benefits of this proposed data center is not in our purview. Rather, the
narrow issue before this Court is whether the Shreveport City Council
properly issued a special use permit to the applicant. In each assignment of
error, the plaintiffs maintain that the trial court failed to find that the City
Council acted in an arbitrary and capricious manner when it approved
Bohler’s SUP application. To support this assertion, the plaintiffs first
contend that the language of UDC Article 16.3(E)(1) is mandatory because it
explains that “the design, location, and operating plans must be such that the
public health, safety and/or welfare is protected.” Because there is no
document in the record setting forth the “operating plans” of the data center,
the plaintiffs suggest that the special use permit application should have
been denied. However, the City urges that Article 16.3(E) lists factors that
the MPC and/or the City Council must balance rather than a single factor
being determinative of an approval or a denial of an application. We agree
with the plaintiffs in that mandatory language exists in Article 16.3(E) when
it says that the MPC and the City Council must consider the following
development standards and design specifications, but find that the language
of the Code is clear that the approval of a special use permit is based on a
15
balancing of these standards and specifications. Furthermore, we agree that
the record provided to the City Council addresses general operations of the
proposed data center which allowed members of the City Council to make
an informed decision when voting to either accept or reject the SUP
application following the MPC’s denial. The City Council’s decision clearly
was not based on any one factor but rather upon a balance of the standards
and specifications set out in the UDC. This is evidenced by the extensive
record before us and the comments made by members of the City Council at
the hearing on the SUP application.
In addition to the Council members’ comments at the hearing, the City
Council heard from members of the community and individuals associated
with the proposed data center project at this hearing.5 The Council members
made it clear that all the remarks were taken into consideration when
accepting or rejecting the SUP application. Ultimately, viewing the record
in its entirety, a decision based simply on a document or lack of a document
labeled “Operating Plans” would be arbitrary given the information obtained
throughout the application and hearing processes.
Another argument raised by the plaintiffs in support of their position
is the fact that the City Council failed to impose necessary conditions on the
project, and the plaintiffs claim that this failure is arbitrary and capricious.
UDC Article 16.3(F) grants the City Council the authority to impose
conditions and restrictions upon the establishment, location, construction,
maintenance, and operation of the special use permit as may be deemed
necessary with the intent of minimizing the impact on nearby properties for
5
The recording from the City Council meeting indicates that the hearing lasted
“nearly four hours.”
16
the protection of the public health, safety, and welfare. Several Council
members admitted that conditions or guardrails should be put in place to
ensure protection for the community members and neighboring properties.
However, no one articulated what specific conditions or guardrails were
needed. The plaintiffs also have not specified what conditions or guardrails
they believe need to be in place before granting a SUP would be warranted
for the proposed project.
As indicated by the MPC staff report, the proposed data center project
adheres to the development standards and design specifications set out in the
UDC with several of the standards and specifications exceeding the
minimum requirements or obligations.6 Many opponents of the SUP
application expressed concerns about noise levels of the proposed data
center and the proximity to residential property. As indicated by the MPC
staff report, the noise generated by the proposed data center will not exceed
the noise already in existence due to the site’s proximity to the interstate and
major highway. Likewise, the building area proposed for the data center is
more than 500 feet from the nearest residential dwelling, whereas the Code
requires the special use to be compatible with the general land use of
adjacent properties within 300 feet. These factors, in addition to others
found in the record, do not support the plaintiffs’ assertions that the City
Council acted unreasonably when approving the SUP application. The trial
court clearly recognized that the City Council made this decision within the
6
Factors 1, 2, 3, and 7 listed in Article 16.3(E) are described as exceeding the
minimum requir