Lifetrans, Inc. v. State, Nev. Transp. Auth.
CourtCourt of Appeals of Nevada
Date FiledNovember 20, 2026
Docket90779-COA
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
LIFETRANS, INC., A NEVADA No. 90779-COA
CORPORATION,
Appellant,
vs.
STATE OF NEVADA, DEPARTMENT
OF BUSINESS AND INDUSTRY,
NEVADA TRANSPORTATION
AUTHORITY AND MEDICAL
TRANSPORT USA LLC, A NEVADA
LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY,
Respondents.
ORDER OF AFFIRMANCE
LifeTrans, Inc., appeals from a district court order dismissing a
petition for judicial review of an administrative decision. Eighth Judicial
District Court, Clark County; Hon. Jacob A. Reynolds, Judge.
In 2021, respondent Medical Transport USA LLC (MTC)
submitted a permit application to respondent Nevada Transportation
Authority (NTA), requesting a contract carrier permit. In 2022, LifeTrans
submitted a petition to intervene in the administrative matter, which the
NTA initially granted. However, in December 2023, the NTA issued an
order titled “Order Dismissing Intervenor and Vacating December 12,
2023[,] Hearing Application.” The order found LifeTrans did not diligently
participate in administrative discovery and failed to submit a witness list
prior to a scheduled hearing. Further, the order cited to NAC 706.3968(4),
which states the NTA shall dismiss an intervenor who has no direct or
substantial interest in the proceeding. The order then concluded that
pursuant to NAC 706.3968(4), “LifeTrans is dismissed from further
involvement in the present proceeding.”
Following this order, the NTA removed LifeTrans from the
service list for the administrative proceedings. The NTA subsequently
permitted another entity, Medlife, to intervene in the administrative
proceedings and oppose MTC’s application at an application hearing. After
the hearing, NTA approved MTC’s application.
LifeTrans subsequently filed a petition for judicial review,
challenging the order granting MTC’s application. The petition did not
challenge, or even acknowledge, the December 2023 order. Indeed, the
petition failed to mention that LifeTrans had been granted intervenor
status but had ultimately not participated in the final application hearing.
Instead, LifeTrans’ petition focused solely on whether MTC’s application
should have been granted and alleged LifeTrans had “unique knowledge”
regarding the non-emergency medical transportation industry. The
petition named the NTA and MTC but did not name Medlife.
Respondents each filed motions to dismiss, which largely
presented identical arguments. First, respondents asserted that, because
LifeTrans was dismissed as a party during the administrative proceedings,
it lacked standing to file a petition for judicial review from the order
granting MTC’s application pursuant to NRS 233B.130(1)(a). As part of this
argument, respondents noted that LifeTrans did not participate at either
the December 2024 or January 2025 application hearings nor did it appear
or participate at the January 2025 General Session Meeting where MTC’s
application was approved. And LifeTrans failed to challenge the December
2023 order. Second, respondents argued that dismissal was warranted
because LifeTrans failed to name Medlife in its petition in violation of NRS
233B.130(2)(a).
2
LifeTrans filed an opposition, which asserted the December
2023 order did not dismiss it as a party but was instead a discovery sanction
prohibiting it from further involvement. And because LifeTrans was not
dismissed, it maintained it was a party under NRS 233B.035 and NRS
233B.130, and thus, had standing to file a petition for judicial review from
the order granting MTC’s application. Further, LifeTrans reasoned that it
was not required to engage in piecemeal litigation by first challenging the
December 2023 order and instead, it was required to wait until the final
order was issued. Further, LifeTrans maintained it was entitled to amend
its petition to name Medlife because the deadline to file a petition for
judicial review did not begin to run until after service of the final order, and
the NTA failed to serve LifeTrans with the final judgment. Respondents
filed a reply, which generally repeated the above arguments and
additionally asserted dismissal was appropriate because LifeTrans failed to
file a transcript of the evidence supporting the final order. Ultimately, the
district court dismissed the petition, finding LifeTrans was not a party, and
thus, lacked standing under NRS 233B.130. Based on this determination,
the court did not address the respondents’ alternative arguments for
dismissal.
We review de novo a district court’s decision to grant a motion
to dismiss pursuant to NRCP 12(b)(5). Buzz Stew, LLC v. City of N. Las
Vegas, 124 Nev. 224, 227-28, 181 P.3d 670, 672 (2008). This court also
reviews a district court’s determination concerning subject matter
jurisdiction de novo. Ogawa v. Ogawa, 125 Nev. 660, 667, 221 P.3d 699, 704
(2007). Generally, courts do not have jurisdiction to review official decisions
of administrative agencies unless there is a statute allowing it. Washoe
County v. Otto, 128 Nev. 424, 431, 282 P.3d 719, 724 (2012). The supreme
3
court has previously explained that the filing requirements of NRS
233B.130 are “mandatory and jurisdictional,” and thus, a court lacks
jurisdiction to consider a petition that fails to comply with that statute. Id.
at 432-33, 282 P.3d at 725.
On appeal, LifeTrans attempts to demonstrate that it had
standing to petition for judicial review from the order granting MTC’s
application pursuant to NRS 233B.130(1) by arguing that the December
2023 order was merely a discovery sanction, which did not dismiss it from
the underlying proceeding as a party, but instead, prevented it from
participating in the final hearing on MTC’s application. Moreover,
LifeTrans asserts that even assuming it was dismissed, it nevertheless
could wait until a final order was issued to file a petition for judicial review
rather than engage in piecemeal litigation.
However, regardless of whether the December 2023 order
dismissed LifeTrans or was a discovery sanction, because the order
effectively prevented it from participating in the remaining administrative
proceedings concerning MTC’s application, as LifeTrans acknowledges, it
has never presented any argument before the NTA with respect to the
merits of MTC’s application. See State ex rel. State Bd. of Equalization v.
Barta, 124 Nev. 612, 621, 188 P.3d 1092, 1098 (2008) (explaining that
“judicial review of administrative decisions is limited to the record before
the administrative body” and that “a party waives an argument made for
the first time to the district court on judicial review”); see also Law Offices
of Barry Levinson, P.C. v. Milko, 124 Nev. 355, 362, 184 P.3d 378, 384 (2008)
(providing that appellate review of administrative decisions is “confined to
the record before the agency”). Under these circumstances, even assuming
that LifeTrans had standing to petition for judicial review from the order
4
granting MTC’s application, as opposed to filing a timely petition for judicial
review from the December 2023 order, LifeTrans could not proceed directly
to challenging the order granting MTC’s application.
Instead, LifeTrans was required to first demonstrate that the
December 2023 order itself was erroneous, as the NTA has insisted
throughout these proceedings, to have it vacated and the matter remanded
to the NTA for further proceedings concerning the merits of MTC’s
application with LifeTrans’ participation. Indeed, after the December
2023’s order’s entry, this was the only avenue available to LifeTrans to
present argument concerning the merits of MTC’s application in the first
instance before NTA. See State ex rel. State Bd. of Equalization, 124 Nev.
at 621, 188 P.3d at 1098; see also Law Offices of Barry Levinson, P.C., 124
Nev. at 362, 184 P.3d at 384.
But LifeTrans did not present any argument in its petition to
challenge the December 2023 order. 1 See Old Aztec, Inc. v. Brown, 97 Nev.
49, 52, 623 P.2d 981, 983 (1981) (providing that arguments not raised before
the district court are generally forfeited). And because LifeTrans
arguments concerning the merits of MTC’s application were not properly
before the district court under these circumstances, we conclude that it
failed to demonstrate the district court erred in dismissing the petition for
judicial review and affirm that decision, albeit for slightly different reasons
than those the district court relied on in dismissing the petition. Cf.
Saavedra-Sandoval v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., 126 Nev. 592, 599, 245 P.3d
1Notably, while LifeTrans suggests in its opening brief that it could
properly bundle arguments concerning the December 2023 order and the
order granting MTC’s application in its petition, it failed to do so as stated
above.
5
1198, 1202 (2010) (noting this court will affirm a district court’s order if the
right result was reached, even if for the wrong reason). 2
Accordingly, we
ORDER the judgment of the district court AFFIRMED.
Bulla, C.J.
Gibbons, J. Westbrook, J.
cc: Hon. Jacob A. Reynolds, District Judge
Paul S. Lychuk, Settlement Judge
Mushkin & Coppedge
Attorney Brent Carson, LLC
Attorney General/Carson City
Attorney General/Las Vegas
Eighth District Court Clerk
2Insofar as LifeTrans raises additional arguments, we have
considered them and conclude they do not provide a basis for relief.
6